ZOMBIES! - Zombies take over for the win!!!

[Starbuck]

@ABR - I have a limited number of shots.

@evil - Yos's posts were feeling very forced to me. It just didn't sit well at all.

[evilsnail]

And I would be the reason why SlySly didn't die, if you are indeed a vig. My power comes with a RBing ability while I investigate. This is what I was hinting at while asking Reck about whether his N1 and N2 results were the same.

If your power comes with a RB, why didn't you target Reckoner?

Well, I thought about that, but since xReck wasn't told he was RBed by me (he claimed to have normal results Night 2), which means he wasn't doing anything Night 2, I thought that there was too big a chance he wouldn't be doing anything Night 3 either. So, I felt like the info gained by investigating someone else was worth it.

[evilsnail]

Starbuck, could you give me specific examples? Did you indicate any of these feelings in-thread?

[Albert B. Rampage]

since xReck wasn't told he was RBed by me (he claimed to have normal results Night 2), which means he wasn't doing anything Night 2, I thought that there was too big a chance he wouldn't be doing anything Night 3 either. So, I felt like the info gained by investigating someone else was worth it.

Probably lied.

Vote: Reckoner

[Grimmy]

I still cannot beleive we let Reck live yesterday.

Vote: Reck

let the Re-cursing of us all begin anew

Grimmy
doesnt beleive that the best defense is being offensive

[Starbuck]

I really didn't. It was something that was in my mind though.

I know that doesn't help my case or anything, but it's normally the people that I'm null on that usually flip scum.

[Grimmy]

So why SlySly last night?
-@Starbuck

Grimmy

[Starbuck]

I haven't been able to figure out that player slot all game. He felt to me that he was purposely overdoing it, especially with his almost near constant spam.

[farside22]

"God has fled. Hell reigns. Darkness prevails."
- Priest, Shadow: Dead Riot (2005)

Reckoner (3) evilsnail, Grimmy, Albert B. Rampage

Not voting:

Wolframnhart
ODDin
animorpherv1
MrSuave
Starbuck
Percy
elvis_knits
xRECKONERx
SlySly
iLord
SpyreX

Day 4 deadline is April 26th, 9:00am PST
With 14 alive it will take 8 to lynch.

[Starbuck]

What is everyone's view on that last minute scrambling by CMAR?

[Starbuck]

Never mind, he died.

[Albert B. Rampage]

I was adamant that CMAR was town the entire time, but near the end he was acting a little weird.

[Albert B. Rampage]

evilsnail, why Starbuck?

[SpyreX]

Vote: Reck

Wow, what a surprise

[SlySly]

My power comes with a RBing ability while I investigate.

How many people can you detain per night?

[ODDin]

Starbuck, why the hell did you not claim vig yesterday? if you're telling the truth, it means somebody was most likely recruited N2.

evil, why did you not reveal your role fully yesterday?

[SlySly]

Evils, can you please, clearly list the people you have detained in the following manner.

N1: player(s), result(s)
N2: player(s), result(s)
N3: player(s), result(s)

TYVM.

[xRECKONERx]

OH HEY GUESS WHAT

Another innocent on Grimmy.

AND OH HEY GUESS WHAT

evil's claim evolves (conveniently) further.

[SpyreX]

God I didn't even think about that ODDin. Woosh.

Woosh this game.

And all the shenanigans going on to take a shot at Sly. Le sigh.

[iLord]

Yeah, that means evil could be a recruit is Starbuck's telling the truth. Starbuck, you really should've claimed yesterday >_>.

Starbuck, do you have any shots left?

Between the two, I"m still inclined to believe that RECK is the scum, mostly because of how he was overplaying the "OMG I"M COP YOU GUYS ARE ALL STUPID!" thing yesterday.

Vote: RECK

[SpyreX]

ES, if lying, would either be prescient or something funny is going on between ES and Starbuck.

Again, everything just like yesterday points to Reck being scum.

[SlySly]

Again, everything just like yesterday points to Reck being scum.

How so? Spell it out for me.

[SpyreX]

ES is either balls to the wall lucky (twice now he's had results on PR's and both, from his point of view, pointed to scum) or, in fact, does what his role does.

If that is the case, Reck targeted KMD. At a point where there would be no recruits.

Thus, Reck is scum.

[xRECKONERx]

Vote: evilsnail

I want to believe him. But his ever-evolving claim which

conveniently

evolves when he needs his claim to fit is too much to ignore at this point. Not to mention... if he thought I was scum, why the HELL would he not target me last night to stop me from killing anyone else?

Yeah, not buying it anymore.

[ODDin]

ES didn't find scum today - he investigated Starbuck and his finds are the same as what she said. So if he isn't scum, neither is Starbuck (most likely, although she could be faking the vig claim and telling her correct targets - if the targets are unique to a ZL. That is, only one ZL actually targets someone, the other does nothing. Which would she wasn't RBed but rather chose to do nothing, while another ZL killed CMAR.)
Another possibility is that ES and Starbuck are scum together, in which case they could've coordinated his "investigation" and her "claim" however they wanted during the night.
Also, we've suggesting the possibility of a scum role detector here (they found out that reck was a cop and recruit-es suicide-bombed him). This makes it much easier for reck to correctly "find out" the PRs. Notice that only after Starbuck said what happened es said "yeah, that's exactly what I found out".