Newbie 893 - Newbieland! (GAME OVER)

[RayFrost]

MME, if you see nothing notable, do you mean "notably scummy" or notable in general?

[My Milked Eek]

I only write down notable scummy things and notable protown things acted out by people I have notable scummy things on.

[SaintKerrigan]

I've completed a basic skim-through, unfortunately my more in-depth read is going to take a little longer because of a situation in one of my ongoing games.

In the meantime:

Unvote: My Milked Eek

because I forgot to unvote in my first post, and I'm not sure yet whether that slot is scummy or not.

[Nikanor]

Okay, I'm actually going to strap myself down and force myself to read Abel's posts now.
*Waves at MME*
*Waves at SK*

@Mod: Can you please say who replaced whom in the player list?

[My Milked Eek]

Hi Nikanor!

It's been some time as well.


Making the final pages post right now.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but a hammer is defined as the L-0 vote. I did not show intent to hammer, I said I would have been willing to L-1 because I think Pom is that suspicious. NOT HAMMER. If I'd had intent to lynch Pom right then and there, I would have. I didn't. Once more, very loaded words. Watch your tongue.

I must have still been sleepy while replying to this, but there's something in here that seems off. Let me get things straight.
1) you had an intent to put Pome at L-1
2) you posted about this when pome was at L-1
3) you had no intent to hammer

Let's recap a bit further. About your suspicions. I'm not sure if I posted that part in that big post, but my notes say:

[#139] TS : Intent to hammer Pome w/ no real previous suspicion [of pome]

Even if you replace "hammer" with "L-1" it still sounds off:

[#139] TS : Intent to put Pome at L-1 w/ no real previous suspicion [of pome]

Add to that that I have noted on a few occasions that you have nothing valuable concerning opinions about anyone, except when talking about pome:

[#073] : TS @ RF "You're villifying Pome" + "...not wish to contribute to the lynching of an

innocent

..."

Sure, might be pulled out of context, but let me add the context:
[#063] RF Votes Pome (II)
[#070] TS Votes RF (II)
And then the #073.

A few questions arise:
1) What happened between #073 and #139 that made you go from innocent to putting pome at L-1?

Ok I had more, but I got distracted and forgot them.

And my tongue's fine, thank you.

More in a few.

[My Milked Eek]

I'm rereading the final pages, going to answer some posts directed at Vap/me:

>> Riza's

Cr

Vap Case

The explanation below will be a sum up of other posts I've made about Vapor.

Like I said, Vapor keeps on voting/unvoting for people with little to no reasoning. It's suspicious.

Is it really? And you're absolutely sure it doesn't fit in with him being a VI?

When he first voted for Pom, he said it was because Frost was of more assistance. Both he and Frost posted little between his vote for Pom and Frost. Therefore, I don't understand how Vapor thinks Frost was of more assistance.

Because Frost was, reread the thread, please. For real. And rewrite this quote, I can't understand it properly.

Wow, that sounds pretty muddled to me. Sorry. e_e Anyway, that's pretty much what lead me to vote for him.

Are you sure you're not forgetting to lie? The only reasons I see for your vote on Vap are:
1) he's an incredibly easy target (you explain this yourself later on)
2) others were already dogpiling onto him, I'm still in doubt about your FoS on Vap after Jarc did so (cf. previous big post)

But what makes me keep my vote is because he unvotes a post later, maybe because he caught quite a bit of negative attention?

Newbie player. VI. Make your pick. Seriously.

And then votes for me, for a bad reason, which can be directed toward him as well.

Bad play does not make a scum. But carry on.

He doesn't even defend himself, even when he's in L-2.

And this is indicative of any alignment in what way? If you're serious about this and I know you're not (you're only dogpiling and finding easy targets), explain it.

Page 8

- not much here lol, don't like Riza's attack on vap, it's really inane.

Page 9

- Riza builds crap case and builds up scumminess. Eggs on Vap and tries not to appear doing so (#213)
- TS excludes Riza from his mini-LoS (Line of Sight)

Page 10

- Riza's #238 contradicts itself, "Vap is newbie scum acting to be a VI". I don't think newbie scum is capable of doing that on purpose.

Page 11

- Pome Votes Riza for good reasons

My conclusions

Riza is scum.
TS is most likely scum.

[My Milked Eek]

I just checked and this should be the third vote on Riza.

Vote: Riza

[xRECKONERx]

D1 Vote Count #9

Pomegranate (2): Honest Abel, chauchaudotcom
Riza (3): RayFrost, Pomegranate, My Milked Eek
My Milked Eek (1): Riza
RayFrost (1): Nikanor

Not Voting (2): ThetaSigma, SaintKerrigan

Deadline: January 29, 2010 at 2:00PM EST

Nikanor just narrowly avoided a prod. I've tried updating the main post at least four times now, and it always freezes up on me. So for quick reference:
SaintKerrigan (replaced JarcLovesCinn D1)
Nikanor (replaced Hetemens D1)
My Milked Eek (replaced Vaporeonage D1)

[Pomegranate]

-MME

I feel that the fact that I acknowledged the reasons you gave as to why you didn't like my case before you stated them, and I voted Riza. I like your play.

-Nikanor

Could you actually do something useful?

[Nikanor]

Give me a break, Pom. Weekends are hard. I had a nine hour shift at work yesterday and I have an eight hour shift today. After work I'm going to dedicate myself to catching up, though.

[My Milked Eek]

It's hypocritical of you to criticize RayFrost for him not posting from a Sunday until a Friday when you've posted nothing of value from last week's Friday up until today, Sunday.

[Nikanor]

I accused him of active lurking, not regular lurking. There's a big difference.
Active lurking is posting nothing of content while trying to appear not to be lurking.
Regular lurking is simply not posting, and in my case, can be attributed to a recent lack of time.

[xRECKONERx]

Honest Abel has requested replacement.

Gayle replaces Abel.

[Gayle]

A newbie game with no newbies. What has happened here?

I apparently have 280+ posts to read. BRB.

[My Milked Eek]

We wanted to play some F11...

[xRECKONERx]

ThetaSigma and Riza are the only 'official' newbies left

[Gayle]

All caught up. Neglected taking notes as if it was homework. Keeping my vote where it is, though I will examine riza and her bandwagon in a bit. I'm always here, got no friends.

[Pomegranate]

I'll be your friend! Do you like skipping? [/highpitchedvoice]

[Gayle]

I'll be your friend! Do you like skipping?

Unfortunately, I've been informed that if I keep skipping I'll be dismissed from class. We can still be friends though if you summarize for me the case on Riza. That way I can continue to laze about.

[My Milked Eek]

Read the last two pages. Might be three.
Posts of Pome and myself contain bits and pieces of the general case.

[Pomegranate]

^^ Yes, this. If you can't skip, at least you can read.

[Gayle]

^^ Yes, this. If you can't skip, at least you can read.

Clearly, my friendship is worthless to you.


That said, I don't agree with the case on Riza. Gonna keep my vote right where it us.

[Pomegranate]

^^ Yes, this. If you can't skip, at least you can read.

Clearly, my friendship is worthless to you.


That said, I don't agree with the case on Riza. Gonna keep my vote right where it us.

That means we're not friends?



Why don't you agree with the case?

[My Milked Eek]

Yeah, what doesn't fit according to you?

[Gayle]

Why don't you agree with the case?

Rather than reading a case scattered across several posts, I just iso'd Riza, and I didn't find her particularly scummy.