Teleportation Mafia Universe TWO (TOWN WINS)

[Jack]

Day 2 Vote Count

animorpherv1 ( 1 ) Anon
Anon ( 0 )
DeathRowKitty ( 0 )
Starbuck ( 0 )
Plum ( 0 )
Elmo ( 1 ) Lowell
fhqwhads ( 0 )
Jack ( 6 ) DeathRowKitty Starbuck Nicodemus Plum Kise VP Baltar
VP Baltar ( 0 )
Kise ( 0 )
Lowell ( 0 )
Maelyn ( 0 )
Nicodemus ( 0 )
Not Voting ( 5 ) fhqwhads Maelyn animorpherv1 Elmo Jack
Total ( 13 )

With 13 alive, 7 needed to lynch.
Deadline: Feb 22nd 19:00 EST

---------[]

???

[Nicodemus]

And Nicodemus I see browsing, what are you thinking about Nicodemus?

I'm thinking we've caught scum is what. I'm also thinking that if you are scum, then Ellibereth is almost guaranteed town, as I see it as basically impossible that he's bussing from a different universe. Also, I think that Lowell would be a fine teleport-ee for tonight.

[VP Baltar]

Scum confirmed. Someone hammer.

[Jack]

Paraphrasing a role PM takes seconds, fabricating a good fakeclaim can take a lifetime.

VP, you seem like a nice guy, but I don't like having my intelligence insulted.

As mafia, I always write my fakeclaim on day 1, and edit as the game goes on. If you don't do that you're retarded, I'm not retarded.

What number would you pick? It is actually relevant.

[Jack]

Scum confirmed. Someone hammer.

I'd like to read over the thread and name my top three suspects and why, just for the "I told you so's" if I'm right.

[VP Baltar]

VP, you seem like a nice guy, but I don't like having my intelligence insulted.

Thanks, you too. It's a shame we couldn't have been on the same team.

I'd like to read over the thread and name my top three suspects and why, just for the "I told you so's" if I'm right.

So, you don't know who you suspect and why? interesting.

---------[]

[Kise]

Yeah, L-1.

I guess I pick the number 37, son. This reminds me a lot of Netopolis when he's scum.

Wait, if the winner is the person closest to half

the average

, wouldn't that mean whoever picked the lowest number won the bonus points?

I think Jack is trying to pick his nightkill victim.

[VP Baltar]

Don't feed the

troll

scum.

[Jack]

VP, you seem like a nice guy, but I don't like having my intelligence insulted.

Thanks, you too. It's a shame we couldn't have been on the same team.

I'd like to read over the thread and name my top three suspects and why, just for the "I told you so's" if I'm right.

So, you don't know who you suspect and why? interesting.

---------[]

Nico and Elmo are scum, but I have to figure out the third and write up a case.

[Nicodemus]

Wait, if the winner is the person closest to half

the average

, wouldn't that mean whoever picked the lowest number won the bonus points?

Not if he picked 1 and everyone else picked 99 (an unlikely scenario to be sure, but he certainly wouldn't win them).

Also, if Jack was picking his Night Kill victim he would just post in the QT. Which he's probably doing now.

------------

Edit by way of preview: Sowwy VP. I like logic questions though...

[DeathRowKitty]

Dont lynch without me again!!!

Oh, wait, I'm already on this wagon.

Someone have a hammer? (Also, not that it matters, but Jack, claim.)

[animorpherv1]

I'll hammer after Jack claims, or 24 hours (whichever comes first).

[DeathRowKitty]

Oh, and I'd pick A(TREE(TREE(g64)), TREE(TREE(n(4)))) for that question. The functions involved should be self explanatory and g64 is Graham's number.

[Kise]

Don't feed the

troll

scum.

I thought it was don't feed the animals.[?]

[VP Baltar]

He's had plenty of time to claim, but whatevs.

[Kise]

Unpick: 37; Pick: 99

The fact this little test is supposed to matter makes me think Jack's not VT.

[Jack]

PBPA (sort of) on nico

First nine or so posts are discussing strategy. He is very supportive of my suggestions, quote: "Exactly" in response to my post.

In ISO 9 he quotes me and Elmo talking about there being three mafia. How did you guys know there were 3 mafia, oh scummy!

Votes me, fos's elmo.

Next few posts discussing strategy. He is very willing to discuss strategy.

Votes drk for scumhunting in the wrong universe. nico hasn't scumhunted. He doesn't post for a while and is prodded.

ISO 19 is first analysis, but it is poor. He seriously questions my rvs vote as blatant omgus. A bit of hypocrisy, not real scumhunting imo.

Nothing more really till today, when he opportunistically votes me and again fos's elmo. He uses "scum can day talk" as part of the evidence. Very non obvious, I had to hunt for it in the OP. He didn't have to check up on the "how do you know there are three mafia?" think because the mod corrected him. Ergo, he knows scum could day talk because he's scum, and he was making up that thing about "how do you know there are three mafia" because he's scum.

Fos'ing his mafia partner for weak distancing.

I'll get to elmo next.

[DeathRowKitty]

Claim.

[Nicodemus]

Nothing more really till today, when he opportunistically votes me and again fos's elmo. He uses "scum can day talk" as part of the evidence. Very non obvious, I had to hunt for it in the OP. He didn't have to check up on the "how do you know there are three mafia?" think because the mod corrected him. Ergo, he knows scum could day talk because he's scum, and he was making up that thing about "how do you know there are three mafia" because he's scum.

Just to touch on this: I knew mafia could day talk because I read the set-up post, and day-talking stuck out to me as a major boost to scum. I did not know that there were three mafia per team because this information was not in the set-up post when I voted you.

Now please, die.

[Jack]

The numbers test is an nth order thinking question. 25 is a 1st order pick, you assume everyone is going to pick randomly. 12 would be a 2nd order pick, you assume everyone is going to think to the first order, so you pick close to the new average, and so on.

I was asking to help me judge how serious people were when they said my post was a scum claim.

Nico picked 25 despite making this post earlier though:

Mykonian in the other universe says I'm smart, for what it's worth.

Maybe you didn't read that right, Jack.

@ the other universe

. Jack is trying to be smart and manipulative.

Town doesn't manipulate. Jack is scum.

Nice misrepresentation of mykonian.

This however I find hilarious beyond all description.

So I'm not sure how useful it is really.

[animorpherv1]

JACK, WE HAVE ASKED YOU TO CLAIM. IN YOUR NEXT POST, YOU CLAIM OR I HAMMER.

[VP Baltar]

oh haaaaay, this is still going on? What a surprise.

[DeathRowKitty]

Well, I mean he kind of already claimed, but I guess claiming scum doesn't count?

[Jack]

Nothing more really till today, when he opportunistically votes me and again fos's elmo. He uses "scum can day talk" as part of the evidence. Very non obvious, I had to hunt for it in the OP. He didn't have to check up on the "how do you know there are three mafia?" think because the mod corrected him. Ergo, he knows scum could day talk because he's scum, and he was making up that thing about "how do you know there are three mafia" because he's scum.

Just to touch on this: I knew mafia could day talk because I read the set-up post, and day-talking stuck out to me as a major boost to scum. I did not know that there were three mafia per team because this information was not in the set-up post when I voted you.

Now please, die.

Which setup post, this one?

Universe 2:
1-shot Mafia B Teleporter
Mafia B Goons x 2

viewing preview:

Ani, I would really like to write up my case on Elmo in more depth and to read through to figure the final mafia.

[Nicodemus]

In effect, it's like having two lynches. We could potentially win by the end of day 2.

I think Jack's point is quite interesting. While there's 3 of a mafia group alive, they'd probably kill in the universe where they had 2 members if they were split (unless they thought they'd be teleported out soon).

Where did we find out there were 3 mafia members exactly? When I was reading through the role list, I figured there were only two. Are you just basing your speculation on balance, or do you have some extra information?

Vote: Jack

FoS: Elmo

Because it's as good as anything right now.

The sign-up had the full setup.

The second posts of each game have now had the setups added.