Stars Aligned II - Game Over!

[semioldguy]

Not solely.

I do want to take time to look at players who have more or less blindly been supporting each plan or if there even are any players fit that description; since each plan proposed thus far has been shown to actually not help town and I think that this would have been easier to notice how it helps cult/murderers if a person belongs to that faction and they could easily go along with something when they see the advantage to themselves.

SlySly is still my choice for the lynch.

[iLord]

I do want to take time to look at players who have more or less blindly been supporting each plan or if there even are any players fit that description; since each plan proposed thus far has been shown to actually not help town and I think that this would have been easier to notice how it helps cult/murderers if a person belongs to that faction and they could easily go along with something when they see the advantage to themselves.

This is extremely unreliable. How do you differentiate mistaken town (like yourself) and scum?

[semioldguy]

Analysis.

[iLord]

Analysis.

Elaborate on what behavioral differences you'd be looking for.

[semioldguy]

If I had been going along with the first few plans, I'd at least question plans before going along with the next after I trusted the first couple which turned out to be bad. Also I don't think town repeatedly blindly would follow plans for the same reason. I'd also look for how easy they let go of the plans when something bad is pointed out.

[VP Baltar]

I agree with SOG on this point. It's not damning evidence on its own, but it can certainly be corroborative imo.

[iLord]

If I had been going along with the first few plans, I'd at least question plans before going along with the next after I trusted the first couple which turned out to be bad. Also I don't think town repeatedly blindly would follow plans for the same reason. I'd also look for how easy they let go of the plans when something bad is pointed out.

Eh, I guess both scenarios could be indicative, but even then it depends largely on playstyle. Most people in this game appear to just don't care/like to check plans and like to just leave it up to other people to perfect/find mistakes. For our game, the only people that are still alive would be me, Magua, Plum, you, and VP.

Incidentally, we don't need to argue about this in the conditional (or whatever) tense, as it really is kind of pointless. What tells did you find?

[VP Baltar]

Eh, I guess both scenarios could be indicative, but even then it depends largely on playstyle. Most people in this game appear to just don't care/like to check plans and like to just leave it up to other people to perfect/find mistakes. For our game, the only people that are still alive would be me, Magua, Plum, you, and VP.

Ah, the Adel sheeple philosophy. Probably true. Out of curiosity, why is Plum on your list? Seems to me she's doing a pretty good job of saying a whole lotta nothing.

[SlySly]

Eh, I guess both scenarios could be indicative, but even then it depends largely on playstyle. Most people in this game appear to just don't care/like to check plans and like to just leave it up to other people to perfect/find mistakes. For our game, the only people that are still alive would be me, Magua, Plum, you, and VP.

Ah, the Adel sheeple philosophy. Probably true. Out of curiosity, why is Plum on your list? Seems to me she's doing a pretty good job of saying a whole lotta nothing.

It's the old elistest "keep the chat club in the game" mentality.

[elvis_knits]

Sly, please post your scum list.

[VP Baltar]

Sly, please post your scum list.

I tried that already, but he's scum so don't expect him to state his reads endanger his buddies.

[VP Baltar]

* and endanger

[SlySly]

Sly, please post your scum list.

DGB is scum, like I said before. TYVM, VP.

[elvis_knits]

Sly, even if dGB is scum, there's gotta be a ton more scum in this game. We've got prob 4-5 cultists(Nico was cult and I assume CSL is cult), and atleast 2 murderers (I assume startransmission was murderer).

Who else is scum besides DGB?

[SlySly]

Sly, even if dGB is scum, there's gotta be a ton more scum in this game. We've got prob 4-5 cultists(Nico was cult and I assume CSL is cult), and atleast 2 murderers (I assume startransmission was murderer).

Who else is scum besides DGB?

Anyone in this game who has played with DGB before knows that she is not anywhere close to playing her usual game.

Hayker and Plum have pinged my scumdar considerably as well, as I have already stated.

[iLord]

Ah, the Adel sheeple philosophy. Probably true. Out of curiosity, why is Plum on your list? Seems to me she's doing a pretty good job of saying a whole lotta nothing.

I was under the impression that Plum was one of the people that actually considered the last plan. I could be mistaken.

[iLord]

Yeah, Plum was one of the people who was discussing the Aversion Plan.

[animorpherv1]

@Aversion Plan:

No. Not good. I know it's been said before, but I wanted to make sure I posted that.

[dramonic]

You guys are too much into breaking the game and not enough into playing it <_<

[SlySly]

You guys are too much into breaking the game and not enough into playing it <_<

QFT

[Ellibereth]

I'm back from floodingnfallingtrees land and in desperate need of a short summary of all the important stuff that happened (yes I know my graverobbing stuff, and I think the whole aversion thing that I didn't get was dropped?).

From a fast skim, I still want to play WHOS-THE-SCUM-ON-SLYTOWN-WAGON.
DGB and dram.

Unvote, Vote DGB

*twitch*

[iLord]

I'm back from floodingnfallingtrees land and in desperate need of a short summary of all the important stuff that happened (yes I know my graverobbing stuff, and I think the whole aversion thing that I didn't get was dropped?).

We dropped it. Graverobbing's the only thing we got.

You guys are too much into breaking the game and not enough into playing it <_<

Really, there wasn't much else to talk about in this day other than finding a way to maximize night actions.

I don't think we have any other outstanding issues before we finally go to night. Anyone else need anything clarified?

[SlySly]

vote DGB

- obvscumuberlurk

iMurderer, self appointed captains stuck in ignore-mode does not a day end.

[Percy]

Prodding Chaco, DrippingGoofball, evilsnail and Hayker.

[SlySly]

Another thing that seems to have slipped everyone's mind is that I have heard noise the last 2 nights in a row. The best idea is to lynch scum and force the murderer that has me targeted to follow through with their work, that way they won't be free to target another investigator.