Mini 931: Supreme Court Mafia (Game Over post 682)

[Jack]

Your question list at the beginning.

[Yosarian2]

Ah, well. Good game, everyone.

Yeah, I was breadcrumbing my innocent results on GC and Jack, I'm glad people noticed that. I was hoping I was going to live to day 3, get one more confirmed innoent, and then claim, and then with me and hopefully two living confirmed innocents, I thought the town might still have a chance. Sadly, it wasn't going to happen.

To the scum: did you notice my breadcrumbs? Was that why you killed me?

[Battousai]

Also, my apologies, Darox.... I was really egging you on there for a while. I hope you weren't too mad
Almost everything I accused you of I was actually doing intentionally.....

When you and Darox had your rounds, I was just mad the other towns didn't pick up on the fact that you refused to do something because you didn't want to do the work for scum (which was just looking to see who posted last, not like discovering bread crumbs). I wanted to just give Darox a 1-shot day vig ability ("As you sit down to think about who is doing the killing, you remember that you have a gun. You check the cartridge and notice it is empty, however there is a bullet in the chamber").

Neto played pretty good scum, IMO. If I was playing I may not have picked up on him being scum early, but might have through linking later if scum were lynched.

I expected the researcher would not be all that effective, maybe only working once. I expected that the veto holder would be a null role, as it isn't the most effective ability. I thought town was going into the game with the game tipped in their favor, but I obviously underestimated the researcher role.

[Darox]

I wanted to just give Darox a 1-shot day vig ability

That would have been so sweet.

[Jack]

(On N0, all roles acted at same time and Jack could have gotten a positive result).

damn...I thought it would do nothing, because I got the result of what they did the previous night.

[Netopalis]

Oh, that. What I said about it was true - I really did do it in two batches.

Battousai - The researcher role normally wouldn't be all that overpowered. However, on D2 and 3, it was fairly obvious who was going to get lynched the next day - or at least who there was a substantial probability of a bandwagon on.

[camn]

@ YOSARIAN

I didn't notice them until you were dead...

I voted you then because the good play would have been No-Lynch, I think... and I thought you would have been the only one with the clout to push it through.
Plus, I think you are very strong in endgame, and I wasn't relishing facing off against you

You and GC were pretty obvious targets to me. Both of you know my meta. And neither of you are swayed by my charms..

[Jack]

Boo, I totally misunderstood my role. I was thinking I could find track the killers, on top of not realizing I could send in N0...

[camn]

Lets put our QT up.
Pman wont care.. and if he does, Bat can take it down, no?

Here it is:
http://www.quicktopic.com/44/H/r6fr5BDvMQz

[pman5595]

this game was so scum sided, it was nearly impossible for us to lose.

This game also has reinforced my meta of acting town as scum and scum as town.

[Netopalis]

this game was so scum sided, it was nearly impossible for us to lose.

This game also has reinforced my meta of acting town as scum and scum as town.

Uh. You're doing it wrong.

[camn]

Also, my apologies, Darox.... I was really egging you on there for a while. I hope you weren't too mad
Almost everything I accused you of I was actually doing intentionally.....

When you and Darox had your rounds, I was just mad the other towns didn't pick up on the fact that you refused to do something because you didn't want to do the work for scum (which was just looking to see who posted last, not like discovering bread crumbs). I wanted to just give Darox a 1-shot day vig ability ("As you sit down to think about who is doing the killing, you remember that you have a gun. You check the cartridge and notice it is empty, however there is a bullet in the chamber")..

That would be SO unethical!
But I did enjoy the irony of that argument.
Especially when I accused him of "muddying up the thread" and the like.. directly after posting pages worth of nothing at all!

[Battousai]

this game was so scum sided, it was nearly impossible for us to lose.

This game also has reinforced my meta of acting town as scum and scum as town.

How so? Town had two investigative roles, a sane cop and a role that can find the scum's most powerful role (since Neto lied about not being a researcher, he would have been outted if he was previously investigated).

[camn]

I agree, Bat. I think we got lucky and leveraged the researcher role pretty well, wheras Jack got UNLUCKY and got nothing.

It also helped that we killed Yos's target right away....

I think it was balanced.

[Netopalis]

Well, scum had two roles that interfered with votes. That's much more powerful than a mere investigative role, at least it is to any scum who has an idea of what they're doing.

[pman5595]

2 scum power roles is too much. 3 for town and 1 for scum would be even.

And the Veto-holder is kind of a useless role. It would almost never actually be needed, and when it would be, it would show the likely alignment of the veto-holder and the would-be-lynchee

so 2 for town one for scum.

[Fishythefish]

btw, Fishy, if that wasn't a "I'm mafia hammering for the win" post I don't know what is. You had me convinced

TBH, I thought I was either town voting scum or town hammering the mafia win. In either case, I couldn't be bothered explaining myself, and didn't need to. Momentarily, I'd forgotten that today could happen in a real way. I'm glad that it didn't matter much - I'd have felt pretty thick.

A good job all round from the scum.

[jasonT1981]

Good game, but if Jack got a negitive on me, meaning I did nothing in the night... why did he vote me? lol

[Netopalis]

Only one member of the scumteam actually takes a night action - a no-action result means nothing.

[jasonT1981]

Ah, fair enough

[Green Crayons]

Oh well. Nice sweep scum.

[MeMe]

last post