Sorry to hear that, Amished. My condolences.Amished wrote:@everyone: sorry for my contribution this past week, my Grandma died last sunday night
^This.PorkchopExpress wrote:I would like Amished to answer Sotty’s question from yesterday. I’m getting some suspicious sensations from the way he kept sidestepping her request for details and don’t think the issue should be dropped just because she isn’t around anymore.
Sure. I find it very suspicious the way he came out very early in the game suggesting that there is a third party SK, at a time when only a third party would know that. He really pushed that theme, even though there was no basis for it. That, to me, suggests that either he's Mafia trying to get townies to look for a third party when there isn't one, or that he's a third party trying to paint someone else in his own role.PorkchopExpress wrote:@Jazz: Expand on Amished suspicions, please.
Then there is the fact that he has accused almost every single player in the game of being scum, despite failing to present proper cases, which is also something that a third party would want to do. So far, he's accused the following players of being scum:
Benmage (but was reluctant to vote him for some unexplained reason, and then when he finally did, he quickly unvoted Ben saying it was only because the number to lynch after Vi died would be fewer, but he never did go back to that vote)
d3x/me (because he thinks d3x is a third party on the basis of absolutely nothing)
PCE (for very weak reasons)
CA (for very weak reasons)
Vi (for very weak reasons)
Sotty (only after she became suspicious of him, and his reasons for voting Sotty ring false)
DJ (despite saying that DJ was "obv town")
VP (for very weak reasons)
Ecto (but only reluctantly, until Ecto made a case against him)
That's nine of twelve players. Excluding himself, that leaves only two players who he has not accused of being scum: pwnz and Nacho. I get a town read from Nacho, but certainly not from pwnz.
Even more suspicious is that Amished has mentioned pwnz's name only twice the entire game: the first in his opening post to random-vote pwnz, and then never again until his post 39 to say that either Nacho or pwnz should do X because they have been around much. Not a single word of suspicion, ever. Not one.
Personally, I think pwnz is very likely to be scum, and yet Amished, who has accused 9 of 12 players of being scum, has not even uttered pwnz's name beyond the foregoing. That strikes me as highly suspect.
There's also the weird posts in which he praises Ben for making a decent post, acting as though it was something spectacular when it really wasn't; and the one in which he gushes over CA, calling him his "hero" for healing Vi, even though Amished was adamant that Vi was scummy until then. It's pretty convenient for him to say
after the fact
that in between the time that he repeatedly called Vi scummy and the time that CA healed her, he had changed his read on Vi. To me, it looks like scum who got caught backing a townie killing who then had to overcompensate for it when CA unexpectedly saved Vi.There's also his repeated promises to provide information and failing to deliver.
Add it all up and it spells scum to me.
Vote: Amished
I hate to burst your bubble, hoss, but the game moderator told me that in her PM to me when she thanked me for replacing in.Amished wrote:The only way to really know that is to look at d3x's posts.
Like I said previously, this town isn't in the market for your snake oil.
Regards,
Jazz
