Newbie 893 - Newbieland! (GAME OVER)

[Pomegranate]

Post later today, I hope.

[TheButtonmen]

Jade Empire?

[xRECKONERx]

D2 Vote Count #5

Pomegranate (3): chauchaudotcom, Nikanor, My Milked Eek
RayFrost (3): Gayle, TheButtonmen, Pomegranate

Not voting (1): RayFrost

Deadline is 2/21/10 at 11:00am EST.

[Pomegranate]

That doesn't answer my question. He either claims vanilla or doc. Would you believe any of the two, regardless if they came from rayfrost?

I would not. And neither would you, correct? Then we only need to tell the doctor not to counterclaim.

I think at this stage claims are worthless, the only value they might carry is a possible counterclaim on a doc claim. If a doc claim gets counterclaimed we lynch the claimer obviously.

Either way, I find Pome's suspicion of Rayfrost to be very suspicious. Iso-read her:
- her suspicions of rayfrost appear when others suspect rayfrost
- she triple or quadruple confirms her vote on nikanor, but when the rayfrost bandwagon gets momentum she switches wagons, even wanting to hammer RF

Now, this does not imply anything about rayfrost's alignment as this could be indicative of Pome bussing or Pome pushing yet another mislynch (assuming pome is scum, which I'm almost certain of).


Also, perhaps coincidentally, her two scumreads are on people who have posted the most fluff of the game. I do not find fluff to be indicative of any alignment, nor is active lurking for that matter. And in fact, it's an easy ticket to appear scumhunting, especially when she didn't do much before this.

I'm sorry you find my suspicions of RF scummy. He is.
Yes. You touched upon the answer. I think they are both scum. Nikanor was at L-1. I want(ed- I still do) him to be hammered. But then I realized it wasn't going to happen, I switched to RF- BECAUSE I THINK THAT THEY ARE BOTH SCUMBUDDIES. Got it?

You agree that RayFrost is scum, yes?

Why is Nikanor a better lynch?

Which one do you think is more dangerous?

Pom. I know your switched your vote but can you answer this question Gayle asked before? Why did you think, previously, that Nika was a better lynch then Frost? Why did you want Nika lynched b4 Frost if they're both going to flip scum (in your eyes)?

Yes, RF is scum. I agree with you entirely on that. But I really want to lynch Nik first. If it comes to I'll switch soon/later.

Why are you so positive RF is scum? All you've said he is posts fluff.

Why is asking a person at L-1 with a threat to be hammered to claim foolish?

For the record Frost had an opportunity to claim back a page already. He was already L-1. Which is why Pom's insistence to put him back on L-1 just to wait for a claim is ridiculous. Particularly given how positive she is that frost is scum. Hence, I'm looking at a strong possibility of a Pom + Frost pairing.

I know it sounds bad, but Nik was a better lynch simply because he conveniently already had three votes on him.

I think he's scum. I've seen RFscum before. And he hasn't done anything. And my poorly tuned gut says so.

Um, he was at L-1, and I said I'd give him one more chance to post before hammering. That was it.

Pomegranate is so obvious, though. I really don't know what the holdup is.
The point of the game is to lynch scum. I'm trying to do just that by lynching Pom, but you guys aren't helping me do that, so I'm asking what's taking y'all so long.

Don't say that you're trying, and that no one's helping you. You aren't doing anything- all you did was jump on a stupid bandwagon for no reason other than the fact that it was the only other BW than your own.

(Lynch all Liars comes to mind.)

Okay, RF is fine.

I'll give him a chance to post once (claim?)

, and then I'll most likely hammer.

To all: I'm willing to go for either a Nikanor or RF lynch.

Since MME unvoted,

Vote: RayFrost.

Yes, I voted him once it wasn't the hammer anymore. He hadn't posted yet.

She said she was sure of rayfrost. What good would waiting for rayfrost's claim do in her willingness to hammer? It's not like she would have gone like "oh, shit, a vanilla/doc, let's unvote". She only asked for the claim so she would look protown. If she was so sure of rf, she would have hammered him.

I'm with chau on this, her hopping to the rayfrost wagon is both opportunistic and straight out appealing to the town.

That's what I do. I give people one more chance. I'm sorry if you have a problem with the way I play the game.

Anyway, I don't have anything valuable to claim, etc.

I AM GOD, EMPREROR SUN! /reference

I'm this undead emperor using the water dragon's heart in order to continue to live past my designated time. I'm also sapping her mighty powers for my own.

Unfortunately, I got owned by the heroes, so now I'm just this feeble old man in the spirit world with a bunch of angry spirits that want to eat me.

So I'm basically powerless against that which to do me harm.

Will someone

please

hammer RayFrost?

[RayFrost]

Jade Empire?

/winner

[Gayle]

Are we satisfied with lynching RayFrost now?

Also,

[Jade Empire Spoilers]

Not everyone has managed to save the village from bandits yet!

[My Milked Eek]

I think we've reached an impasse. Both wagons are L-1 and it seems no one on either wagon is going to budge or hop to the other one. I think we should lay out both cases in bullet points and decide if we're going with one or the other. Or neither of them.

[RayFrost]

Hmmm...

I'm the only one voting.

Well, if it's between me (town) or Pom (unknown)...

Yeh.

vote: pomegranate

[Gayle]

So you come in here and lurk, promise to build a case and then replace, fail to do either, make a joke post, and then hammer without a reason.

I dunno, that kind of pisses me off.

Lynch RayFrost tomorrow.

[TheButtonmen]

So you come in here and lurk, promise to build a case and then replace, fail to do either, make a joke post, and then hammer without a reason.

I dunno, that kind of pisses me off.

Lynch RayFrost tomorrow.

What He/She said.

[xRECKONERx]

D2 Vote Count #6

Pomegranate (4): chauchaudotcom, Nikanor, My Milked Eek, RayFrost
RayFrost (3): Gayle, TheButtonmen, Pomegranate

As you all begin to lynch up Pomegranate, she struggles. She doesn't want to go. But you all load her up on the dunk-a-clown tank and all take shots. chauchaudotcom, Nikanor, My Milked Eek, all take shots... but it's not until RayFrost throws his final pitch that she is sunk. You all close the lid on her and watch as she drowns. Unfortunately for you all, you were compleeeetely wrong.

Pomegranate,

Vanilla Townie

, lynched D2

The thread is now locked. N2 deadline is going to be 2/17 at 1:00PM.

[xRECKONERx]

Sleep. And then... the blood-curdling screams wake you all up. Everyone rushes outside just in time to see chauchaudotcom strapped to the roller coaster track. He screams for help, but it's too late as the coaster barrels toward him and splatters him like a bug on a windshield. You might wanna clean your body off... you've got some chauchau on you...

chauchaudotcom,

Vanilla Townie

, killed N2

It is now D3. Deadline will be 3/10/10 at 11:00am. With 5 alive, it takes 3 to lynch.

[Gayle]

Vote:RayFrost

He

screams for help

[Gayle]

Actually

Unvote

[TheButtonmen]

@Everyone:

I've noticed a problem, mainly that RayFrost hasn't been lynched yet. Please help me rectify this.

[My Milked Eek]

While that may be a problem. Let's hear from Nikanor first.

[RayFrost]

@Everyone:

I've noticed a problem, mainly that RayFrost hasn't been lynched yet. Please help me rectify this.

...

and no vote

helloooooooooo obv scum

Vote: TheButtonmen

[Nikanor]

Yeah, why didn't you vote for Ray, buttonne?

[TheButtonmen]

Yeah, why didn't you vote for Ray, buttonne?

...It's 3-2. So I'm not throwing down a vote 8 hours into the day.

Why do you want me to put a vote so much>

[TheButtonmen]

EBYOP:

Why do you want me to put a vote so much? (I missed the / key)

[Nikanor]

Why do you want me to put a vote so much?

Are you fucking with me? You're fucking with me, aren't you? There's no WAY someone could be this obviously scum. The 'Too scummy' fallacy is the only thing keeping me from voting you right now, believe it or not.

[RayFrost]

oh snap, lylo. >.<

forgot.

unvote

[Gayle]

Why do you want me to put a vote so much?

Are you fucking with me? You're fucking with me, aren't you? There's no WAY someone could be this obviously scum. The 'Too scummy' fallacy is the only thing keeping me from voting you right now, believe it or not.

Excuse me, what? The fact that he doesn't want to cast a vote in lylo before there is any discussion is scummy?


Guys, is there any reason to believe that RayFrost and Nikanor are not the scum team?

[My Milked Eek]

Well, I do have my gut read on RF. But my gut has been wrong before, lol. And I did feel more scum vibes from SK than from Nikanor, however, BM has given me the opposite.

It's between BM-Nik-RF for me.

Nikanor, your top scum please. Same goes for RF and BM, although I don't expect anything from RF.

[TheButtonmen]

Ray Frost, Nik are close 1st and 2nd, MME is distant 3rd, Gayle I'm fairly sure is town.

Well, I do have my gut read on RF. But my gut has been wrong before, lol.

In this case you should believe in your internal organs more!