Mini 918 - A Hot, Steaming Bowl of Mafia - Game Over!

[RedCoyote]

Lynching BH is still my personal preference, but I don't really have any issues with taking charter out either.

[d3x]

@Mod

- Can we get a Prod on Bio, plz?

Does anyone have any reasons

not

to Lynch charter?

[Bio Hazard]

@Mod

- Can we get a Prod on Bio, plz?

Does anyone have any reasons

not

to Lynch charter?

Can I please get an answer from you to my question about charter's play D1?

[Locke Lamora]

d3x: yes, I expect if charter did decide to kill his own scumbuddy and CC was killed before he had a chance to track again, we probably would let him win. I do think it depends on too many variables and would be a gamble for scum when they could just as easily create a lot of WIFOM without killing one of their own. I can think of ways that we could throw a spanner in the works if the situation did happen but it's clearly not going to happen anyway as everyone's now so freaked out that I'm rethinking the charter lynch that we won't get another one through today.

CC: no good reason. I really was just interested.

I'll hammer charter today at some point, I think.

[Locke Lamora]

Well, this clearly isn't going anywhere.

Vote: Charter

[sigma]

With 7 alive, it takes 4 to lynch.

Final Vote Count:

Col.Cathart ( 0 )
d3x ( 0 )
RedCoyote ( 0 )
charter ( 4 ) Col.Cathart, RedCoyote, Zachrulez, Locke Lamora
Bio Hazard ( 0 )
Zachrulez ( 1 ) d3x
Locke Lamora ( 0 )
No Vote ( 2 ) charter, Bio Hazard

[sigma]

You decide to lynch Charter. As he hangs, a telltale ID card falls out of his pocket...

Charter

Mafia Goon

It is now night. You have until Tuesday, March 16th at 7:30 AM (EST) to submit night actions.

[sigma]

You wake up with a feeling of dread, waiting to see who would be missing from the community breakfast... but then you count the arrivals... and a feeling of hope comes over you.

No one has died.

Deadline: March 30th, 12:30 PM (EST)

With 6 alive, it takes 4 to lynch.

Vote count:

Col.Cathart ( 0 )
d3x ( 0 )
RedCoyote ( 0 )
Bio Hazard ( 0 )
Zachrulez ( 0 )
Locke Lamora ( 0 )
No Vote ( 6 ) All

[Locke Lamora]

I'd be inclined to say scum would bus yesterday, so that'd be Zach or RC. I'm guessing you tracked d3x to nothing, CC?

[Col.Cathart]

Yup, d3x did nothing tonight. During the night when no NK happened that also means nothing.

Anyway, does anyone wants to claim something, or we can just safely assume scum overslept/deliberately missed the night kill?

[Locke Lamora]

The thing I don't get is there's no point scum continuously avoiding you. Why would scum not try to kill you? Their scumbuddy's just been killed and a no kill just compounds the problems. If they're worried about a doctor, that problem doesn't go away. They'll have exactly the same problem tonight and so the game will just go on with no night kills until we lynch scum correctly.

[Col.Cathart]

I know, it baffles me as well. You know, I'm actually really sad, because it's been ages since someone actually NKed me in any game, and I feel like I'm not townie enough when playing as town

Anyway, the only thing that comes to my mind is: someone tries to establish 'CC is in fact scum cleverly hidden as Tracker'. Considering Hoopla incident and that Charter thing yesterday it's really preposterous, but seriously, I cannot think of any other explanation. Maybe fear of the Doc but that's stupid as well...

Or maybe scum really overslept Night Phase. In this case my eye falls on Bio, the least active player around.

[Locke Lamora]

No, BH has posted plenty during the night. It's either a deliberate no kill or a block to me.

I'm going to go ahead and:

Vote: Zachrulez

Everything he did late on the charter lynch feels off to me. He kept charter as his number one suspect throughout the day without voting for him while we argued over whether to lynch him or not. His whole rationale for not putting charter at L-1 was then undermined as he did exactly that when I unvoted, claiming there was a clearer consensus. That's the safest time to put your vote on! He avoided it while there wasn't a clear consensus and let others argue for it, then when RC and d3x appeared ready to go along, he decided it was ok for him to vote (ie. time to bus now that the other viable lynches had gone). I'm really not buying the fear of another quick hammer. BH would never have done it again after what happened with Hoopla and I don't think anyone else in this game would have either. Then after I expressed my doubts and voiced my other suspicions, Zach immediately tried to use it against me and say I was trying to set up future lynches.

[d3x]

Happy Scumday LL!! I'll throw a 1-man parade in your honor!

Anyway...

'CC is in fact scum cleverly hidden as Tracker'

It's funny, but that'd been floating around in my head for a while now. I didn't much care for the counterclaim on Hoopla because this isn't an open setup. There's nothing that says there aren't 2 trackers in this game. I don't believe that you are Scum in the slightest {especially with the charter flip} but I'd be lying if I said it hadn't crossed my mind a few times yesterday.

As you saw, I did nothing last night.

Bio- I'm sorry I didn't get a further chance to answer your question regarding charter's D1. I mostly had a null read on him.

In other news, I'm down for a lurker Lynch. Especially now that we have a bit more breathing room.

[Locke Lamora]

Thanks d3x! It's been a fun first year.

It is possible CC is scum, of course. Scum tracker is a possible role and he could have tracked Hoopla N1, but that would have led to him gambling on Shotty being vanilla. Fakeclaiming tracker is even more risky and also completely unnecessary, as scum could have just let Hoopla vs myself play out and guaranteed themselves an easy townie lynch. Bussing charter instantly on D3 with one scumbuddy already down makes CC-scum even more unlikely.

By lurker lynch I assume you still mean Zach or BH?

[Bio Hazard]

I agree with LL that charter was probably bussed yesterday.

I'll go back and look at that.

[d3x]

LL- That's exactly what I mean. As a matter of fact, I'll start with...

Vote:Bio

[RedCoyote]

We could vote no lynch, you know, try and force the mafia to make a move, but I don't think we have to.

Vote: Bio Hazard

BH said the right things yesterday, but I don't think he ever voted anyone, namely charter. Sure, maybe people (d3x) were telling him not to hammer, but hammering scumcharter I think would've given him a little more town creditability. All of this said, Locke understandably takes a hit from the comfortable townie read he once was for me. He was very nervous yesterday. Sure, he explained it with a lot of smooth talkin', but the fact remains that he went from a major proponent of lynching charter to someone who felt the charter wagon was moving too quickly.

[RedCoyote]

I agree with LL that charter was probably bussed yesterday.

Oh, yeah, I'll bet you do.

[RedCoyote]

One more thing. I'm basically throwing the idea that the Colonel is a scum tracker out the window. I'll acknowledge the slight possibility, but yesterday he could've had his cake (or Oats as the case may be) and ate it too. Basically, even with the charter investigation, I know that I was still willing to lynch BH. The Colonel was easily the biggest proponent of staying true to his report, while everyone else either wavered or at least were not as comfortable with the charter lynch as he was. Bussing is one thing, but I think the Colonel could've bussed while being more open to the possibility that we should "test" charter's claim. The fact that he didn't really speaks to me.

[Bio Hazard]

BH said the right things yesterday, but I don't think he ever voted anyone, namely charter. Sure, maybe people (d3x) were telling him not to hammer, but hammering scumcharter I think would've given him a little more town creditability.

Yeah, then I would have a bunch of people shrieking at me like I did D2.

If everyone is voting me just for the D2 hammer, I don't think that's good enough of a reason.

[Locke Lamora]

So can we safely assume that nobody protected CC (or anyone else, for that matter) last night?

[Bio Hazard]

^What's with the rolefish?

[Col.Cathart]

^What's with the rolefish?

At this point (probably one scum, one power role outed) every another probable power role is better for town. I think, if someone has anything to claim, the time is now.

[d3x]

I'm down for a MassClaim.

C.C- As our resident confirmed Town, please pick the order.