Mini 931: Supreme Court Mafia (Game Over post 682)

[Jack]

Jason is either mafia or the person the mafia were planning on getting lynched. The 2nd possibility is what scares me. But he's said basically nothing today and I don't feel confidant in anyone else.

Vote:Jason

[Fishythefish]

vote: jason

I think he's scum.

[Jack]

unvote

hold on a minute

[Jack]

You researched him didn't you

[Jack]

If it was fishy-camn-pman then I hate you all.

[pman5595]

what the hell was that fishy?

[Netopalis]

What. If that was a lynch, then you have some serious 'splainin to do tomorrow, Fishy. And yes, if he's town, there will be a tomorrow due to the most-votes tiebreaker.

[pman5595]

Mod: was that a lynch?

[Battousai]

Vote Count:

jasonT1981 -4- camn, pman5595, Jack, Fishythefish

Darox -1- jasonT1981

Not Voting:

Netopalis, Dry-fit, Darox

jasonT1981 -Antonin Scalia, Vanilla Justice- has been lynched!

It is now Night. Deadline is Monday, April 5 at 6pm (GMT-5)

[Battousai]

Night Scene

Darox -Simon Jackson, Vanilla Officer- has been NK'd!

It is now Day 4. Deadline is Monday, April 14 at 6pm (GMT-5)

With 6 alive, it takes 4 to lynch!

[Fishythefish]

First, a plea not to do anything rash. I'm sure we're all aware that if there are three scum left, the town needs to quicklynch scum. But suppose there

are

3 scum left. Then the town hasn’t lost, quite. But here’s what needs to happen for us to win:
1. We lynch scum today faster than the scum can vote.
2. 2 people agree and lynch scum tomorrow faster than the scum can vote.
3. One person goes faster than the scum on the day after tomorrow.
Even if you are nearly certain someone (me, say) is scum, if there are 3 scum left the chances of tomorrow and the next day going well are

extremely

low. Effectively, it’s game over. So if there is any doubt in your mind about whether I am scum, you would do better to discuss it, and hope that there are only 2 scum. I won’t be voting until we have agreement on a lynch, and I urge you to do the same.

That out of the way – I was surprised at the violence of the reaction to my hammer (as it proved to be). I had been pushing jason’s lynch hard, for two days. I had said I was ready to vote him. I wanted him dead. Of course, I knew that if he was town, there was a good chance I was hammering. But I felt there was no more to be said. My vote post was short – but I’d given full and I think good reasons why I thought jason was scum elsewhere. Put yourself in my position as a townie – what else needs saying before that vote?

Some thoughts on who the scum are tomorrow.

[Netopalis]

I'm going to go ahead and put this down, because I think that this is you trying to stall until your buddies show up.

Vote:Fishythefish

Best start explaining.

[camn]

Wow. Darox = town?

Fishy... you are caught scum.
Finding your partners might be hard.
I am thinking Pman and DryFit.

We will know after today, unless one of them busses you.
Town: Lets get 3 votes up right quick.. then we can talk.

VOTE: FISHYTHEFISH

H

I agree with Neto completely.

[pman5595]

Vote: FishytheFish

[camn]

My vote post was short – but I’d given full and I think good reasons why I thought jason was scum elsewhere. Put yourself in my position as a townie – what else needs saying before that vote?

And no.. you knew he was researched, and you saw the chance to quickhammer.
One of your partners must be exceptionally town... and you figured you could afford getting quicklynched today. Hmm.
Maybe Jack? I think he is town... but he could be a godfather or something? I doubt that though.

Whoever it is, he might be bussing today, soas not to be totally obvious tomorrow. Let's play sharp. Heck.. maybe it is Neto? You two were both all over the night-end deadline, weren't you? Coordinating your movements in the QT?

[pman5595]

I mean,

Vote: FishytheFish

[camn]

Oh good.. that is three.

Looks like we caught them sleeping.

DO NOT UNVOTE under any circumstances!
We should have a lock on the deadline lynch... though hopefully one of you two is scum, and we can pick up the hammer before then. Which I suspect is the case.

[pman5595]

Ok, so scum is Fishy, dry-fit, darox?

[pman5595]

and by darox I mean jack

[camn]

I kind of think Netopolis.

He has a uber-townieness... they must be relying on him not getting force-lynched ever.

[pman5595]

I kind of think Netopolis.

He has a uber-townieness... they must be relying on him not getting force-lynched ever.

no, think of it this way. If there are scum on the wagon Fishy is town. I don't think there are any scum on the wagon.

[Netopalis]

Well, presuming that there is a 3-person scumgroup, I seriously doubt that they'd be so blatant as to hop on their partner at the same time. I'd guess that there's likely 1 scum on the wagon, plus Fishy and one person off of it.

[pman5595]

why would scum vote their buddy, though? They would try to vote a townie. I really think we beat all 3.

[Netopalis]

Because they know that there will be future days and they want to win when we have the same situation again tomorrow?

[Jack]

Well, fishy is scum, and camn is scum. I like how you come right into this day all anti-fishy with the whole strategy figured out camn.

I guess p-man for the last though I'm not quite sure of it.

What I wonder is, why was fishy willing to sacrifice himself for a lynch? Did he think it would win the game? I know I thought it was over.