Mini 904 - Narnia: LWW Mafia (Game Over)

[Heilograph]

I guess somtimes you have to hop on a wagon to get the game moving..

[Starbuck]

Why not bring some of your own opinions to the table instead of following the crowd?

[Kdub]

Vote Count

Starbuck (6)

- dybeck, Papa Zito, kikuchiyo, wolframnhart, Riceballtail, Heilograph

Riceballtail (0)

-

bv310 (1)

- MadCrawdad

MadCrawdad (0)

-

kikuchiyo (0)

-

Heilograph (0)

-

Papa Zito (1)

- Sibelius

wolframnhart (0)

-

Grandi (0)

-

manho (0)

-

dybeck (1)

- Starbuck

Sibelius (0)

-

No Lynch (0)

-

Not Voting (3)

- bv310, manho, Grandi

12 votes available, 7 votes needed to lynch.

Deadline is January 26, ~ 12:30 am MST.

[Sibelius]

Heilograph, that was an interesting move on your part. Jumping onto a bandwagon and putting Starbuck at L-1...it seems kind of opportunistic. Why did you decide to change your vote?

[Starbuck]

Rumblebuffin

[Sibelius]

I should clarify--I'm not suspicious because Heilograph jumped onto the wagon, I'm suspicious because of how he did it.

[bv310]

Rumblebuffin

Are you really trying to claim the most obscure Giant in Narnia as your role? (Yes, I looked it up)

[Starbuck]

I do not claim until L-1.

L-1 is here. I have claimed who I am.

[wolframnhart]

unvote

I need to think about this one....

[wolframnhart]

Rumblebuffin

Are you really trying to claim the most obscure Giant in Narnia as your role? (Yes, I looked it up)

Bv310 why do you believe Rumblebuffin is "the most obscure Giant in Narnia"?

According to wiki "

Rumblebuffin was a member of the Buffin giant family: one of the most respected of all the giant families in the Kingdom of Narnia as mentioned by Mr. Tumnus. He was turned to stone by the White Witch, but was eventually restored to life by Aslan (with Rumblebuffin stating that he must've fallen asleep) during the ransacking of the Witch's fortress. After being asked his name by Aslan and being asked to let everyone out, he used his club to open the door for Aslan and the freed creatures to get out. He participated in the First Battle of Beruna where he uses his club on some of the soldiers in the White Witch's Army (and also stepped on some of them).

"

That's not an obscure Giant, that is a respected member of a giant family well known in Narnia. Odd for you to jab Starbuck like that with no vote being placed anywhere.

[Starbuck]

I play theme games because I know the material. I honestly can't stand those who try to act like they know it all when they admittedly just read the wiki.

/sigh

[wolframnhart]

Bv310 I have a question for you.

You hace only voted once, during RVS against Manho. You have said a couple times that you find PZ and Starbuck scummy, yet have not tried to vote either or push a case against either. Why?

[bv310]

Maybe I exaggerated a bit with "the most obscure", but I somewhat doubt that a Giant who plays such a minor role in the book would be included as a character in a 12 person mafia game. I'd expect things like Peter, Lucy, Tumnus, maybe Mr and Mrs Beaver, but not Rumblebuffin. (Note: I haven't read the book in a little while. May be time to bust out the collection)

As for the voting, I haven't voted because I was waiting for a real case to be made. As it is, the case against Starbuck is pretty good, but I think there's a good chance that she's actually just a very lazy townie.

[wolframnhart]

you are "waiting" for a case to be made and you are calling Starbuck a lazy townie?

[wolframnhart]

Also as far as the characters go, that is trying to out guess the mod and who he feels he wants in the game.

[Sibelius]

Also as far as the characters go, that is trying to out guess the mod and who he feels he wants in the game.

QFT.

As for the voting, I haven't voted because I was waiting for a real case to be made.

Way to make it clear for all of us that you're not going to scumhunt. Alright, here's something for you.

Papa Zito: Maybe he just naturally has a snarky playstyle, but the snark and his pursuing of the (flimsy) case against Starbuck make him scummy to me. I think he's the vote for the day, but everyone's too busy being persuaded against Starbuck to think.

You: Lurking in plain sight as far as I can tell, and this last post of yours. It's rather non-committal, and as I said above, you're basically admitting to waiting for a viable case against someone to pop up so you can jump in. That's pretty scummy.

As it is, the case against Starbuck is pretty good, but I think there's a good chance that she's actually just a very lazy townie.

A case that rests on a less-than-significant action and a choice of words that might be questionable is a good case?

[dybeck]

Rumblebuffin

Rumblebuffin! Wicked... we found a scum Day 1!

And they don't have safe claims! Awesome!

This is going to be a piece of cake!

[Starbuck]

Lurking in plain sight as far as I can tell, and this last post of yours. It's rather non-committal, and as I said above, you're basically admitting to waiting for a viable case against someone to pop up so you can jump in. That's pretty scummy.

And the basis behind all the votes on me are because I have been "active lurking".


People need to quit tunneling and take a good look around because I am not the scum you are looking for.

[Starbuck]

Rumblebuffin

Rumblebuffin! Wicked... we found a scum Day 1!

And they don't have safe claims! Awesome!

This is going to be a piece of cake!

My guess is that you never have read the books or read them ages ago?

[dybeck]

Rumblebuffin

Rumblebuffin! Wicked... we found a scum Day 1!

And they don't have safe claims! Awesome!

This is going to be a piece of cake!

My guess is that you never have read the books or read them ages ago?

Far from it. I know 'the Lion the Witch and the Wardrobe' like an old friend. I read it first when I was six years old and then over and over. I must have read that book a dozen times or more.

Everyone else - we're looking at no more than a town of nine people here. Beyond a shadow of a doubt we have Peter, Lucy and Susan Pevensie. No mod would omit Aslan. No mod would omit Tumnus, and we have Mr. and Mrs. Beaver.

The remaining two will be some permutation of Professor Kirke, Father Christmas and Edmund Pevensie.

Not freaking Rumblebuffin. Let's lynch this phoney already.

[Heilograph]

Heilograph, that was an interesting move on your part. Jumping onto a bandwagon and putting Starbuck at L-1...it seems kind of opportunistic. Why did you decide to change your vote?

Well to start off the game is moving here at snail pace. I decided that one way to get somwhere is to put at l-1 and than let the others argue back and forth , while I go back a few pages and try to get better reads on people.

[kikuchiyo]

I see no reason not to lynch Starbuck. The claim is what it is and I am not going to try and outguess the mod. I don't agree with everything Dybeck has stated, but I certainly see nothing in Starbuck's posts or claim to stop this lynch.

Anyone else against the Star lynch needs to speak up and explain why.

I find it interesting that when in trouble Starbuck points to Sibelius, and now Sibelius defends Starbuck. Bv310 is also a person of interest. I think we have enough information for a day 1 lynch. That doesn't mean we need a hammer in two or three posts, but this wagon should not be derailed except under extreme circumstances of which the likelihood is slim.

[wolframnhart]

I believe Starbucks' claim. Again I am not going to try and out guess the mod on which characters he put in the game, but her role makes sense to me. Bv310 is definitely someone of interest to me though due to his past few posts ,and I would rather the day not end until he at least tries to make a case against either PZ or Starbuck if those are still his top two suspects, and in his own words not a rehash.

[kikuchiyo]

Wolf: A vanilla claim should not stop a lynch. There is no reason for you to have been on the wagon in the first place if you were going to back off a vanilla claim. The reason for claiming before lynch(especially on day 1) is to help town avoid hitting a power role. Your unvote due to claim is noted. Saying "her role makes sense to me," is a giant cop out. So basically, anyone getting lynched can search the wiki for a name and you will believe them? Does not compute. I agree, however, in further discussion so converse away.

[dybeck]

Wolfram: is there a claim that would have sounded phoney to you?