Vi wrote:hp [leaves] 829 wrote:It refers getting killed at night as malfunctioning and dying. At first I just thought it was flavor; but as EB got poisoned and malfunctioned due to that, it made me think poisoning is the only kill method in this game.
Hmm... That's plausible based on the first statement you made Today.
hp [leaves] wrote:I also think there's no mafia in this game. Just a SK. If there's a mafia, that win condition (3 points of every color) is
very hard
nearly impossible to achieve.
Mmm. Actually, I find the remark a bit odd in review. Why would it be harder for multiple partners to achieve something than a single SK? The opposite seems more likely. Attempting to discount links between players without reason is unhelpful.
Scum would also know whether it was their kill or not (unless they're a traitor), so an informed guess isn't really a town tell.
As for the role, it's a gut check but unverifiable; BP is a good claim for scum. This ups the stakes, but it's still down to whether he's scum or not. Nothing in the claim convinces me he isn't, so I'm content where my vote is at.