Open 189~Trouble@Warren State Mental Hosp (Over)

[Porochaz]

meh got to man up.

unvote

[VP Baltar]

Are you drinking atm?

[Porochaz]

I wish I was. Im really not in a good place atm, so Im sorry. I have decided to take it to facebook and ms etc. the less said about the last couple of posts the better. Look I know your case on JDodge, I know why your voting him etc. however I disagree with voting him simply because I have seen him play this way before as town and whats more I believe there are better options like to vote and re

vote Cayke

. (balance restored) I stated why a while back. In my view there are better options than jdodge and that is not going to change.

[Vi]

In my view there are better options than jdodge and that is not going to change.

What do you think of the delinquent tajo's rationale for Cayke not being scum?

[Porochaz]

Tajos point rests on caykes ability, which I find tenuous at best. Especially from someone who is not bringing his best game to the table. (neither is anyone else Ive played with before including myself for that matter)

[Xdaamno]

Poro, I feel for you man, but that's the first time I've seen the 'mentally unstable' defence used in a game of mafia, lol.

What we really need is for Hyl/Cat/Qooq/Izzy to weigh in here.

Requesting prods for those 4 people

[DizzyIzzyB13]

I'm voting for scum, what more do you want from me?

[VP Baltar]

As far as I'm concerned, about half of this game needs to be replaced since they haven't posted in about a week. I'm sure our

mod

could handle such a task.

[tubby216]

Poro, I feel for you man, but that's the first time I've seen the 'mentally unstable' defence used in a game of mafia, lol.

What we really need is for Hyl/Cat/Qooq/Izzy to weigh in here.

Requesting prods for those 4 people

**********************************

working on prod's replacements today,

My appologies it has been very busy around here.

[Vi]

I'm voting for scum, what more do you want from me?

Convincing us why VP Baltar is scum and the alternatives being passed around are not.

Tajos point rests on caykes ability, which I find tenuous at best.

I disagree; those kinds of tells are rather effective if plied properly.

[Porochaz]

Meh Im not saying I mentally unstable just had a bad night thats all and decided the best place to vent my anger was on the interwebs, also daamo Im not really defending myself, I dont really have anything to defend against. I am done in regards to my opinion. I think jdodge is town, mostly due to gut or the case against him . I think Cayke is scum, Ive given general reasons for that but am willing to look at anyone elses case.

[VP Baltar]

Prozac, could you at least link to the JD meta you are going off of. Vi has linked a scum meta for him w/ respect to similar play here. Providing a town game where he played like this would at least make his playstyle null.

What do you think of him not posting in the thread for so long now that he has been called out as scum?

[Porochaz]

http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=10162

and

http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 54&start=0

[VP Baltar]

much obliged.

[Vi]

http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=10162

and

http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 54&start=0

I disagree with the first one resembling his play in this game, but the second one is similar enough that I understand why you're holding on to a meta connection (though I still disagree).

But thank you for providing the links ^.^

[VP Baltar]

Hey Howard, how's that Xdaamno vote treating you? Still happy with that wagon?

[tubby216]

****************vote count****************

xdaamno

~ (3)L-4,crywolfi,Howard Roark,cat

VP Balter

~(2) L-5, Hyl,Izzy

crywolf(cayke)

~(2) L-5 ,Jdodge,porochaz

Howard Roark

~(3) L-4,populartajo,Vi,xdaamno

JDodge

~(2) L-5, VP balter,Vi

not voting

Qooq,

looking for a replacement for qooq, also hyl has 24 hours to reply to prod

with 12 alive 7 votes to lynch

deadline 14 days remaining

[Cat]

Sorry, holiday weekend was unpredictably extended by predictable power outage.

Will post ASAP.

[populartajo]

baltar and vi, i dont understand what is the case against dodge?

i blame the game dying to the scumchatters, get out of aim and come play.

[Vi]

still waiting on what you have to say in response to my posts vivivivivivi <3

whywhywhywhyYwhy me in particular ^_____^

Because you saidsaidsaidsaidsaid you were waiting for the rest of my posts (>^_^)>

oh ok

I think your posts are garbage all the way down, but wanted to see what else you were going to do before saying anything.

***********************************************

prods sent out to
(...)
Jdodge

oh hey it's someone who has been posting onsite and just happens to be scumposting ITT

reminds me of a certain other game where jdodge was scum, so there's precedent for this sort of behavior

All better than JDodge who has given cases and content which generally given off a town vibe and as far as I can see there is not much of a case against him.

Neither cases nor content really. More like slinging whatever he can find at people in hopes of something sticking.

And how is that worse than those mentioned.

Acting scummy and then deciding not to play the game is worse than acting vaguely and then deciding not to play the game.

Hence voting cayke. And where is jdodge saying he is not playing the game.

He doesn't have to; he just has to post elsewhere onsite while telling us he's going to post shortly before not posting again.

There is virtually no chance that JDodge is Town in this setup based on his posts combined with his lurking (emphasis more on his posts).

[JDodge]

is playing to his town meta.

If this is the case, then why was I able to link to a game in which JDodge was scum and was playing more or less

just like this

?

[VP Baltar]

I think I listed why I think JD is scum pretty succinctly here and here.

Basically, disappearing once he was called out for his lack of content is reason enough for me to lynch him and move this damn game forward.

[populartajo]

So basically is a case of not posting after being accused of lack of content.

Why not assume boredom?

vi, can I get an example of any scummy post? baltar, same question.

[VP Baltar]

ALL OF HIS POSTS. Just click the iso tab.

It's not a case of being bored because he's posted plenty elsewhere on the site. Also, he had plenty of specific things to respond to after I replied to him. It's not like he wasn't being engaged and simply had no comment.

[populartajo]

yep, i just isolated him, i just cant get the same feeling you seem to get from his posts.

thats why im asking for a concrete example.

[VP Baltar]

His larger posts are especially devoid of actual content, imo.