Mini 915 - Murder in Murder Free Village (Over)

[Kmd4390]

Sigh. No. We're in another game together and we were talking to each other in both games at the same time.

So scum can't daytalk?

Is that because I unvoted and voted someone else, or for another reason?

Because you backed off of Dee so easily and put a vote with awful reasoning in it's place.

[danakillsu]

So scum can't daytalk?

I don't know the answer to that question.

[Nobody Special]

@Danakillsu, aren't you the least bit apprehensive about being modkilled for talking about an ongoing game? Also, you don't seem to be doing any favors for yourself going on about daytalking scum. Care to elaborate?

I'd also like to hear more from My Milked Eek. Generally.

[Herodotus]

Vote Count, which happens to be on page 4:

danakillsu (3):

Haschel Cedricson, DeeJayCee, Darkstrike_11

Flareonage (2):

Kmd4390, Lastsurvivor

DeeJayCee (2):

Flareonage, Radical Hijinx

Kmd4390 (2):

charter, My Milked Eek

Lastsurvivor (1):

Nicodemus

Haschel Cedricson (1):

danakillsu

No Lynch (0):

Not Voting (1):

Nobody Special
With

12

players, it takes

7

to lynch or

6

to choose not to lynch.
Deadline is 6:00 AM UTC, Monday, Feb 15.

[Lastsurvivor]

@Danakillsu, aren't you the least bit apprehensive about being modkilled for talking about an ongoing game? Also, you don't seem to be doing any favors for yourself going on about daytalking scum. Care to elaborate?

I'd also like to hear more from My Milked Eek. Generally.

Well, he really didn't go into details, so it's not that bad.

[Darkstrike_11]

oooooh 'ello

Lastsurvivor, what is your opinion on Danakillsu?

[DeeJayCee]

Hey guys, Just started High school yesterday. So Fun , anyway will be posting soon!

[My Milked Eek]

I'd also like to hear more from My Milked Eek. Generally.

If you'll excuse me for one more day, finals finished this week and there's some partying and stuff.

[charter]

Still waiting Kmd. Not really much has changed since I last posted, dana is scummy, but I think Kmd is scummier.

@NobodySpecial, who are you most suspicious of? Why aren't you voting? Why are you calling out MME for not posting yet you're posting much less than he is? Do you want to hear more from Nicodemus?

Haschel, who's your second suspect after dana?

[Haschel Cedricson]

I probably won't be able to post anything long until tomorrow night, but for now I'll say that nobody is pinging my scumdar hard enough to merit being considered a "second suspect" yet. I don't think DJC is scum so much as he is 14 years old. I disagree with Kmd's case on Flareonage, but I get the impression that Kmd believes his own case. That's more important to me than the case itself, so Kmd gets a slight nudge into the pro-town category.

Everybody else I don't have a strong read on yet.

[Kmd4390]

This game just ended. Looking over it, I didn't catch him with the nervousness tell here, but Netopalis was scum who I placed a serious vote on in my first post (Post 15). Too bad I bought his fakeclaim.

My other example hasn't ended yet. At least from this, you can see a game where I was town and was serious about believing I caught scum from my very first post. I make a post a little later saying I have 4 very solid reads on players. Turns out 3 of the 4 were right.

[Nobody Special]

@NobodySpecial, who are you most suspicious of? Why aren't you voting? Why are you calling out MME for not posting yet you're posting much less than he is? Do you want to hear more from Nicodemus?

There is no single player that stands out (yet) as scummiest to me; that's why I'm not voting. I hope to ferret out some scummitude soonest.

"Calling out" MME? I just asked for more posts, much like any other player might ask me for more posts. More input means more potential analysis and therefore more scumhunting.

I would, in fact, like to hear more from Nicodemus. Anticipating your next: I didn't count every persons posts; MME leapt out at me as a potential Active Lurker.

[Herodotus]

I'm not making an official warning for any player right now, but please be more careful in the future not to make indirect comments on other ongoing games. It is against rule 9 in this game, and probably against the rules of the other game. Completed games are fair to discuss.

[Kmd4390]

NS, I find it hard to believe you don't have an opinion on anyone yet.

[Nobody Special]

@NobodySpecial, who are you most suspicious of? Why aren't you voting? Why are you calling out MME for not posting yet you're posting much less than he is? Do you want to hear more from Nicodemus?

There is no single player that stands out (yet) as scummiest to me

; that's why I'm not voting. I hope to ferret out some scummitude soonest.

"Calling out" MME? I just asked for more posts, much like any other player might ask me for more posts. More input means more potential analysis and therefore more scumhunting.

I would, in fact, like to hear more from Nicodemus. Anticipating your next: I didn't count every persons posts; MME leapt out at me as a potential Active Lurker.

NS, I find it hard to believe you don't have an opinion on anyone yet.

My bolded statement above simply means what it says: No one player is scummiest, to me, at this point. I have opinions on several players.

I wonder why you might feel the need to put words in my mouth. Care to defend that?

[Kmd4390]

Can you share those opinions because I haven't seen any from you.

[Nobody Special]

Can you share those opinions because I haven't seen any from you.

A pudding half-formed is quite inedible. Patience, my child.

Can you answer my question now, please?

[Kmd4390]

I just find it contradicting that nobody is scummiest, but you say you have opinions. And not sharing your opinions is anti-town.

What question?

[Nobody Special]

I wonder why you might feel the need to put words in my mouth. Care to defend that?

[Kmd4390]

There's nothing to defend. You haven't given any opinions so I pointed that out.

[charter]

This game just ended. Looking over it, I didn't catch him with the nervousness tell here, but Netopalis was scum who I placed a serious vote on in my first post (Post 15). Too bad I bought his fakeclaim.

My other example hasn't ended yet. At least from this, you can see a game where I was town and was serious about believing I caught scum from my very first post. I make a post a little later saying I have 4 very solid reads on players. Turns out 3 of the 4 were right.

I don't think these two are all that similar, I think good scumhunting caught him in that other game, but that's not what you're doing here. Here you took some posts, created some 'scumtell' and said those posts contained that scumtell. That's not good scumhunting, that's fake or very poor scumhunting.

NobodySpecial, what opinions have you formed then? I don't really get how you can have opinions on people but don't find anyone scummy, please explain.

[Kmd4390]

It's good scumhunting if I'm right.

You are just echoing my question to NS by the way.

[charter]

It's good scumhunting if I'm right.

This is crap. Anyone can justify any action by saying that, but there's no way to verify that until the person's alignment is known.

You are just echoing my question to NS by the way.

Well yeah, he's doing absolutely nothing and that's going to change or he's going to get lynched.

[Nobody Special]

NobodySpecial, what opinions have you formed then? I don't really get how you can have opinions on people but don't find anyone scummy, please explain.

I have some half-formed opinions on some people; I never said I didn't find

anyone

scummy, only that I don't have a

scummiest

player yet.

Honestly, why are you and Kmd trying to misrepresent me so blatantly?

[Kmd4390]

I can make the same arguement against your point.

I agree about NS. The only thing is I don't see why you had to echo my question and make it look like an original point.