Mafia 103 - Ktown Mafia (Game Over)

[CrueKnight]

Looking through the thread I noticed:

Scott Brosius was an odd kill choice btw. Not sure if it makes CrueKnight more likely to be scum, probably slightly does I think. Sure it's WIFOM but meh, doesn't mean it's entirely useless to speculate on.

Why is this? Why does it all point to me all of a sudden because Scott died?

Scum want to kill people who are suspicious of them, iirc he was voting you @ the end of the day.

Didn't like everybody vote for me that day? :p
If I were scum, I would kill Wicked. He has been against me probably the strongest.

Wicked also agrees that CK is probably town. But here its kind of suspicious that wicked would have a turn like that, yet his reasoning is logical. I've gotten a pretty pro-town vibe from Furry so far, yea knock it as a "gut feeling" possibly but if a pro-town seeming player defends another player as town, then I'm not going to waste my vote voting against that, when I have suspicions that the other side, namely wicked, is the scum.

I did notice this as well, when he said that, I really didn't know what to say... so he basically dropped everything he had against me and made a 360 just because I had votes on me in 20 posts?

[Sir Chris]

I would be very happy if we killed wicked today, people seem to be swirling around him instead of going after him. kunk's player slot's biggest mistake was defending wicked as I said. How about we keep our eyes on the prize and stab wicked in the face, figuratively speaking.

[Kdub]

Vote Count

CrueKnight (1)

- danakillsu

Furry (0)

-

cruelty (1)

- Wickedestjr

Sir Chris (0)

-

Rhinox (0)

-

Wickedestjr (2)

- Sir Chris, kunkstar7

kunkstar7 (3)

- Rhinox, mikeburnfire, Furry

Faraday (0)

-

SolemnJ (0)

-

danakillsu (0)

-

mikeburnfire (0)

-

cades (2)

- cruelty, Faraday

No Lynch (0)

-

Not Voting (3)

- cades, CrueKnight, SolemnJ

12 players alive, 7 votes needed to lynch.

Deadline is December 19, ~11:00 pm MST

I have added 12 hours to the deadline because I will not be available until later on Saturday.

[Rhinox]

Not Voting (3) - cades, CrueKnight, SolemnJ

I expect 2 of you to be voting right now. why aren't you?

[Sir Chris]

Rhinox why are you voting kunk and not wicked? This confuses me.

[danakillsu]

unvote vote: cades

[Wickedestjr]

Alright. This is my last day here, and I didn't have the time to catch up completely, but I'll switch my vote to a place where it serves a good purpose. In this case, I like the cades votes the best, even though cruelty is one of the people voting him:

Unvote Vote:cades

When I return it should be day 3, so I will be crossing my fingers that we vote off scum.

[CrueKnight]

Not Voting (3) - cades, CrueKnight, SolemnJ

I expect 2 of you to be voting right now. why aren't you?

I'm not really sure who I want to pin. I guess Wicked would be the one planned. But if he's town, that isn't good for me. And I can't be so sure he is scummie.

As for Cades... we could get him, but is that worth a lynch for someone we don't know anything about?

I will wait til tomorrow to vote.

kunk's player slot's biggest mistake was defending wicked as I said.

I didn't really understand "kunk's player slot's"...

[Sir Chris]

malpascp

[Rhinox]

Rhinox why are you voting kunk and not wicked? This confuses me.

I am voting kunk because of an analysis of the haylen lynch wagon - I'm sure there's at least one scum on it, and malp's jump onto the wagon seemed most scum-like.

I am not voting wicked because I'm not convinced the main point against him is a scum tell. but if it comes down to a deadline decision of wicked or no lynch, I would rather see wicked lynched. Just because I'm not convinced he's scum doesn't mean I think he's town.

[Sir Chris]

That makes a bit of sense, if I had to guess I'd think Solemn is the scum on it though. Still, wicked not being scum would throw me for a loop.

[SolemnJ]

if we lynch cades, we're just lynching a lurker who is likely to be town.
I agree that the Wicked case isnt good enough...

Hm...kunk. The person this player replaced does seem...scummy. Or at least badtown. But kunk himself seems solid.

Question:

Claim Cult Leader Day-Vig Jester Survivor.

impossible! I already have that role...

vote furry

cuz I don't wanna get touched anywhere inappropriately...

Im a role-doubler

hm?

[kunkstar7]

@SolemnJ:

Nope, unfortunately I don't have any special role, just a vanilla townie.

[SolemnJ]

Hm...I believe kunk now. Sigh.

I don't like any of these. Does that mean I should vote cades?

vote cades

I suppose lynching him is better than lynching town.

[Kdub]

Vote Count

CrueKnight (0)

-

Furry (0)

-

cruelty (0)

-

Sir Chris (0)

-

Rhinox (0)

-

Wickedestjr (2)

- Sir Chris, kunkstar7

kunkstar7 (3)

- Rhinox, mikeburnfire, Furry

Faraday (0)

-

SolemnJ (0)

-

danakillsu (0)

-

mikeburnfire (0)

-

cades (5)

- cruelty, Faraday, danakillsu, Wickedestjr, SolemnJ

No Lynch (0)

-

Not Voting (2)

- cades, CrueKnight

12 players alive, 7 votes needed to lynch.

Deadline is December 19, ~11:00 pm MST

[SolemnJ]

heck we have two days.

unvote

One sec...

[kunkstar7]

unvote vote: cades

Dana, I really don't like your voting style. No substance, no opinions, nothing, just going along with whatever happens to be the fad at the moment. Do you think it is better to vote for cades because of his noncontribution so far, or better to vote for someone suspected?

Whats your opinion of voting for noncontribution?

You have any reasons that haven't been brought up for voting anyone?

[Faraday]

@SolemnJ:

Nope, unfortunately I don't have any special role, just a vanilla townie.

?????? why did you claim.

[Faraday]

Hm...I believe kunk now. Sigh.

I don't like any of these. Does that mean I should vote cades?

vote cades

I suppose lynching him is better than lynching town.

wut. why do you believe the vanilla claim??

[Faraday]

SolemnJ are you scum?

[SolemnJ]

I have this ping in my head that determines truth from lie.

Kunk and his predecessor fit the mold of a vanilla claim.

I actually only wanted a yes/no, or a vague answer :/

I am obvnot scum.

[Sir Chris]

How about instead of just voting for the guy not posting we vote for the person who has been around and is actively scummy. That makes sense to me, thanks.

[danakillsu]

Do you think it is better to vote for cades because of his noncontribution so far, or better to vote for someone suspected?

Whats your opinion of voting for noncontribution?

You have any reasons that haven't been brought up for voting anyone?

idk, it's hard. Maybe I should let cades get replaced.

It's almost always a good thing.

No.

[CrueKnight]

@SolemnJ:

Nope, unfortunately I don't have any special role, just a vanilla townie.

Ha. Can you explain why you would RC like that???

Vote: Kunkstar

This is very suspicious to me. He may not have been acting scummy like his predecessor, but this is surely one.

You should NEVER RC unless you're forced to. If you were town, you would have just said that it wasn't your role.

SolemnJ, this didn't prove anything... he most likely re-read through mafiascp's posts and knew about the RVC.

[kunkstar7]

I can see how it seems scummy, but I was just clarifying to sJ that mal was just messing around at that point. I would understand if my role was something that could be detrimental if the scum found out, but its not, I'm just saying what it is.