Mini 967 - Mafia War (Over)

[Empking]

Unvote

Vote: AC

AC: Are the first and last quotes in your post, separate posts?

[Amish_Charney]

No, they're not.

[Exemption]

EBWOP: "Why lynch Me=weird first and not unsight?"

because if they are both scum it doesn't matter the order. however if one of them is not then its likely that the other is not (Not guaranteed because of multi scum game). Personally I would much rather to have an active member like unsight alive than someone who has gone to a horse show ect.

ohh and just my opinion but I don't think unsight was lurking.

[Stef]

Hmm.. if they are both scum I'd rather have nub-scum than active and manipulative scum D2 to be honest. It makes more sense to me so that's why I'd still rather we lynch Unsight first.

I'll wait till tomorrow to see if the Unsight case gets enough heat for a lynch. If not, I'll go for Me=Weird but please weigh in both options.

Also, I think we need a lynch atm. Discussion has run out on most subjects (something going on in the AC corner but otherwise...) and a flip would probably be the most helpful. Me=Weird is at L-2.

[Exemption]

Hmm good point. I'll go ether way on those two. Both will give us information. I do suspect some others still though.

[Unsight]

Hmm.. if they are both scum I'd rather have nub-scum than active and manipulative scum D2 to be honest. It makes more sense to me so that's why I'd still rather we lynch Unsight first.

I'll wait till tomorrow to see if the Unsight case gets enough heat for a lynch. If not, I'll go for Me=Weird but please weigh in both options.

Also, I think we need a lynch atm. Discussion has run out on most subjects (something going on in the AC corner but otherwise...) and a flip would probably be the most helpful. Me=Weird is at L-2.

Not in favor of lynching Unsight because she's town. I also think that Amish_Charney guy is way scummier than Me=Weird.

So Stef, what do you think of Amish_Charney? After all these pages and posts regarding him, what's your read on him?

[Snow_Bunny]

-Vote Count-

Amish_Charney (3) - Unsight, Hrezs, Empking
Hrezs (0)
pman5595 (0)
Unsight (1) - Stef
horrordude0215 (0)
Soundwish (0)
Katsuki (1) - Me=Weird
Stef (0) -
deadjoker (0)
Me=Weird (5) - horrordude0215, Exemption, Amish_Charney, pman5595, deadjoker
Exemption (1) - Soundwish,
Empking (1) - Katsuki

Not voting - No one

It's seven to lynch.

Me=Weird is at L-2.

Deadline is on 26 May 2010.

[Katsuki]

So we have 3 more days until deadline, and are semi-torn between me= and AC.

Unvote, Vote AC

I do not necessarily think he is more scummy than me=, but I do not wish to put me= at L1. However, imo a case can be better made on AC because he has more posts and substance for us to analyze, but as I said earlier, I have not liked me='s play. AC's last post trying to paint Unsight as a lurker has moved me to vote.

[Amish_Charney]

...a case can be made on me because I haven't been posting... that is... I haven't been lurking, unlike that person you're not voting for.

Confused Amish is confused.

[Katsuki]

"...a case can be made on me because I haven't been posting..."

huh? Definately did not say that. Said you have posted while me= hasn't. I think both of you are lynchable. Me= precisely for all the lurking and non-existant contribution, and you, well, you're the next after me= on my scumlist.

[Amish_Charney]

Misprint I my part. I apologize.

[Amish_Charney]

sorry, on my part.

[Stef]

Hmm.. if they are both scum I'd rather have nub-scum than active and manipulative scum D2 to be honest. It makes more sense to me so that's why I'd still rather we lynch Unsight first.

I'll wait till tomorrow to see if the Unsight case gets enough heat for a lynch. If not, I'll go for Me=Weird but please weigh in both options.

Also, I think we need a lynch atm. Discussion has run out on most subjects (something going on in the AC corner but otherwise...) and a flip would probably be the most helpful. Me=Weird is at L-2.

Not in favor of lynching Unsight because she's town. I also think that Amish_Charney guy is way scummier than Me=Weird.

So Stef, what do you think of Amish_Charney? After all these pages and posts regarding him, what's your read on him?

Nobody asked you.

On the AC subject.. lol.

Empking has not mentioned AC ALL GAME and now votes for him without a second's notice and without a case. Come to think of it, empking hasn't made any cases all game. Just asked people questions, never commented on them, kept asking for a claim when noone else did. I started with a town read on him but lately, looking over, it has shifted completely. My suspicions of him started before his latest vote as you can see here.

EMPKING: Will you be so kind as to answer the things I've asked you in THIS POST or will you continue to ignore them?

Also, what do you think about the Unsight case?

Katsuki, AC

What do you think of the Unsight case?

----------------------------

To answer Unsight and to address the AC wagon:
He is a null player pretty much like Me=Weird. Difference is he hasn't dropped so many tells. His vote on me was.. well.. groundless, his vote on unsight seemed like a good vote at the time since I agreed that Unsight was doing nothing but asking people questions and that does not constitute scum-hunting (not that AC was doing any). After being voted by Unsight he calls it "Supremely anti-town" which is... lol. Very bad defense and scummy. However.. meh. All this + inactivity make a mid-scummy anti-town player.

@Hrez: just noticed something, you said "Stef's policy lynch post", I never said anything about a policy lynch. For me it's a decent scum-tell and a good place to start hunting.

My Scumdar atm is set around:
1. Unsight
2. Me=Weird
3. Empking/Pman
4. AC

I'm gonna go on a limb and say there are at least two scum on this list. I guess we shall see by the end of this game.

=======================

Unsight is first because he has dropped the most scum tells: Twisting words, creating distractions, trying to stop a lynch without recognizing it, self-contradictions. Nobody else in this game has flipped so many tells from my book.

Me=Weird is only second do to the connection I see with Unsight. Otherwise he would be on #3 having Pman (who has almost disappeared and who's tells I'm not forgetting) and Empking (read above for reasons) on #2. AC for me is at #4, very close to Me=Weird but not equal because AC hasn't made any outright anti-town posts.

Later Edit: Just looked over Me=Weird's posts... still don't see much there. Just getting the vibe of newbness and a connection to Unsight. Not getting a town read on him but not a strong scummy one either. I want Unsight lynched first.

[Soundwish]

Hang on, what is the AC case? Seems to have sprung up out of nowhere. At this point I would go back to Me=Weird for a deadline lynch, but I would really much rather go for Exemption or deadjoker, as I have mentioned before.

[Empking]

The Unsight case is awful.

The answers to your questions are: We were near deadline and I didn't want us to have to rush a lynch.

[Katsuki]

I would personally prefer to wait to analyze unsight tomorrow. IMO there is not enough time for us to get a proper discussion on his case for his lynch going now.

[Stef]

Empking, is that your best? Give reasons, don't be a lazy arse.

Katsuki, some of us have been discussing the Unsight case for a few days now. What kept you?

[Stef]

EBWOP: Empking, you seem to have a deficit in reading, I'll give you a hand since you cba to click a damn link since I made it easy for you.

Why have you been pushing for a claim before Me=Weird was at L-1 and before anyone else expressed any intention of sealing his fate?

Why are you pushing for a claim at all? Even if he were a power role, how would it be helpful for the town for him to claim?

[Hrezs]

did I say stef policy lynch post?
i meant me= (unless.. someone else this game has made a post like that that I dont remember)

[horrordude0215]

Stef, how could someone be "Null and possibly scum"?

FTR... Still waiting for an answer on this. This was one of the most wishy washy things I've ever heard. Ever.

[Stef]

Missed it. Null = not helpful, possibly scum = scummy? Don't get what you're hitting at.

[Katsuki]

Katsuki, some of us have been discussing the Unsight case for a few days now. What kept you?

I am not entirely sure of my read on unsight. I am not gonna jump in when I am not sure of my own thoughts and analysis. Considering I have seen a similar style of play before, he does not immediately jump out at me as scum. As such, he is still neutral-ish in my eyes.

[Unsight]

Hang on, what is the AC case? Seems to have sprung up out of nowhere. At this point I would go back to Me=Weird for a deadline lynch, but I would really much rather go for Exemption or deadjoker, as I have mentioned before.

Lots of things will seem to "spring up out of nowhere" when you only post once every two days.

Why Exemption or deadjoker?

[Soundwish]

Hang on, what is the AC case? Seems to have sprung up out of nowhere. At this point I would go back to Me=Weird for a deadline lynch, but I would really much rather go for Exemption or deadjoker, as I have mentioned before.

Lots of things will seem to "spring up out of nowhere" when you only post once every two days.

Why Exemption or deadjoker?

That's quite funny, you suggest that my posting rate implies I am not reading the thread, when in fact, you are clearly not reading the thread if you have to ask that question. I have already said that Exemption and deadjoker joined the Me=Weird wagon scummily. I found it curious that this was ignored.

[Amish_Charney]

mod- Some things came up at work- I will be V/LA until the end of tomorrow