Open 201 - Fire & Ice Mafia ~Over~

[CSL]

Final Votecount

JacobSavage (L+1) TheLonging, Gheb, xofelf
TheLonging (L) farside II, DTMaster

Not Voting: JacobSavage

Mod Scene: Endgame

Everyone was clamoring as the day went on. Three wanted JacobSavage, two wanted TheLonging.

At sunset, you all push Jacob to the ground, and proceed to beat the ever-living shit out of him.

As TheLonging checked Jacob's pockets, everyone was nervous. Have they caught the first ice mafia?












No.

TheLonging stood up, and turned around to see farside and Xofelf standing there, menacingly. They took out their guns, and shot TheLonging. Gheb, and DTMaster suddenly turned around, and were shot in the head as well. They then froze their bodies, except for Gheb's, as his wouldn't, so they just curbstomped his head, and he was no more.

Xofelf and farside laugh, as they remove their sweaters to reveal Ice Mafia jackets

--A wincon has been fulfilled, the game can no longer continue!--

JacobSavage was a Generic townie.

TheLonging and DTMaster were Generic Townies

Gheb was a member of the Fire Mafia

Xofelf and farside, whom were Ice Mafia, have won Open 201!!!

Sanhora, and kmd4390, have also been given the game as compensation for VERY BAD mod errors!!!

Gayle has also partly won because of an avatar bet.

(Couldn't help myself to the last one...)

[CSL]

Everyone may talk.

Honestly, after Xofelf and Pom were chosen as Ice Mafia, I knew it was done.

Also, There were 5 players alive going into N3, but Gheb likely would've gone fore either of the ice mafia, and the ice mafia would just pick someone off, which is why I called it lylo.

Questions/Concerns/Complaints?

[CSL]

Ice

Fire

QT's are above.

[Slaxx]

Gheb you burn me down man. I is sad.

[DTMaster]

I had Farside2/Pom as fire scum lol. Your endgame play made no sense for Ice scum but what evers. Awesome directing.

If we didn't have so many modkills I would think Xolelf's death would have been generated earlier.

[CSL]

Well, they needed another way to endgame Gheb.

[TheLonging]

Oh Farside 2 you silly goose

[CSL]

-looks at TL's record-

Uhh, you DID lose this. Might want to change that.

[farside22]

Well this game should have gone to night.
Bad mod no biscutt.
The two elements could have targeted the same player and it would have been 2 town, 1 fire and 2 ice.
I have no idea why CSL didn't have this go to night it was the only reason I didn't hammer

[CSL]

farside

Also, There were 5 players alive going into N3,

but Gheb likely would've gone fore either of the ice mafia, and the ice mafia would just pick someone off, which is why I called it lylo.

It was already said

in DAY 3

that it was lylo. Don't badtalk my ruling. It violates Rule 0.

Last time I'm ever going to mod an open game.

[Gheb]

Had farside as scum D1 and Pom D2 or D3 (not sure which one) :rolleyes:
Was pissed that the game became pretty much unwinnable for me after D1 -_-

[farside22]

farside

Also, There were 5 players alive going into N3,

but Gheb likely would've gone fore either of the ice mafia, and the ice mafia would just pick someone off, which is why I called it lylo.

It was already said

in DAY 3

that it was lylo. Don't badtalk my ruling. It violates Rule 0.

Last time I'm ever going to mod an open game.

1) that is WIFOM. Did you ask Gheb who he was going to kill before declaring the ice the winner
2) The game is over and frankly the way you modded this I don't care if I'm ever in a game that you mod again. Ever. You mod killed when you should not have. You declared a game and winner without thinking of possiblity that the ice and fire could have targetted the same player.
In short I think you were in a hurry to end this game and not let it play out as it should have.
I will send my notes to the list mods and let them decided if you modded this correctly.

[CSL]

Ok, I know I did bad, so I PM'd a random member of the ice, and fire mafia. I'll then post again once I get a reply from both of them.

[TheLonging]

-looks at TL's record-

Uhh, you DID lose this. Might want to change that.

I know, I forgot to change it.

[xofelf]

2) The game is over and frankly the way you modded this I don't care if I'm ever in a game that you mod again. Ever. You mod killed when you should not have. You declared a game and winner without thinking of possiblity that the ice and fire could have targetted the same player.
In short I think you were in a hurry to end this game and not let it play out as it should have.
I will send my notes to the list mods and let them decided if you modded this correctly.

Thing is, knowing that we already had fire scum known to us, personally, no matter what had happened, i was gonna target Gheb again for the simple fact that we would win no matter who else he targeted. So your arguement isn't completely valid. Yes i know that i would have had to get agreement from you, but it honestly didn't really matter anyways.
I agree there were some mistakes, but every mod goes through that and as long as it didn't totally scar someone from ever wanting to play again, i say let it go.


Also, i apologize for seemingly lurking all game. I have played many games with KMD and i know that he's come to know that if i'm generic town, i'm not around as much as if i'm scum. Yes, i did also have life creeping up, but it was also to get myself as close to confirmed town as possible with one person who usually holds sway over many others in whatever game he's in.

[CSL]

Well.

farside went TL.

Gheb went DTMaster.

It would've been endgame.

[farside22]

2) The game is over and frankly the way you modded this I don't care if I'm ever in a game that you mod again. Ever. You mod killed when you should not have. You declared a game and winner without thinking of possiblity that the ice and fire could have targetted the same player.
In short I think you were in a hurry to end this game and not let it play out as it should have.
I will send my notes to the list mods and let them decided if you modded this correctly.

Thing is, knowing that we already had fire scum known to us, personally, no matter what had happened, i was gonna target Gheb again for the simple fact that we would win no matter who else he targeted. So your arguement isn't completely valid. Yes i know that i would have had to get agreement from you, but it honestly didn't really matter anyways.
I agree there were some mistakes, but every mod goes through that and as long as it didn't totally scar someone from ever wanting to play again, i say let it go.

If that happened Gheb could have targetted one of us. It could have been the same with 2 town, 2 ice and 1 fire.
I'm not sure if Gheb would have targetted DTM knowing who is what role but it can't be undone.

[The Quintastic One]

Xofelf easily is the laziest scum player in the history of Mafia. I could probably count the number of posts she made over 27 pages on one hand. If I would of stayed in this game I would be very upset with the laziness.

As for Gayle, her play this game reminded me exactly of the type of attitude that made Newbie 884 the worst Mafia Game on this site. Refusal to answer perfectly acceptable questions, demanding we lynch the Doctor POST CLAIM and constantly asking for clarification on suspicions of her even though the reasons are spelled out word for word as if having to talk to a baby. I commend whoever nightkilled this player and made it so that I could read this thread without having to cross over anymore useless Gayle dribble.

CSL as a mod definitely seems far too eccentric, impatient and erratic. Too many modkills for trivial reasons, speeding up of deadlines to unrealistic levels, and constant badgering with every other hour reminders and prods of the deadline. I would of become very irritated with this game.

And on the note of all that negativity, Farside22 gets my pick for MVP of this game. Before or after Ice Mafia. Rightfully questioning Gayles horrible town play, and Pre-Ice Mafia being the only person who did legitimate scumhunting this game. Congrats on a good Ice Mafia win Farside.

[farside22]

Thanks TQO. I think I can understand your frustration if gayle acted like that in another game. It was hard being Ice mafia as I felt sure gayle was scum and I thought she was scum with morph because she completely ignored anything he did and pushed for my lynch.
I knew jaboc was not scum with morph and I meant what I said about that push on morph over me that day does not equal fire mafia.
I also had trouble seeing Gayles POV on masvan as when a player post elsewhere and I see them looking over a thread here it is actively lurking and newb's mostly don't know how to handle pressure. Her calling him town just was too hard for me to believe it was town. And yes when you say someone is more likely to flip town that means town to me.

[CSL]

Actually, I have to agree with TQO on that one for MVP.

[TheLonging]

I agree TQO

[TheLonging]

EBWOP: on Farside I/II being MVP

[DTMaster]

Haylen might beat Xolelf in the lazy scum and winner award

[CSL]

Ok. I have thought about it, and decided that this game must be re-done, as this runthrough does not count.

Those who wish to participate in the redo please pm me AND farside, or just post here. Those who wish not to, I will replace them. I will be posing a new ruleset in the next post.

Thank you. (If you added this game to your win/loss record, slash it)

[CSL]

Rules

(Created and revised by: CSL, farside22)

Day Phase

0. I am Mod, thy God. My word is law. Disrespect it, and you die.
0a. If errors should come up, make it known in the thread if it's votecount. If it refers to ANYTHING ELSE, PM ME!
1. During this phase, you try to find out who the Mafia are, and then proceed to lynch them. Votes must be in the style of

Vote: Rockhead

. Unvotes must be in the form of

Unvote: Rockhead

. Unvotes do not have to be name-speified. An

unvote

in that form is acceptable.
2. If you quote any information from the gamemod, unless it's paraphrasing, you will be modkilled. This

DOES

exclude votecounts.
3. Deadlines will be x+10 (x= the amount of players still alive). Once deadline strikes, the player with the highest number of votes is lynched.
3a. If there is a tie, the player who reached the highest amount first gets lynched.
4. If you are dead, you are dead. Shut up, and save it for the aftergame.
5. During lylo, I will impose a "Lynch Method" section. Example is in Open 201.
6. Prods will be handed out if a player does not post for 48 hours (2 days). If I prod you, you have the same 48 hours to respond, or you will be replaced. If I have to prod you a fouth time, I won't prod you, and you will be force replaced.

Night Phase

1. Thread will be locked. If not, assume it is locked, AND DO NOT POST!
2. All night actions are due in 72 hours. Nothing more, nothing less. Don't send in a night action, you get no action for that night. All factions that have a QT may post in their respective QT. Everyone else, shut up about the game until Day.

General Stuff

1. Do not post your role PM. A modkill awaits you if you do.
2. Don't get too personal.
3. This is a game. Enjoy it, or replace out.
4. The colors

blue

and

dark blue

are reserved for mod usage.
5. Do not edit/delete your posts. Do not use small text, strikethrough, or spoiler text.

6. Modkills will take place if a breaking of a rule is 100% visible to the gamemod. If taken place, their role becomes a neutral survivor, and auto-loses. Blacklists only occur if any site rule is broken during, or after, the modkill.

7. Do not talk about another game, unless it's one that is over. Also, out-of-game discussions are prohibited, or you will be force-replaced.
8. If any mention of DIAF is used, it will cause me to remember a fire that killed two elementary schoolgirls in my area, and it will cause me distress, and such. It will also lead you to the chopping block, and ending the day, and get blacklisted. (This rule was put in here since April of '08, when it happened)
9. ELASTIC CLAUSE ALERT: I will edit or change the rules without warning. I will let you know if a new rule has been added, edited, or deleted.