Newbie 873 - Game Over.

[CSL]

Say, here's what I think. You don't have to go along with it, and that's fine.

If cades is going to get replaced, I'd vote him off, because it would give the gamemod, that's Zorblag, less trouble in finding a replacement, because cades would be gone.

Also, in games that I have played, it was better to lynch someone who is posting either ridicuous stuff, or not posting at all, than to lynch someone who is ACTUALLY posting.

Posts = information = more protown than lurking

lurking = nothing from that player = antitown.

The way I'm posting, sure it's a good idea to lynch me, but I actually POST, and not cades.

tl;dr: cades is not posting, I'm posting. Games go faster if lurker is lynched, and not active person.

[Jackabomb]

Question to everyone: If CSL flipped town, who would your next scum candidate be? If he flipped scum? Same two questions for cades if CSL and crummy were convince us to lynch him instead.

[CSL]

If cades flips town, we're screwed. If he flips scum, that's one down.

If I'm lynched, you are all in ylo, and that's a no-no.

[foilist13]

@CSL - No. You are twisting the issue. Cades is no more likely to flip town than you are, so lynching him to avoid lylo is stupid. You are making this defense based on the assumption that you are town, which would be a foolish assumption for the rest of us to make. We have already established that you have acted scummier and are a better lynch.

No he isn't posting, and lynching him would make the game go faster. The problem is we have no read on him, which makes it nothing more than a probability play, which because of his lack of content is 1/7. Worse than yours. The game is not forgiving enough to lynch people because they don't post enough. That's why we have replacements. It sucks, but that's the way it is.

[CSL]

Hehehehehe...

You guys won't be responsible for my death...

unvote

Want to know why?

vote: CSL

I am out of options, and defending myself will only fuel more wagonfire. Here's your better lynch, and lylo alert.

[Jackabomb]

Jackabomb snatches the gun out of CSL's hand. He straps CSL to a rock. "Sorry, pal. I already called the killer vote. I would use the chair, but it turned out to be counterfeit. So, I'm going to stick this rock in the tar pit yonder and hope you sink quickly enough so that your screams don't wake me up tonight."

Vote: CSL

[CSL]

Actually, Jack, I already summoned a huge rock to squish the shit out of me. lol

[CSL]

EBWOP: It's going to squish you, unless you get out of the way.

Cades is a lynch target tomorrow. He needs to get his ass here. I am looking forward to seeing his scummy ass die a thousand deaths.

[Jackabomb]

You can't summon any rocks. You're stuck in a tar pit! I did in fact, call hammer vote earlier.

[CSL]

Too late, I hammered myself. You should've taken the chance, and hammered me earlier, but you lost it. Too bad. Maybe you can be thehammer on a town loss, or preservation. Your choice.

[Jackabomb]

So? It's still a hammer, it's just not the first hammer.

If trying to lynch mafia is this dangerous, we should have just paid that stupid swimming pool debt.

[CSL]

Yeah. lol

[Jackabomb]

Don't you think quickhammering like that is scummy? You'll probably be voted tomorrow. If you still want to help the town, tell us how cades is so guilty if you're town.

[CSL]

Not giving reasonable responses. Trying to hide from us. Only posting when he is under pressure. Why do you not see this?

[Zorblag]

Vote count 2.5

The numbers by the voters indicate the order in which the vote was cast. If two or more players are tied for the most votes to lynch at the deadline the tiebreaker will be the player who has the earliest active vote.

CSL: 3: MichelSableheart (2), cades (3), foilist13 (5), CSL (7)
cades: 1: Crimmy (6)

Not Voting: dimaba, Jackabomb

With 7 alive it takes 4 to lynch.

CSL, townie

is lynched day two.

It is now night two. Deadline for submitting night actions is 11:00 PM EST/8:00 PM PST on Friday, December 18th.

Mod Note: As cades was being prodded when the day ended I will confirm in thread when he replies to the prod via PM. If he doesn't pick up his prod then he will be replaced before the night ends and the night will go till 24 hours past when his replacement is named.

-Zorblag R`Lyeh

[Zorblag]

Mod Note: cades has not picked up his prod. I'm looking for a replacement now.

-Zorblag R`Lyeh

[Zorblag]

Mod Note: Kyiv replaces cades as of now. Night will now end at 5:00 PM EST/2:00 PM PST on Saturday, December 19th.

Thanks for replacing, Kyiv!

-Zorblag R`Lyeh

[Zorblag]

Night Two had now ended.

MichelSableheart, townie

is killed night two.

It is now Day Three.

Vote Count 3.0

The numbers by the voters indicate the order in which the vote was cast. If two or more players are tied for the most votes to lynch at the deadline the tiebreaker will be the player who has the earliest active vote.

Not Voting: Crimmy, dimaba, foilist13, Jackabomb, Kyiv

With 5 alive it takes 3 to lynch. Currently no one would be lynched at deadline. Deadline is 5:00 PM EST/2:00 PM PST on Saturday, January 9th, 2010.

-Zorblag R`Lyeh

[Crimmy]

I hate to make posts like this, but I told you all to retreat your votes until we were sure.
(And I said that many times, too.)

Also, I'm really suspecting on ex-cades now. Meaning Kyiv.

[Jackabomb]

In case anyone says that it's unfair to use arguments against a replacement, the only difference is that the replacement has a hard time defending themselves. The same arguments apply.

If you'd like to know cades posted only a few times. First, "I told you so. Jack and CSL are scum". Second, he voted CSL, giving his signature ATE. Third, brief explanation of his vote which didn't tell us anything new.

Total lurking to the point of replacement. Look, he shows up and dissappears. Crimmy, there really isn't anyone to blame for yesterday. CSL suicided.

[foilist13]

@Kyiv - You have replaced the super lurker from hell. Congratulations.

What we need from you now, is for you to read the whole thread, then post a short player analysis of everyone who is still alive. Tell us what you think about them, and why. Who do you think is scummy, and who do you think is town?

I would hate to be in your position, and I will do my best to keep you alive until you've been able to establish a coherent position distinct from that of Cades, as I think that is only fair.

Actually, I think that everyone should post a scum list. Sadly I don't have the time to follow my own advice right now, but I will reread and do so as soon as possible.

[Jackabomb]

I have a pretty big scum read on cades for obvious reasons *snicker*. I have town reads on crimmy and foilist, leaving dimaba as the last possible scum, though he's done a grand job of blending in. Crimmy has a tendency to err on the side of caution, but that is better than being reckless. Foilist has been generally helpful to everyone. He's been pretty active and seems to scum-hunt hard, even though it hasn't been too successful.

[Crimmy]

Well, all I can say, right now, is that I know what precise game style we're using.
It's the F11 with the Mafia roleblocker.

[Jackabomb]

We've known it was F11. That's the standard for all newbie games.

[Jackabomb]

Crimmy, who are your scum suspects?