Stars Aligned II - Game Over!

[elvis_knits]

Seriously though, if anyone commits a murder, I will lynch you.

If anyone commits a murder? How flawed is your logic? I could ONLY kill Dramonic. Have someone use occult books, and stop being impulsive.

HoS

Impulsion will get you no where in this game.

People trying to be vigs will only screw us for several reasons, which I already said.

1)More likely to hit town
2)While you're stalking and murdering, you waste 2 nights worth of pro-town actions. You are effectively taking that from the town
3)You make it harder for others to distinguish you from a murderer, increasing the chance that we lynch you
4)Also, you could totally be a murderer faking this "vig" bullshit to explain why you were killing an innocent townie. The excuse is too convenient. And I will not open the door for murderers to use a "vig" excuse.

So, yes, I will totally lynch anyone who commits a murder.

[SlySly]

I challenge you to find where I broke a rule.

Take it to PM if you like

- point out one single instance of where I discussed this game outside of this game.

Don't ask others to ignore the rules and break them, too, RuleBreaker.

[DrippingGoofball]

Your assuming, with only meta behind.

FAIL.

Also, I can't speak for elvis.

But you FAILED to explain why I was wrong. Do you know for how many years the scum have been calling my arguments "insane" and "trash" when I caught them, but were unable to say how and why? Nice to know the tradition lives on.

vote: Chaco

[elvis_knits]

Your assuming, with only meta behind. And Elvis wants to lynch

me

is

anyone

gets murdered. That add up in the slightest? If it does, by all means, please let me know. I wanna be the first.

WHAT...

I would only lynch you if you're responsible for the murder.

The "you" was a general you, not specific.

[iLord]

Logic aside, I think ani knows that any renegade activity from him going forward will result in his lynch. The recent ani/saber bet debacle has given me a certain opinion of him. I don't see why he wasn't banned along with saber, but I am in no way pushing that issue and have no personal problem with ani.

Eh, I guess so. The only other game I've seen Ani in he didn't seem to act nearly as bizzarely, but his behavior so far makes me hesitant to agree with arguments that entail him making any logical/obvious decisions.

[elvis_knits]

Seriously though, if anyone commits a murder, I will lynch you.

Was this not clear?

Whoever commits a murder gets lynched.

NOT

"If any player in the game commits a murder we lynch chaco."

[iLord]

Don't see the attack against Chaco at all.

[Chaco]

LOL what Goofball?

Effect: You may choose the Commune Night Action.
Destroyed when: Commune discovers someone more Insane than you are.

And gotcha Elvis, seemed broad.

Other things wrong with your argument Drip:

I couldn't ward if I were cult.
You can check my insanity with occult books.

I'd say that vote is as baseless as it gets.

[Drench]

Unvote, Vote: Iecerint

explainez vous?

CRAZY IDEA THAT NOONE SHOULD TAKE SERIOUSLY BUT I'VE BEEN THINKING ABOUT.
This is also probably flawed as hell, but whatever:
We somehow come together with a list of 12 peoples not counting Ani that are "town", and we run Adel's killing plan with the town reads killing off everyone else.
If I'm being an idiot, ignore this post.

i don't see what's changed enough for the opposers (myself included) to support this

on slysly - sit on uncle drenchy's lap, everyone, and listen to my story

this. is. not. a. scumtell.

we are basing the fact that sly is scum because he requested it on information that is /not even known/. how can you say someone's scum just because he requested modkills on players who 'might be town'? not to mention that they were actually breaking the rules. and probability says that there's a good chance they're both town anyway.

so yeah

Actually, no. I put up with this from SlySly because he appears to be retarded and he's probably scum, but you don't get to repeat what he says as though it's truth. I challenge you to find where I broke a rule. Take it to PM if you like - point out one single instance of where I discussed this game outside of this game. Until that, you don't get to call me a rulebreaker.

i'll take this up after the game if i remember, but i won't pollute the thread with it

oh, and one more thing. you may find this hard to believe, but (amazingly) i have an opinion about this too! i know, it's shocking. i was surprised too.

[Chaco]

Seriously though, if

anyone

commits a murder,

I will lynch you

.

Was this not clear?

Whoever commits a murder gets lynched.

NOT

"If any player in the game commits a murder we lynch chaco."

Not that clear at all.

[Percy]

Hayker replaces Adel.

There will be no modkills.

[DrippingGoofball]

Not that clear at all.

Very poorly worded, but there is no way she meant what you imply that she meant with your literal interpretation of what she said.

[SlySly]

It's unsettling to know that some are exempt from the rules. Coddlefest in progress.

[Chaco]

Not that clear at all.

Very poorly worded, but there is no way she meant what you imply that she meant with your literal interpretation of what she said.

There was no other text to get the intention clear, not until clarification.

Anything else?

[animorpherv1]

@Chaco, she's thinking that anyone who murders is planning to become a murderer, and she doesn't want it to happen. Both you and elvis can stop cutting each other's throat's now.

[Phate]

I'm not feeling a Chacolynch. I looked at him in iso, and while I don't get townvibes from him, I don't think he's as scummy as, say, Ellibereth or Nicodemus.

[Iecerint]

Why is Ell scummy? I remember that thought crossing my mind a long time ago, but he has been well-behaved recently.

And who is Nicodemus? (Goes to read.)

[Ellibereth]

Chaco vs. DGB = town vs. town
I'm also sad noone would took my suggestion seriously, ah well.

[Phate]

Ellibereth, I am in favor of your plan, but you can stop wasting your breath because there are several town players who shirk their duty to play to win.

[Iecerint]

Nicky is innocuous-to-scummy IMO. Supporting Adel while expressing lack of understanding is an event that falls into the latter category. He's posted several empty "fun" posts, too, and without other substantive posts.

It's certainly better than my Ani vote.

Unvote: Vote: Nicodemus

[Ellibereth]

Not@Phate:
The main "problems" with Adel's plan to some people (I think):
Using a generator to decide pairings.
Breaking Infractions on purpose.

If we make the pairings list ourselves, it's still playing mafia! Townhunt 12 people. Cult tries to get enough people in that list to survive.

If this is still not "playing mafia", then any form of pure Night action regulation within the town isn't playing mafia, as in essence, that's all the plan is.

[Iecerint]

What do you mean by "breaking infractions on purpose"? I don't follow.

[Phate]

Vote: Nicodemus

[Ellibereth]

What do you mean by "breaking infractions on purpose"? I don't follow.

Adel's plan involved the people stalking/murdering to choose infractions like Twitching/Paranoid and some other of the like that can be confirmed via breaking them in thread.

[Iecerint]

Phate, why do you -- in back-to-back posts -- single-out Ell as a Hall of Fame scum player and then give her +like points for her brilliant plan?