Mini 884 - Last Man Standing (Over)

[PorkchopExpress]

It looks solid, and works to maximise the potential of town correcting any errors in judgement it makes. (We try to preserve as many guns as possible, to make sure that any audacious LYLO move by scum would be fatal). I'd adopt it if people really aren't convinced on the me/Amished divide one way or the other. Have you made anything more of the 3rd party chatter?

It seems to me that Amished revealed a scummy underside to his 'pro-town' endgame play in his latest behaviour.

I'd like to know what Pwnz thinks at this stage.

[VP Baltar]

Unvote

Yeah, I'll wait and hear from others, but to me it just seemed like Amished's plan basically maximizes his own chances of being around tomorrow (hence why my vote landed there).

[pwnz]

I have no problem with following the majority to a win. If we follow VP's plan, it appears to me that our margin for loss is extremely slim. *hic

[Amished]

@PCE: Vote me then. I'm trying to make sure that I'm not wrong that it's between us. I obviously don't know what hohum had in mind exactly when he made the setup; a sk-cop mason would be extremely imbalanced. You can't deny that I've had suspicions of VP for a long time. When he made what I thought to be a lazy play without justification or thought about if he was wrong/useless before; I thought it was bad town or scum. I also think that having two cops is pretty imbalanced, especially with a healer, but that's not up to me and up to the mod depending on information I don't have and can't really garner right now as it's information that I can't really 100% trust.

I've been talking basically to myself trying to find a way to minimize errors. It's like Golf: you shoot for the hole, but if you miss, you wanna make a small miss so it doesn't really hurt you.

I want any solution that we come up with. The only problem that I see with a NL is that if I'm wrong and PCE isn't scum; with the NK we're left with 4; and PCE/me cross shooting would lose the game instantly. If we could all coordinate; and pwnz lives I think there's a way to shoot in a circle and vote/lynch for the last person while dying/wounded to make sure he's alive; that might work too. I have no idea how wounding and night interacts; and we have no way to test that either.

But, don't get mad at me when the plan is to lynch me and then we have no plan; cause I know that lynching me will not end the game.

[VP Baltar]

I want any solution that we come up with. The only problem that I see with a NL is that if I'm wrong and PCE isn't scum; with the NK we're left with 4; and PCE/me cross shooting would lose the game instantly.

No it doesn't. If Cobalt protects me tonight, I'll still be around to shoot the other person tomorrow and auto win. I realize you have some trepidation about me being town, but seriously this would be an epic gambit beyond the realm of my feeble mind to claim mason-cop-strong shot if I was actually scum. The proof is there in the thread from my interaction with Sotty.

[Amished]

And if Cobalt protects you {VP}; then pwnz (our admitted most powerful night action at this point) is free to be killed.

[VP Baltar]

Yes, but I have a gun and pwnz claims to not have a gun....so the beauty is that Cobalt can WIFOM the scum on the kill and either way we will have an acceptable course to pursue tomorrow (either my shot or pwnz's track) that will likely lead us to the win.

[pwnz]

I think that cobalt (our healer) should decide who he wants to protect himself rather than predetermining that course of action... just my opinion. *hic

[VP Baltar]

Yep. Let's not waste anymore time with this debate and just win this game.

Vote: No Lynch

[Cobalt]

unvote vote no lynch

I like this plan.

[Amished]

Unvote
Vote: No Lynch

[zoraster]

Christmas Vote Count:

PorkchopExpress (L-2) ~ Cobalt

No Lynch:

VP Baltar, Cobalt, Amished

Not Voting:

PorkchopExpress, pwnz [/color]
[size=0]Ami 0 | Cobalt -1 | PExpress 0 | pwnz 0 | VPB 0[/size]
--With 5 alive, it takes 3 to lynch.
--Deadline is Saturday, January 2 2010.

----CONSIDER THIS THREAD LOCKED. THERE WAS NO LYNCH TONIGHT.----
Any player posting after this time will be in biggggg trouble.

[zoraster]

[color]PS. Send your night actions to both Vi and Me. I think Vi will be back before night is over, but just in case, I'll stay up on it.[/color]

[Vi]

I'm back. Thank you, zor!

Ah, Night ends at 2100 EST this Tuesday, the 29th.

[Vi]

That Night, Cobalt's lifesaving activities were ended as he was subjected to the worst punishment imaginable. He woke up bound and gagged in the saloon's back room, clearly able to see a candle plugged into a barrel of TNT. Worst of all, a phonograph was playing old-style country music right next to his ear.

The remaining Townsfolk (and others) gathered around the remains of the watering hole and went about what had become their usual business.

--- Cobalt ---

Town Doctor

--- Gone Country Night 3...

----

Vote Count:

Not Voting:

Amished, PorkchopExpress, pwnz, VP Baltar

-It is now Day 3! Everyone has been prodded.

--With 4 alive, it takes 3 to lynch.
--Deadline is Tuesday, January 19 2010.

[Cobalt]

Don't believe in yourselves. Believe in me, who believes in you.

[VP Baltar]

Thanks for the easy win scum. Amished and PE, shoot each other now for pwnz and my entertainment!


Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it!

[PorkchopExpress]

So, no guilty result last night VP? Be prepared to shoot Pwnz if this all goes tits up.

Shoot: Amished.

[Vi]

Amished is

Wounded

and has

72 hours

to live!

[PorkchopExpress]

Told you I was a weak shooter.

[Amished]

This is way too easy... I'll be around tomorrow to shoot PCE like I promised.

@pwnz, what was your result?

It still seems like VP is setting us all up...

[Amished]

VP: Is pwnz 100% confirmed town *to you*?

[Amished]

Also, what was your investigation result last night?

What i'm thinking is if we can all trust pwnz, I shoot VP and VP shoots PCE.

That way *only* if pwnz is scum we lose, right?

[VP Baltar]

I investigated Cobalt last night to be certain. Got an innocent result, which means I'm sane and PE is town.

That leaves Amished and pwnz as potential scum. Of course, Amished not following the plan pretty much indicates to me that he's scum in his last ditch effort at something (I don't know what he hopes to accomplish).

I suggest he shoots pwnz now since I know for sure that PE is innocent.

VP: Is pwnz 100% confirmed town *to you*?

I would say I'm 99% sure he's town.

[PorkchopExpress]

Once again, I'd like to hear from Pwnz. The only way VP works as scum is if he was unconfirmed mason with Sotty, judging from the play between the two of them on Day 1. This doesn't strike me as likely.