![Razz :P](./images/smilies/icon_razz.gif)
You see anything interesting other than the no random-vote thing yet?
I believe that someone that is town aligned would be significantly less likely to claim scumbuddies. If someone is significantly less likely to be town, then that person is significantly more likely to have a different win condition than the town. At the time of my vote, I did not consider that the person in question had just finished a game with the person he claimed as a scumbuddy in which they actually were scumbuddies.Elmocrates wrote: So apparently you suspect him because he did something that isn't inherently town. That's a crappy reason to suspect someone, because some things that aren't inherently town (like signing your name) are obviously not suspicious. I asked you to explain to me why you found it suspicious, and you haven't done that. Please do so.
It is not that I think scum are necessarily more likely to joke about being scum; but I believe that town is less likely than scum to joke about it. Additionally, scum couldn’t be that stupid to do something like that, so it could give the perfect cover for a scum to slide through like that.Elmocrates wrote:xvart: Why do you think scum are more likely to joke about being scum?
I was not the only one confused by your analogy; but I suppose I just incorrectly equated “not inherently town” to “scummy.”xvart wrote: No. You can tell I'm not saying this because I didn't say it
Kmd and debatably, FarsideElmocrates wrote: Please name the people who have said that he can't possibly be scum.
Done.Someone quotemeand respond to this statement in saying that itisscummy, and then lets back a back and forth refuting each others stances and opinions.
You coulda said that when I asked why you suspected him. Why do you think that?xvart wrote:I believe that someone that is town aligned would be significantly less likely to claim scumbuddies.{..}It is not that I think scum are necessarily more likely to joke about being scum; but I believe that town is less likely than scum to joke about it.
I don't see it. Neither of them say that Elscouta's even likely town.
AW CRAPZ.SpyreX wrote:Done.Someone quotemeand respond to this statement in saying that itisscummy, and then lets back a back and forth refuting each others stances and opinions.
Busted your breadcrumb.
Breadcrumbing in general I feel is poor.Jack wrote:So far the only thing I have to say is, breadcrumbing your role if you're a cop is stupid.
Why don't you explain why it's a bad thing scum do? Did I misunderstand your comment about "a certain subset of players who can talk to each other at night"?SpyreX wrote:I wanted to know what rationale you had because making any reference to a breadcrumb at this stage is one of those "If I had a daykill I'd sure be greasing the barrel" kind of statements and, silly me, I opted to let you try to explain how that was a GOOD THING or, really, even A NULL THING versus A BAD THING SCUM DO.