Pledge of Allegiance (Game Over! Page 76)

[UncertainKitten]

A scum tracker WOULD be something Vi would do. And any lynch that's not mafia is a mislynch FOR the mafia.

Fun theory.

But, anyway, Nico, your last post does nothing to assuage the fact you are scum and since it FINALLY appears a wagon on you is starting, despite my failed efforts in the past to get you lynched,

##Unvote, Vote Nico

[Plum]

When did this happen?

A few days ago.
Am I the only one that wants all the non-obvtown people to claim?

Nope, you're not the only one.

I'm okay with a Nico wagon, still like the Zorblag one, let's see a votecount and we'll settle it up.

[farside22]

Literally half of farside's posts are solely about how fishy should be lynched. She has said nothing else today.

Nope I'm being stubborn and childish.
I believe he is lying scum deal with it.

[Chronopie]

Tunnel Vision on a Lying, potentially anti-town other.

--

I don't see why

Every

non-obvtown player should claim, you want to out any Docs, the Bus-driver that Fishy claims exists, and any other pro town PRs that aren't already (such as a vig)? An MC isn't going to blow this game wide open this early.

Although we know that at least 6 people chose other, and there's some suspicion on several others being other. I'd expect an Sk after all.

--

@Fishy: no it wasn't an answer to anything, it was separating the known non-town PR from the Town/unknown alignment PRs.

[LlamaFluff]

Literally half of farside's posts are solely about how fishy should be lynched. She has said nothing else today.

Nope I'm being stubborn and childish.
I believe he is lying scum deal with it.

At least answer me this.

Why would a scum RB not target a softclaimed PR or regarded town player over someone that is a lynch prospect? That is what is making me think driver and fishy targeted some pro-town looking player, along with the scum RB.

[popsofctown]

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/You%27re_e ... against_us


http://youtube.com/watch?v=pSwy412nttI&feature=related

[Chronopie]

and that's a False Dichotomy, non-hostiles aren't with or against either side. OTOH Hostiles are against everyone.

[Chronopie]

although Fishy did state that a town win was worth some points in his wincon...

[StrangerCoug]

@SC: Well, yeah, you have to say that now, or else you admit you're scum .

One of us was clearly misguided on the matter, and I was ready to accept it was me if that proved to be the case.

@Fishy: You are not town. That is why the town should lynch you. Are you as dumb? Seriously what type of question is that.
Fishy not town = lynch.

##Vote: farside22

. This is coming off as a policy lynch of absolutely anybody not town, and hunting for Mafia should be priority.

[UncertainKitten]

@SC: Elaborate on why farside is scummy. Explain how her actions benefit scum.

[Jack]

@UK: didn't you answer your own question at the top of the page?

[UncertainKitten]

I'm not asking why I think farside could potentially be scum, I'm asking why SC thinks she could potentially be scum, and I'd prefer NOT to have answers handed to my suspects so I can get original thought out of them, k thanks.

[Jack]

psst Coug, just paraphrase UK where she said "A scum tracker WOULD be something Vi would do. And any lynch that's not mafia is a mislynch FOR the mafia. "

[DrippingGoofball]

and that's a False Dichotomy, non-hostiles aren't with or against either side. OTOH Hostiles are against everyone.

In this post we learn that Chronopie is an OTHER.

[Plum]

It's plausible but I disagree that the quote shows it and it's not a big concern at this point either way.

[UncertainKitten]

Oh dammit Jack recruited SC in his no hostile cult .

[Jack]

The weirdness of his fishy explanation could fit with him being an "other" investigator from one of the factions opposed to fishy's.

His jump at claiming "town cop" is a bit odd, considering he didn't actually get a "guilty/innocent" type result.

[Jack]

Oh dammit Jack recruited SC in his no hostile cult .

Recruitment gives us the ability to talk publicly in the thread.

[LlamaFluff]

and that's a False Dichotomy, non-hostiles aren't with or against either side. OTOH Hostiles are against everyone.

In this post we learn that Chronopie is an OTHER.

I dont think so... him claiming like he did today was really stupid if he is and I have to think he would run by a fake(?) result with partners who would

laugh at him

discourage him from doing so.

on the other hand, im betting if this is a 2-2-2 non-hostle, you can find two of them on this wagon

fishythefish ( 5 ) farside22 charter Debonair Danny DiPietro Zorblag Chronopie

I think that would be farside and one of DDD/charter. I had a strong town read on charter, but he is playing most like what I would expect non-fishy other to be playing. Farside gut has been going crazy on all game but I for the life of me cant find anything to back it up. DDD.... ehhh... I just dont have a super strong town read on him. I want to say he is town but something is causing me to think hard about it, and I can see him being non-hostle other as the reason behind that.

I also have one more request (yes im being needy today). Can someone make sure im around about at the time a hammer is thrown down? One more thing showed up that I want to do, but it wont be horribly devistating if I cant.

[DrippingGoofball]

and that's a False Dichotomy, non-hostiles aren't with or against either side. OTOH Hostiles are against everyone.

In this post we learn that Chronopie is an OTHER.

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

@DDD - and actually everyone else who thinks I should be lynched: to what extent do you think my claims are true?

I believe your general claim of being an other rather than a SK or mafia aligned. What I'm not very inclined to believe is that your presence and "points" actually benefit the town.

But I think the chance of your lynch has deflated and I think the Nico wagon which I was repping yesterday and today is finally growing and has the chance to actually lynch scum instead of an other who doesn't have the town's best interest at heart.

##Unvote
##Vote: Nicodemus

[DrippingGoofball]

and that's a False Dichotomy, non-hostiles aren't with or against either side. OTOH Hostiles are against everyone.

In this post we learn that Chronopie is an OTHER.

Sorry for duplicate, I refreshed the wrong screen.

[LlamaFluff]

and that's a False Dichotomy, non-hostiles aren't with or against either side. OTOH Hostiles are against everyone.

In this post we learn that Chronopie is an OTHER.

Sorry for duplicate, I refreshed the wrong screen.

I would actually like to hear some elaboration on this, even though I dont think it will change too much for me.

I just can not see chrono pulling what he did today as anti-town

[Chronopie]

The weirdness of his fishy explanation could fit with him being an "other" investigator from one of the factions opposed to fishy's.

His jump at claiming "town cop" is a bit odd, considering he didn't actually get a "guilty/innocent" type result.

No, I got a town/

Not Town

Result. Same difference.

[RedCoyote]

Anyway, time to make things worse: I

will not

visit the PGO tonight.

Okay.

##Unvote
##Vote: Fishythefish

---

Oh Hai RC, why did you vote Jack again?

Because I've never been more sure of an anti-town role in my life... except for Fishy, of course.

---

Where did he say investigation? I don't recall him saying his role is investigative.

Chrono is right. I don't think it's necessary to elaborate beyond that until I have something to actually offer the town, but yeah.

---

I must admit that I feel completely out of my depth in this game. I just got done reading through the thread, and I still have precious few suspicions.

Well, you should look at that Nico guy for rolefishing... oh wait.

Seriously though, I agree with you on the first part. Frankly, I think we've got quite a few third parties who are trying to confuse the town into leaving them (and their buddy Fishy) alone because there's a huge looming scum faction or factions out to get us that is much more pressing.

That may or may not be the case, but look it, when you've caught someone who is surely anti-town, then you take care of business. You don't leave him alone because he talks a pretty game about how he's 90% on your side.

A least that's how I was raised to play mafia. What do you think, Nico?

---

A scum tracker WOULD be something Vi would do. And any lynch that's not mafia is a mislynch FOR the mafia.

This is coming off as a policy lynch of absolutely anybody not town, and hunting for Mafia should be priority.

Wrong answers, Fishy friends.

I don't get what the reservations are. He's said he isn't town. He said he's not going to obey the town's orders (even after this whole argument on, "We can keeps Fishy around only if he follows orders!"). He's throwing around nondescript actions that are roleblocking town PRs. Why do you want to keep him around other than this paranoid, "...but, but the mafia!" routine?

Maybe because you have a personal interest in keeping Fishy alive? Hmmm? No one is saying that we should drop everything and ignore mafia or SKs or cults or whatevers. Let's not allow this branches of government group to continue to fester, potentially stealing a win from the town despite how lucky we are against any other factions.