CooLDoG wrote:well, why don't you
a)start spelling my name out in full, and why don't you capitalize all of the letter correctly
Fine.
CooLDoG wrote:
1) I understand, still you said all, all means everyone, not you...
If I wanted to mean "everyone", I wouldn't have said "I'm only speaking for myself", now would I?
CooLDoG wrote:
2) I have a real life I can't hit the refresh button 50 times hoping a new post pops up
I'm not expecting you to sit at your computer and read every post when it appears. I'm expecting you to catch up with everything you've missed once you do come and over and before you post. Or, at any rate, catch up with everything that is relevant with what you're posting (though I do expect you to catch up with everything else as well eventually).
CooLDoG wrote:
2a) I also got a scummy scent from him early on, I vote him on gut, and because he DID say that zaz was scum baste on him not having many posts
No, he didn't, he said so himself and it's absolutely clear he didn't from his posts. Read them again, and try to understand it this time.
CooLDoG wrote:
2b)Because I un-like you don't have two hours to randomly hit the re-fresh button, I have to work. And I don't have all the time in the world to write up posts. I was going to put it at the end of my post. I hit submit thinking it was over. I had a litle more time on my hands so I hit the refresh button. I then saw his post and it hit me that I forgot to put that in my post...
2c)above...
Fine. Why didn't you say this earlier?
* * *
wolframnhart wrote:@ODDin
Wow? Wow what?
Wow at McGriddle saying that he doesn't need to read the game because he's already caught the scum. It's just so completely obvious to anyone that bothers to think for even a little bit that "I don't need to read the game because I've caught the scum" (on D1, no less) is at the very least completely and utterly anti-town and not the thing one is supposed to be doing, that I was contended with simply expressing my emotions.
* * *
McGriddle wrote:A. WTH is a cult game B. I figured there were only 2 scum because every game I have been in has had 2 scum, and C. You think EVERYTHING is a slip.
Yet another wow. For starters, read the rules of games you sign up to.
farside, in the sign-up thread wrote:This is a cult game which means players become zombies or if they are a power role they will die.
Frankly, when I read the original post I thought you meant "I've caught my 2 scum for today and won't read the game until they're lynched and I can move on to the other scum". Now that you made it clear that you actually thought there are 2 scum in the game, I'm with yos, definitely sounds like a slip. I mean, for your sake, I hope it's a slip, and not that you actually thought it makes sense to have 2 scum and 18 town in a non-cult game.
* * *
Kmd4390 wrote:No, I'm more willing to vote Reck. You want me to hold on to my gut read for the entire game though because it came so late in the game.
Just to make it clear, I don't specifically want you to do anything here.
kmd wrote:I was more willing to vote Reck, my top suspect, which is why I did. I said that I was also willing to vote Evilsnail at that time because he was my next suspect.
[...]
ODDin, I'm not sure where you get "equally willing" from. You said it multiple times, but I don't believe I ever even implied that.
You said "vote: reck, also willing to vote evilsnail". When people say such things, I understand that they are equally willing to vote for both of them, so they just select the marginally scummier among them. When I have two suspects, one significantly more scummy than the other, I say "vote: X, FoS: y".
There's a difference between "willing to vote" and "fos".
* * *
Starbuck: calling somebody dumb is not ad hom, per se. ad hom is a logical fallacy where your argument is based on the personal qualities of a person which have nothing to do with the matter at hand.
For instance, "I hate your political opinions and therefore you must also be a bad mathematician" is ad hom, since political opinions have nothing to do with the understanding of mathematics.
In the case of mafia, to say "you're an idiot and therefore you're scum" is ad hom, since your intellectual qualities have nothing to do with the role you're being given.
What iLord said was in no way ad hom. If anything, it was protecting against ad hom coming from others.
