Newbie 848 - The Bunny Mafia Family - over finally!

[Haylen]

I think we should no lynch today. Hit wrong and we lose. At least we have a night kill to give us more info.

Argh. My instinct is telling me it's Neto but logic is telling me it's either VRK or Charter. This is NOT fair.

[Vel-Rahn Koon]

I think we should no lynch today. Hit wrong and we lose.

At least we have a night kill to give us more info.

Argh. My instinct is telling me it's Neto but logic is telling me it's either VRK or Charter. This is NOT fair.

And your guarantee that the scum won't No Kill is.....???

[Incognito]

Vote Count #1 of Day 6

charter (1) <-~ Netopalis

Not voting (3) <-~ charter, Haylen, Vel-Rahn Koon

With 4 alive, 3 votes will do it.

Thursday, February 11th at 8 P.M. EST.

[Haylen]

I think we should no lynch today. Hit wrong and we lose.

At least we have a night kill to give us more info.

Argh. My instinct is telling me it's Neto but logic is telling me it's either VRK or Charter. This is NOT fair.

And your guarantee that the scum won't No Kill is.....???

I can't guarantee anything scum will do. But I do know that we've got another two goes before it's a draw again. And I don't want a draw. I'm gonna go meta Charter now. I don't give a flying rats ass if metaing is inappropriate in newbie games.

[Netopalis]

Ironically enough, all the players remaining are either IC or SE. I really don't think that this fits the standard definition of what is right and wrong to do in a newbie game.

[Haylen]

Yeah, the last newbie game that this happened in, I was given the deciding vote and somehow managed to hit scum. Based on instinct. Again.

[Netopalis]

Regardless, I think that the case on Charter is pretty obvious.

SK/Me doesn't make sense, given that I was attacking SK pretty heavily out of the gate.

SK/VRK doesn't make sense, given that SK needlessly attacked VRK early, when he could have attacked Haylen

SK/Haylen works a bit, but I don't think it really fits all that well.

SK/Charter, on the other hand, fits brilliantly. The two suspected the same people, but almost never referenced each other by name, which is a method of formal distancing. It's quite clear to me, from their posts and interactions, that they were playing off of each other.

[Incognito]

Looks like this needs a bump.

[Haylen]

I really want to vote Charter cause I'm sure he's scum. But then I'm worried that VRK will be the real scum and hammer. Or that I haven't listened to my instincts as I should have done all game and voted for Net...

[Haylen]

Vote No Lynch

Solves that problem.
I want it narrowed down for tomorrow, it will make the scum seeing easier. And it's not really logical, why lynch and maybe lose with little info when we can no lynch, have a kill and have info from the kill not to mention 2 players to choose from.

[Haylen]

Everyone else are lurkers.

[charter]

vote no lynch

Been too busy to reread.

Neto, I really don't think your vote is good. Yesterday, you were agreeing with my points, but in the end didn't vote for Haylen. It seems kind of hypocritical. Almost like you were setting yourself up to switch to Haylen if another townie voted her.

[Netopalis]

Yes, I was somewhat swayed. The problem is, there were two potential scumteams yesterday - You and SK vs. Haylen and Nacho. Now that we know that SK is scum and Nacho is town, it doesn't make a lot of sense for anyone but you to be the scum.

[Haylen]

Mod, please probe VRK

[Incognito]

He hasn't reached 72 hours yet (I count weekends as 24 hours total). If he hasn't posted by tomorrow, I will prod him.

[Haylen]

Fine. I expect a full Vel-Rahn Koon probing to be executed tomorrow.

[Netopalis]

I want to hear VRK's comments before I commit us to a no-lynch. I'm fairly sure that I know who the scum is, but I'm willing to wait a day if you all insist.

[Vel-Rahn Koon]

There will be no probing of the VRK. I don't do probing. Unless some weird space alien abducts me and then I really have no say in the matter.

Anyway, I'm here guys. I don't get time to post on weekends and yesterday was being a typical Monday.

Haylen, 1134 makes no sense. Why do you think the scum is going to kill tonight if we No Lynch and make finding them easier? That's a ridiculous leap in logic. I agree that if we No Lynch it's good for us and that we get another go at information, but I don't think it follows that the scum are going to do us any favors and make a kill tonight.

It kills me to say it but I agree with Neto's 1137. I can't see how Haylen is scum any longer considering that Nacho died last night. Everything about my thought process is WIFOM, but Haylen's been in such hot water all game long I don't see her (as scum) killing off one of the only people who thought she was town. Like I said, it's WIFOM. And Nacho seemed to be the only person to partner her with. I can't see an SK/Haylen team TBH.

I'm willing to go with the No Lynch, but I don't think we should be surprised if we all have a weird sense of Deja Vu on Day 7. I'll wait until people have responded before throwing a vote.

[Haylen]

Haylen, 1134 makes no sense. Why do you think the scum is going to kill tonight if we No Lynch and make finding them easier?

I presume they will because that's what scum do. They kill at night. Go and look at any game on this site and you will see scum night killing, except for 5pV's and other nightless games of course.

[Haylen]

Lol, when I'm giving a role involving a kill, I always shoot. It's a bit of a compulsion. Hell, I kill as Vig on night 1. Guess im being quite presumptuous in saying that everyone does when they clearly dont seeing as the amount of free nights we've had Weird...

HEY! VRK! YOU'RE THE LIST MOD! Which newbie game in the history of newbie games has had the longest amount of days?

[Netopalis]

Nah, killing doesn't actually help them any, as it doesn't get them any closer to their goal....

[Haylen]

Yeah it does. Lol. Their wincon says = to the amount of townies. Only way that can achieve that it by killing townies. *shrugs*

Nah, killing doesn't actually help them any, as it doesn't get them any closer to their goal....

You said that almost lovingly.

[Netopalis]

Either way, a mislynch is a loss. A kill tonight does not put scum any closer to winning, but it does make it easier for the town to lynch correctly. That's why scum hasn't been killing at night.

[Vel-Rahn Koon]

Haylen, 1134 makes no sense. Why do you think the scum is going to kill tonight if we No Lynch and make finding them easier?

I presume they will because that's what scum do. They kill at night. Go and look at any game on this site and you will see scum night killing, except for 5pV's and other nightless games of course.

Yes but this presumption is 100% at odds with what we saw happen on days 3 and 4 of this game. That's why I think your train of thought is off. We've already seen twice now in this game that scum will not NK for whatever reason.

And you answered this yourself in 1144, so nvm the above.

/agree with Neto 1147. Since we're in MyLo, the scum don't need to kill tonight to win the game. A mislynch in MyLo will win the game for them just as well as a mislynch in LyLo will.

As for longest number of game days, I think this is either the winner or damn close to it. This is probably pushing the page count as well. I'll have to go look at the wiki.

[Incognito]

Bumping a vote count.