Nah, cancel that request.
Don't make me prawn you, shrimp. ~Vi
@Percy and Porkens, have the two of you ever played in a game together before?
I was following along with the game during day 1 with the idea of replacing at the time, so I had some thoughts from before the day 1 lynch:
Dramonic looks scummy for his active lurking.
Dramonic being scum suggests that Nikanor is town.
DDD is right to derail the Nik wagon, but why not lynch Dramonic?
Given Nikanor's flip, I'm feeling much less certain about my scumread on Dramonic. My read on him is confused, but he's more likely town than scum.
People seem really focused on L-1. The rules don't imply that being at L-1 is necessarily the trigger for the "one last shot" abilities, regardless of the one sample role PM. While it may be a good idea to pause a lynch wagon when it reaches L-1, I see no reason to wagon someone just because it could potentially give them an ability.
I don't think I've ever seen Porkens as scum before. His willingness to accept almost any day 1 lynch and his interest in 'handing out abilities' are not scumtells for him, as he has played that way as town. But I also have the feeling that he was playing to his meta and milking it on day one -- the only serious stance I can recall his making was on Dramonic. Also, his early posts directed at dramonic, then pomegranate, remind me of Rhinox (who was scum) throwing mud at Porkens and me during Mafia Reverberation.
Porkens 46 - votes Dramonic for saying Percy might not realize the game had begun
Porkens 51 - it's weird to ask why Dramonic didn't defend Tony in the same way as Percy when no one was attacking Tony. Dramonic was clearly responding to Seraphim's 'die lurker die' comment, so defending only Percy as opposed to both of them was clearly reasonable.
Pomegranate 53 - buys into Porkens's idea, and I don't understand why.
Jahudo 58 - is a good summary of the above.
Porkens 129 - a major shift from "give Tony a power by putting him at L-1" to "hang him so he gets ghost powers"
As d3x pointed out in post 135, Porkens was also dodging questions, which I don't recall ever seeing him do before.
Porkens, is Dramonic scum?
Jahudo said Porkens would be easier to read from day 2. Jahudo, what is your read on him?
Pom needs to post more.
Pomegranate wrote:But let's say that I don't like it when people think that I am scum.
I don't think you're going to like me in this game. You've been hiding in the background, and no one (other than SOG) has called you out for it. Your reactions to other peoples' discussions of SOG, Jahudo, VP, and Cobalt on day 2 looks like following the crowd.
I could see the VP/Jahudo argument D2 as possibly town-town due to the nature of their back and forth posts.
They each argue that the other gave some indications of not lynching Nik D1, and they're right in that regard. But they both argued for lynching him and voted him when they had other options.
DDD, you've managed to be off the scum-lynch and on the town-near-lynch without giving me scum vibes. You've been focused on Tony/SOG since about page 1. Now that the Tony/SOG playerslot is gone, who is scum?
I can't tell from here whether Percy's late D1 play makes him a Nikanor buddy, but Nikanor's D1 play makes Percy not look like a Nikanor buddy.
d3x looks town.
Just because a majority of a group of people decide it's okay doesn't mean it's not murder. - Cobblerfone
