First I'd like to say that I wrote this entire post after a full thread re-read during
Night 2. All of these observations are before mod reveals N2's results. I feel that
these notes, while possibly out of date, can still be useful to the town, so I'm
posting it as is. I'll "advise and extend my remarks" if necessary once
I read up on the nights events .
I'll almost exclusively focus on D2 however, since not much needs to be said about day 1
That being said: Nerd Observation - Am I the only one that thinks its awesome that Han took a shot at Boba Fett.
Geek out much? Only thing better would have been Greedo. LOLZ
Now on to D2 analysis:
Post 432: bv310 posts very soon after day begins and says he doesn't like WS's iso, and to
"trust him on this"
Post 490: Scott Brosius comes to wreck star's defense, then rolefishes.
Post 505: danakillsu defends the role fishing. People start dropping
Scott in favor of dana.
Post 525: Slicey focuses on CMAR's investigation. More focus
is taken off Scott. CMAR bw leads to eventual CMAR role claim
(premature much?).
Post 573: There's the yoda role claim, with posts later to breadcrumbs. To note is
CMAR's "I officially dislike Scott, dana (I've always disliked you), Toon, and SoG."
Pretty much my thoughts.
Post 574+: Dana starts getting (imo well deserved) suspicion. However, Scott gets lost
in the shuffle.
Post 588: sog and farside start getting into it. sog looks a little scummy to me
at the end of their exchange, in part because of CMAR's
roleclaim and it's apparent clearing of farside.
Post 610: FCG claims dana-Scott connection due to Scott defense of dana.
Post 627: Scott seems nervous about being setup for the next days lynch by ReaperCharlie
Post 633: bv claims investigation as reason for "trust me" in 432. That was my read
before I even got here. Wasn't going to say anything in this summary
for fear of outing power role. Can we please stop roleclaiming,
you already made your point without outing yourself.
Post 653: And then he full name claims Luke. WAS THIS NECESSARY? Good lord.
Post 674: WS claims Chewbacca using terrible fluff explanation. Possible
safe claim provided by mod? No one CC'd the Chewie or Lando, correct?
Would a Neutral get a mod provided safe claim? (New to forum mafia)
I think we can assume scum have mod provided safe claims but not
full role claims, as there have been two terrible fake claims.
Post 688: WS claims to have tracked SOG and saw him visit THC. They say all good
lies have a kernel of truth to them. This might be it?
Post 755: Really unfortunate it was 1 shot vig. Vig on SOG would have straightened
everything out. Fortunately Kast sees the WS scum and gets the final ball
rolling on WS.
Post 760: The bolding here is EXACTLY what I would have done.
Post 771:WS flips scum tracker. Major flag in SOG's direction.
Wrap up: After all of this my major opinions are
Town - CMAR, farside, wolf, bv, kast
Likely town - Reaper Charlie
Possible scum - dana
Likely scum - Scott Brosius, SOG
Vote: Scott Brosius
HOS: semioldguy
Hope I'm of much more help than the previous player in my slot. That's it for now.
Thanks for the game invite kdub. Glad to be in the game!
**PREVIEW EDIT** Night's results match what I've said perfectly. CMAR is confirmed. This confirms farside. I stand by what I've posted. Sorry if the format of this message is bad, I cut and pasted from my text editor.
