Rapture Mafia - Over!

[Knight of Cydonia]

I fail to see how being able to use Hypnotise on Big Daddies makes them more likely as a doctor role.

Because then they protect you (the main character). They're also constantly protecting Little Sisters. Ultimately, I think, that's their role in Bioshock. Can you think of a more fitting character that would be a protector? The only other person I think it could be would be the Russian chick.

Dr Tenenbaum makes far more sense as a Doctor role yes. If soras had claimed Big Daddy as Bodyguard, or even Vig, I would consider it more believable. But Big Daddies don't heal people. They stick a drill in your guts if you go near a Little Sister. That ain't healin'.

[MehPlusRawr]

Big Daddy as Doc is believable. What's the case on TF?

[xRECKONERx]

Unvote, Vote: don_Johnson

Quick, everyone iso him. It takes two minutes and is worth quite a laugh.

[xRECKONERx]

Unvote, Vote: don_Johnson

Quick, everyone iso him. It takes two minutes and is worth quite a laugh.

[xRECKONERx]

Unvote, Vote: don_Johnson

Quick, everyone iso him. It takes two minutes and is worth quite a laugh.

[xRECKONERx]

Unvote, Vote: don_Johnson

Quick, everyone iso him. It takes two minutes and is worth quite a laugh.

[Toon Fighter]

Huh? I thought chrono would be dead by now. Ok.

unvote

.

Will read the game and post again at a later time.

Why the bandwagon on me? I was just surprised to see that Chrono hadn't actually been lynched. I knwo I have been lurking, but I have been busy, and I bet I am not the one with less posts on this game.

You are voting for me based on three things:
- this post
- my initial lurking
- me believing soras claim? I don't know what else.
- I justified my attack on chrono, and I wasn't the only one who saw him scummy, as he was at L-1

I have just explained that post, and I am trying to post more.

Plus, have you looked at don_johnson? He voted for me with just: "wheeeeeeeeeee!

unvote, vote: toonfighter"
I bet he didn't even read the thread before that post! I am waiting for him to say more about that, but for now

vote: don_johnson

. Will read more of his posts and post later.

[Chronopie]

Quad posted for emphasis?

But you're right, active lurker alert.

[ReaperCharlie]

Quad posted for emphasis?

lol no kidding. haha

I should be caught up later today or tomorrow.

[Kise]

If I told you guys that bv was scum... would you believe it? Could you see it?

If I had to lie and claim daycop with a guilty, or lie detector that scanned something bv said and my machine went erratic... would you lynch him with me?

If I even had to say something as anti-town as "lynch me if I'm wrong and he's town" to convince you... would you take it?

I don't want any questions;

no wiggle room

. I'll get lynched if I'm wrong about him, fuck it. I'm not trying to steal Nacho's swagger with the secrecy, but now I believe that maybe, just maybe, I understand what he is relating to his suspicion of KoC -- let me go on record by saying I myself do not find KoC suspicious. With bv, this isn't a masked grudge lynch or PL. Nothing trivial, I promise. This isn't a bus or some usurper ploy, nor a lyncher thing.

Alternatively, don johnson is a lynch I also support since he (along with 72.22% of the rest of you) is not showing a serious sign of committal to the game. I replaced into the game and caught up, no prob. Then I got behind for a week, and still was able to catch up on new developments with no prob. So... I don't get it with the nonchalantness these other replacements are showing. And with me, my schedule is so hectic that it's a blessing to even be able to sit down and read through a game like this.

Lastly, I will say that I can see why TF would be an understandable lynch. However, some of the people who are voting for him (name check: Fate, bv, don, and Red to a lesser degree) make me feel uneasy. Lynching him I suppose would be worth the risk of not knowing the setup in full; as in the number of nightkillers and/or alignments.

[Chronopie]

I dislike those willing to make a 1:1 trade, such as Kise is offering. We either lose 2 townies (high % probability), or scum is making a gambit. Never the less, Would Bv310 please weigh in on this? seeing as he's the other party.

[SpyreX]

I like your moxyish but I'm doubly confused: why the hell aren't you voting for him if you want to dance the dance?

Me? I'll kill almost anyone. We've got a lurker problem and bv definitely falls that way.

[Chronopie]

EBWOP: what's more, if Bv and Kise are both town, it would allow any scum to hide behind a kise wagon, using his own 1:1 trade as explanation.

[xRECKONERx]

Fucking site problems.

[Budja]

Votecount

7 - Toon Fighter: (DeathSauce, horrordude0215, RedCoyote, SpyreX, Fate, don_johnson, bv310)
4- sorasgoof: (Knight of Cydonia, Drives, Nachomamma8, Chronopie)
2 - don_johnson: (xRECKONERx, Toon Fighter)
1 - Drives: (CryMeARiver)
1 - RedCoyote: (MehPlusRawr)
1 - MehPlusRawr: (sorasgoof)

Not Voting: ReaperCharlie, Kise

* = being replaced.

With

18

alive it will take

10

to lynch.

Deadline:

14th May

[Nachomamma8]

Alright, so let's be honest here. These wagons lately, they ain't doing much for us. They haven't been fun, they haven't been glorious, they just haven't been... WAGONS. So, we need the wagon to end all wagons.

It isn't Sora. Yeah, I know we all kinda want to lynch him because his manners are shitty and he doesn't know how to behave like a proper townie gentleman, but... he did claim doc. And we don't lynch claimed docs on day 1.

It isn't KoC. I mean yeah, that's the wagon with the most heart and the highest chance of hitting scum, but the time for his head must be wrapped around a noose is not now.

It isn't ToonFighter. Seriously, that's a crackhead wagon, and we don't do crackhead wagons here.

It isn't bv. That is, unless Kise doesn't mind being lynched first... The whole "I am not a lyncher" gives me a bad feeling 'bout him. Also, a question. If you see what I see about KoC, how can you not find him scummy?

So... wait? What is the best wagon to join, Mr. Nacho?

Vote: CMAR

If you aren't voting for him after you read this post, you had better have a DAMN good reason.

[xRECKONERx]

Thoughts on don?

[Chronopie]

So... wait? What is the best wagon to join, Mr. Nacho?

Vote: CMAR

If you aren't voting for him after you read this post, you had better have a DAMN good reason.

I remember my first newbie game... (911)

[don_johnson]

Thoughts on don?

don is open and receptive to questions. saying "he's lurking", but not offering him any carrots to nibble is just plain silly. don is actively voting and trying to obtain a lynch. without a lynch, day 1 is worthless. we're almost to 600 posts. thats one helluva bunch of crap to sift through on reread and what not. its not my fault people keep flaking off wagons. if you have a question, just ask. i am happy to answer you. the only section of this thread i haven't read is between page ten or so and when i replaced in. its about four pages(i think). i'll read through it if anyone gives me a reason. otherwise i am comfortable playing with what i did read when i replaced in and all that i have read until this point. what exactly is wrong with the toonfighter wagon?

[Chronopie]

Thoughts on don being active lurker?

[Fate]

Vote: CMAR

If you aren't voting for him after you read this post, you had better have a DAMN good reason.

I don't, but get some more votes on him before I join you again. CMAR vs. Toon Fighter are two pretty good competing wagons to have.

Kise's being weird and foolish and overconfident, not going that route.
Don_jonson is town.

CMAR and TF are left.

[RedCoyote]

Enough with the AtEs. Man up and actually try to defend yourself instead of whining about how everyone's playing and how everyone's against you.

I will, however, support a TF wagon.

Do you buy sora's claim, or do you think Toon is an okay/better lynch?

---

I knwo I have been lurking, but I have been busy, and I bet I am not the one with less posts on this game.

Do you think the one with "less" posts should be lynched today?

---

I'll get lynched if I'm wrong about him, fuck it. I'm not trying to steal Nacho's swagger with the secrecy, but now I believe that maybe, just maybe, I understand what he is relating to his suspicion of KoC -- let me go on record by saying I myself do not find KoC suspicious. With bv, this isn't a masked grudge lynch or PL. Nothing trivial, I promise. This isn't a bus or some usurper ploy, nor a lyncher thing.

I had an inkling, yes. His flip from sora to Toon seemed a little strange. I want to hear more from him before I make any rash decisions though.

---

It isn't ToonFighter. Seriously, that's a crackhead wagon, and we don't do crackhead wagons here.

I don't get this, "crackhead" wagon? I'll go back and make a case for Toon if necessary. I think we're on to something with him.

---

its not my fault people keep flaking off wagons.

I agree with this, to an extent. Do you think the Chrono/sora wagon should've been carried through to the end?

[RedCoyote]

Enough with the AtEs. Man up and actually try to defend yourself instead of whining about how everyone's playing and how everyone's against you.

I will, however, support a TF wagon.

Do you buy sora's claim, or do you think Toon is an okay/better lynch?

---

I knwo I have been lurking, but I have been busy, and I bet I am not the one with less posts on this game.

Do you think the one with "less" posts should be lynched today?

---

I'll get lynched if I'm wrong about him, fuck it. I'm not trying to steal Nacho's swagger with the secrecy, but now I believe that maybe, just maybe, I understand what he is relating to his suspicion of KoC -- let me go on record by saying I myself do not find KoC suspicious. With bv, this isn't a masked grudge lynch or PL. Nothing trivial, I promise. This isn't a bus or some usurper ploy, nor a lyncher thing.

I had an inkling, yes. His flip from sora to Toon seemed a little strange. I want to hear more from him before I make any rash decisions though.

---

It isn't ToonFighter. Seriously, that's a crackhead wagon, and we don't do crackhead wagons here.

I don't get this, "crackhead" wagon? I'll go back and make a case for Toon if necessary. I think we're on to something with him.

---

its not my fault people keep flaking off wagons.

I agree with this to an extent. Do you think the Chrono/sora wagon should've been carried through to the end?

[Fate]

Do you think the Chrono/sora wagon should've been carried through to the end?

The hell is the point of this question? Yes they should've gone through, and Chrono should've been lynched.

Mistakes happened, now Chrono is near confirmed town, and Soras is dead tonight. Are you dissatisfied with this outcome?

[RedCoyote]

Whoa, back up. Fate, you were the main proponent of stopping the Chrono wagon. Are you changing your mind?

And what do you mean what the point of the question is? don specifically said people were flaking off of wagons, I want to know if he thinks either the sora or the Chrono wagons shouldn't have been abandoned.

I am kind of dissatisfied with this outcome, yeah. I wouldn't have jumped back on sora personally. I think everyone who did is suspect.