Star Wars Mafia (Game Over)

[Slicey]

Wait... just thought of something. If you think about it, a town person with a cop ability wouldn't look for town players (what CMAR did), they'd look for scum players. CMAR agreed with wolf that there is two scumteams (when there is no evidence provided). I'm thinking CMAR to be some form of scum cop, looking to find an innocent player to look more town.

I think I might be on to something here...

Unvote, Vote: CryMeARiver

[CryMeARiver]

Wait... just thought of something. If you think about it, a town person with a cop ability wouldn't look for town players (what CMAR did), they'd look for scum players. CMAR agreed with wolf that there is two scumteams (when there is no evidence provided). I'm thinking CMAR to be some form of scum cop, looking to find an innocent player to look more town.

I think I might be on to something here...

Unvote, Vote: CryMeARiver

http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 229417#top
Can you please lay the fuck off now?

[CryMeARiver]

Wait... just thought of something. If you think about it, a town person with a cop ability wouldn't look for town players (what CMAR did), they'd look for scum players. CMAR agreed with wolf that there is two scumteams (when there is no evidence provided). I'm thinking CMAR to be some form of scum cop, looking to find an innocent player to look more town.

I think I might be on to something here...

Unvote, Vote: CryMeARiver

http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 229417#top
Can you please lay the fuck off now?

Look at TheFonz's post 7

[wolframnhart]

@CMAR

If it drives you crazy figuring out which alignment Dana can be in a game why did you not investigate her? I realize you said Farside was neutral but there wasn't anyone else that stood out to you to try to investigate?

[CryMeARiver]

@CMAR

If it drives you crazy figuring out which alignment Dana can be in a game why did you not investigate her? I realize you said Farside was neutral but there wasn't anyone else that stood out to you to try to investigate?

Read the above freakin posts

[wolframnhart]

Man you really get your dandruff up when questioned don't you?

I don't care what theFonz posted, I am asking

you

why you didn't investigate someone you have a hard time telling the difference of whether or not they are town.

[CryMeARiver]

Man you really get your dandruff up when questioned don't you?

I don't care what theFonz posted, I am asking

you

why you didn't investigate someone you have a hard time telling the difference of whether or not they are town.

I had no idea what I should do with a one shot investigation. Whether I should keep it for later in the game or use it N1 and try to clear/catch a person. I posted in that forum and TheFonz answer really stuck. So I investigated a prominent player who could either be town or scum and that would help later in the game knowing she is town.

Quick question: Was the Chancellor in Episodes 4-6? I'm pretty sure he wasn't, but I just wanted to check.

[wolframnhart]

Not as The Chancellor he wasn't.

[CryMeARiver]

Not as The Chancellor he wasn't.

That's what I thought. Just making sure there wasn't any Godfather possible flavor type role.

[wolframnhart]

Just because The Chancellor wasn't in ep 4-6 as The Chancellor doesn't mean there isn't and Godfather possible flavor type role.

[CryMeARiver]

Just because The Chancellor wasn't in ep 4-6 as The Chancellor doesn't mean there isn't and Godfather possible flavor type role.

Yes, I'm not counting the fact out, but he was the most likely

[wolframnhart]

Well I am sure The Chancellor wouldn't be a GF, Emporer yes. Even so they would have a safe claim, to claim Chancellor would more then likely be an immediate lynch.

[CryMeARiver]

Well I am sure The Chancellor wouldn't be a GF, Emporer yes. Even so they would have a safe claim, to claim Chancellor would more then likely be an immediate lynch.

I was looking more into the role of a godfather, he appears to be innocent (the Chancellor) but is actually guilty, rather than Godfather as just the machoman of the dark side (the Emperor).

[CryMeARiver]

@Town (and hidden scum I suppose): Is it necessary for me to full claim really?

[farside22]

@Town (and hidden scum I suppose): Is it necessary for me to full claim really?

I don't see why.

@Slicey: What crack are you smoking now?
Wolf is there any reason you don't believe CMAR and keep questioning his claim? Do you think his claim was scummy for some reason?

[AlmasterGM]

I don't see why not.

If he's already claiming one-shot cop, what harm is a full claim going to do, exactly?

[Wreck Star]

[Starbuck]

Btw, I've played the Star Wars LARP and it's all sorts of fun. =)

On CryMeARiver

[Starbuck]

It's typical BV. He's just mad because we were right about him.

Is this a reference to a different game? Also, Starbuck hates me, you don't. That's ironic

You realize that Starbuck was talking then, as she is now?

And I don't hate you. I just hate lurkers. You are getting better though. Much better than bv.

Weird thing is, they never use stun grenades in Star Wars...

DUDE..........................SERIOUSLY??

/sigh

I had a one shot investigation and supposed I'd use it on a prominent player who can act pro-town whether he is town or scum.

I'd say that's a good reason. I normally have a pretty hard time reading farside, but if you felt she was town, why wouldn't you investigate someone that you are suspicious of? Rather than clear someone who you already felt was town?

No chance Wolf could be scum now. He's 100% clear since his mason buddy is dead and flipped exactly what he said.
I am town. So is Farside.

YOU CANNOT CLEAR YOURSELF.

The only person who is cleared right now is Wolf.

Since I was only a one shot, I didn't want to risk investigating a scummy person as it wouldn't help us later in the game and an actual investigative role might investigate them as well.

What? I don't understand this.

Post 526 - Please tell me that you didn't just link to yourself talking about this game outside this thread?

On bv310

@bv - Not getting the Wreck Star obvscum ISO read. Care to elaborate?

I'm waiting on this too.

On Scott Brosius

Post 490 - L O L for being a hypocrite

On danakillsu

CMAR, if you're going to claim that much of your role, you should give us the name of your role so that we can confirm whether that fits. Until then, I'm suspicous of you for claiming without any real pressure.

Blatant rolefishing ftw!

FOS: danakillsu

Now Reck placed the vote on bv and not myself, for everyone voting for a lurker, why are you voting for that person vice people like...

DragonsofSummer
VRK
Toon Fighter
Scott

?

[wolframnhart]

@Farside

Only reason I am questioning CMAR is because twice now when I ask him something he gets really upset and snotty, and I am trying to figure out if I really do believe him or if he is scum trying to clear himself. Had I an investigation role I would have investigated the person i have the hardest time reading, which to me his hardest player is Dana, but that was his choice. If i truely didn't believe him right now I would vote him.

right now though we have a lot of non posters and I really do not like bv310 lurking his ass off since his vote against WreckStar.

[Toon Fighter]

bump

[anti-prod post]

Well, looking at CMaR's claim, I think the best move as town would be to lynch him. If he turns up innocent, then we just lynched a (now vanilla) townie and confirmed farside as innocent. If he turns up guilty, then we have just lynched scum. What do you think?

[ReaperCharlie]

I'll read more later, just checking the few new posts for now (Starbuck is right, DragonsofSummer, VRK, Toon Fighter, Scott, bv310, and quite a few others need to post more often)


ToonFighter, what sense AT ALL does it make to claim townie PR as scum? It doesn't. It brings you way too far out in the open and into the center of attention. I don't see CMAR as scum for the simple reason that he's obviously not that ballsy, especially after the way he 'got his dandruff up' at wolframnhart's questioning. Unless he is playing us masterfully, he is LIKELY a townie.

Not to mention, it'd be a waste of a townie, a waste of a lynch, and a waste of discussion time (our deadline is May 22, no use lynching before we use at least a good portion of that).

FoS: ToonFighter

[danakillsu]

I don't see why not.

If he's already claiming one-shot cop, what harm is a full claim going to do, exactly?

Precisely what I am saying.
@farside or CMAR
give one good reason for CMAR NOT to give his roleNAME. I've already given a very good reason for him to give his rolename
The wagon on me looks like misguided townies who don't understand exactly what I'm doing and one person (I wonder who?) who looks like a blatant OMGUS'ing scum. Did anyone else notice that he posted plenty between when I asked him to roleclaim and his vote, and yet his vote only came when his reasoning convinced other people to wagon me? My vote is DEFINITELY in the right place.

[ReaperCharlie]

@mod:

Btw, here is DragonsofSummer's ENTIRE iso:

vote ooba

just cause.

Sorry I have been absent guys, will read the game and post later tonight.

sorry about absence after promising a post, will post tonight.

He just comes back every 5 days and says 'Sry I'll post more.'
I don't think prods will work. Just replace him, please. Thx.

Love,
ReaperCharlie

[Scott Brosius]

Now Reck placed the vote on bv and not myself, for everyone voting for a lurker, why are you voting for that person vice people like...

DragonsofSummer
VRK
Toon Fighter
Scott

?

I feel like the others are just not posting (as opposed to actual lurking), while bv is attempting to play. The latter is more interesting/scummy as it cannot just be blamed on v/la or whatever. Also his random ISO on you revealing scum without explanation and then his disappearance don't sit well with me.

The idea to lynch CMAR is bad. If we are doing it because even if we lynch CMAR and he flips town, we then have a confirmed townie in farside, given the bounty, I do not see farside living through the night. So then we basically waste a lynch.

[AlmasterGM]

[DOS] just comes back every 5 days and says 'Sry I'll post more.'
I don't think prods will work. Just replace him, please. Thx.

+1.

[AlmasterGM]

[DOS] just comes back every 5 days and says 'Sry I'll post more.'
I don't think prods will work. Just replace him, please. Thx.

+1.