ZOMBIES! - Zombies take over for the win!!!

[ODDin]

reck means, what sort of results will you get from farside?

When I reread McG's ISO, I tend to agree with e_k, McG is most probably lying. A cop would've tried harder to avoid a lynch, instead of saying "I'm okay with you lynching me" (which, coming from town, is a sign of vanillaness).

[farside22]

Tallahassee: Time to nut up or shut up!
Zombieland

Reckoner (3) Kmd, McGriddle, Albert B. Rampage
tatetothetot (5) evilsnail, iLord, Diamondilium, ODDin, Morph

McGriddle (9) Yosarian2, Starbuck, xRECKONERx, Wolframnhart, CryMeARiver, manho, CooLDoG, Elivis_knits, bv310

Manho (1) tatetothetot

vote voting:

MrSuave
Dr.Cyanide

With 20 alive it will take 11 to lynch
Deadline is Friday March 12th, 9:00am PST

[elvis_knits]

I mean, I will feel like a dumbass if McGriddle really is a cop... but I really think his behavior does not fit.

Also, it sounds like we think there is Cult, but also a SK or a mafia? In that case, mafia might have a cop or rolecop to help them find the cult. In which case, McGriddle could really be a cop and also be scum.

[iLord]

and @ iLord - you want me to lie about myself being a cop? I am not going to do it. I am the damn cop. Lynch me if you don't believe but i am telling you it's a mistake.

Hmm. E_K's question may not be as damning as it seems.

[McGriddle]

I mean, I will feel like a dumbass if McGriddle really is a cop... but I really think his behavior does not fit.

Also, it sounds like we think there is Cult, but also a SK or a mafia? In that case, mafia might have a cop or rolecop to help them find the cult. In which case, McGriddle could really be a cop and also be scum.

Personal attacks are modkillable.

[elvis_knits]

Who did I personally attack?

[elvis_knits]

GRIDDLE, please anser this question:

McG, what kind of investigation results will you get?

[Diamondilium]

I agree with elvis_knits; McG's previous behavior does not coincide with his claim.

iLord, what made you think that McG is lying as

town

?

[McGriddle]

@ E_K sorry, I misread that.

It's Day 1 I haven't had the chance to investigate anyone yet. If you are asking me what I will get back from an investigation, it will probably be somewhere along the lines of "This player is from _____ faction" ____ being town or not town.

[iLord]

iLord, what made you think that McG is lying as town?

The fact that I read him strongly as town, but he was obviously lying about his cop claim.

It's Day 1 I haven't had the chance to investigate anyone yet. If you are asking me what I will get back from an investigation, it will probably be somewhere along the lines of "This player is from _____ faction" ____ being town or not town.

Yeah, that's the way out.

The other major point against McG's cop claim is that he didn't exactly display standard newb-PR behavior. His explanation for this just sounds like a string of excuses. If anything, it represents a convoluted thought process I don't he actually put together when he expressed his defeatism.

Gut's still telling me that he's lying town, but I'm fine with his lynch if he doesn't admit so.

[wolframnhart]

I mean, I will feel like a dumbass if McGriddle really is a cop... but I really think his behavior does not fit.

Also, it sounds like we think there is Cult, but also a SK or a mafia? In that case, mafia might have a cop or rolecop to help them find the cult. In which case, McGriddle could really be a cop and also be scum.

Personal attacks are modkillable.

Elvis didn't personally attack anyone, if anything he was attacking himself. For someone who's case on another person is that he was pushing for modkills you sure are quick to try and get someone else modkilled.

[xRECKONERx]

McGriddle, did the mod not tell you which results you'd receive?

[ODDin]

The mod almost always says the sort of information a cop gets, so this "most likely" is another nail in the coffin of "McG is making his role up".

Also,

For someone who's case on another person is that he was pushing for modkills you sure are quick to try and get someone else modkilled.

QFT

[ODDin]

But McG, if you aren't lying, please remember that actually quoting your role PM is most definitely modkillable, so don't.

[xRECKONERx]

ODDin why the fuck would you respond before him?

I'm finding it hard to believe, based on his wording, that the mod didn't explicitly state his possible results.

[ODDin]

I didn't answer before him. Look here:

@ E_K sorry, I misread that.

It's Day 1 I haven't had the chance to investigate anyone yet. If you are asking me what I will get back from an investigation, it will probably be somewhere along the lines of "This player is from _____ faction" ____ being town or not town.

This is the answer to the question you've just asked. All you did was restate the question once again, but the answer is already there, and that "probably something along the lines of" suggests he's likely making it up.

All I did was warn him not to do anything stupid like actually quote his role PM, because there's no reason for people to get modkilled just like that.

[iLord]

[quote="ODDin"The mod almost always says the sort of information a cop gets, so this "most likely" is another nail in the coffin of "McG is making his role up."[/quote]

I'm not so sure about this part - especially if farside intended for it to be ambiguous as to whether or not there's other scum along with the cult, she might decide it prudent not to enlighten the cop as to the nature of his investigation.

[McGriddle]

Oh shi, I did this a 2nd time. I am a townie not a cop, I messed up this game with another. I got lynched for the exact same reason last time. Whatever, kill me, I am a liability to town being alive.

[CooLDoG]

Site ate me post. (can I say shit now?) I don't think you can mix up between games your roles. And even if you did mix up you should not have had such a lame claim. Before you even claimed you were asking people to lynch you, and after it you asked people to lynch you. I am now fine with an McG lynch even if he is town, he (respectfully) will not be good to have around in the late game.

well thats all I can post. In other news we got a few lurkers around here (sorry I can't post much I did however, have a post that the site ate. sorry bout that). Well at least we got a full days worth of talk to go over for d-2.

[manho]

so McG admitted lying, someone please hammer it.

[McGriddle]

I think CD should be the target tomorrow guys. He is pushing awfully hard for my lynch when he knows I am telling the truth, then he's going to play it off as "well he certainly looked the most scummy oujt of everyone, not my fault, blah blah blah"

[CooLDoG]

Nice lets shift the blame to the guy who wanted to lynch to other guys over you. I really would want a reck or tate lynch today, don't get me wrong you however, are what I've got to settle for. You were 3rd on my list and I think thats pretty good for day one.

[CooLDoG]

also nice job lurking manho. Would you mind to post something of meaning instead of lurking (thanks...).

@all
What do you think of lurkers in the context of this game? Would you lynch on it or not? Sorry that I am asking this late in d-1 I meant to ask it earlier but...

[wolframnhart]

@CD

I don't even think it's the context of the game that matters, lurkers hurt no matter what.

I think CD should be the target tomorrow guys. He is pushing awfully hard for my lynch when he knows I am telling the truth<snip>

Makes no sense. You lied, you admit to lying, you could have outted the real cop assuming there is one with your lie, and you told people to lynch you because you are a liability to the town. CD says he is fine with your lynch and now you are saying he is pushing hard for your lynch?

[ODDin]

unvote, vote: McG

(L-1)
Openly lying is just bullshit.

Also, CD is not pushing harder for your lynch than anyone else.