Mini 968 - Bastard Mass Effect (Game Over)

[VP Baltar]

Thanks for answering for bv, doombunny.

[Fate]

"This is one of the posts that Fate isn't going to read."
This is one of the posts that Fate will skim quickly.

Nominate: TonyMontana

Best Mod ever....

Anyway, so what do we have here? Doombunny (neutral/scum) softdefending BV(neutral/scum) AND attacking VP (town)?

We can't have that. We can't have that at all.

Now we just need Bv to post to put all the pieces together.

[bv310]

Alright. I present to you: the world-famous bv310 catchup post!

First off,

Are you masons or neighbors? Masons are confirmed town. If bv310 masonized you and confirms this, then I'm not interested in lynching Reck. If not, then his lying comes into question.

We are Neighbours. My role allows me to choose one person during the game and "sync minds" with them. I wish I could have been here over the night, to actually utilize the ability, but it's still there. I chose Reck initially because he seemed pretty townie, but when I was trying to help him find a target, I started to get suspicious of him. Not sure what to make of him now, but I'm leaning town. The few posts he's had in the QT seem genuine. I'm thinking Doombunny could be a GF, or Reck just sucks with his gun.

Next up,

EBWOP:

... Luke died last night didn't he. I feel so retarded.

unvote

*High-fives*

Third,

I don't really like the bv wagon. Fate's reasoning I can go with, even if I'd rather lynch someone else. VP on the other hand has a very crappy reason to vote him.

Lulz. You're coming on a little strong there, Mr. Godfather. "Hey look, a townie's being voted with little to no conviction! Time to step up and be a hero." A wagon is more than two votes.

Also, it was a check-in post. That's what people usually do when they come back from V/LA.

So, in conclusion,

Vote: Doombunny

Also, since Reck already outed my whole damn role, I'm Liara.

[Fate]

Besides him softdefending you and xRECK's shots not killing him, why do you find Doom scummy?

[VP Baltar]

Why do you think he's a Godfather?

[VP Baltar]

stupid MS.

Is it just the UNK or do you have another reason?

[Doombunny9]

Thanks for answering for bv, doombunny.

He already answered the question before you even asked it. Did you expect him to change his mind about if it were a check in post or something?

Lulz. You're coming on a little strong there, Mr. Godfather. "Hey look, a townie's being voted with little to no conviction! Time to step up and be a hero." A wagon is more than two votes.

This makes no sense at all. When I see something scummy I do something about it. What did you want me to do? Stay silent and let VP off scotch free? I don't think so.

[TonyMontana]

Not everyone at once. I mean, you have 4 days, be cool.

[xRECKONERx]

Vote: Doombunny

if I'm not already. If he is unNKable, he needs to be lynchlynchlynched.

[Fate]

This makes no sense at all. When I see something scummy I do something about it. What did you want me to do? Stay silent and let VP off scotch free? I don't think so.

What exactly is scummy about being the second vote on a wagon on a lurker who has contributed SFA to this game and needs pressure?
I think you're a little

too

sure Bv is town. That slap on the wrist of VP's votes almost makes me certain that you were trying to make him look bad in the event of a Bv flip.

Not everyone at once. I mean, you have 4 days, be cool.

THE MOD DEMANDS BLOOOD

Unvote:
Vote: Doombunny

Miles ahead of a xRECK lynch.

[Fate]

This makes no sense at all. When I see something scummy I do something about it. What did you want me to do? Stay silent and let VP off scotch free? I don't think so.

What exactly is scummy about being the second vote on a wagon on a lurker who has contributed SFA to this game and needs pressure?
I think you're a little

too

sure Bv is town. That slap on the wrist of VP's votes almost makes me certain that you were trying to make him look bad in the event of a Bv flip.

Not everyone at once. I mean, you have 4 days, be cool.

THE MOD DEMANDS BLOOOD

Unvote:
Vote: Doombunny

Miles ahead of a xRECK lynch.

[VP Baltar]

yo doombunny...you UNK?

[Doombunny9]

If he is unNKable, he needs to be lynchlynchlynched.

As far as I know, I am not NK immune. Also, even if I was, why lynch me for that reason alone? Can there not be a NK immune townie? Also, still missing your case

What exactly is scummy about being the second vote on a wagon on a lurker who has contributed SFA to this game and needs pressure?

If you were to look back you would see that my suspecting him isn't because I think bv is town but its because of his constant vote-hopping (usually for little reason at all).

[VP Baltar]

ninja'ed

Anyhow, do you believe in meta doomb?

[Doombunny9]

Anyhow, do you believe in meta doomb?

Metaing is fine, just as long as it's not the only thing you're using. For example, if Person A voted Person B for the sole reason that "By looking at meta they're acting like they do when they play scum instead of when they play town". Then Person A has a very weak case, if he had something else to go with it (say for example: Person B has been scummy throughout the game and the meta is only backup and a lesser part of the case) then it would be fine. On the flip side, your defense to me ("But I vote hop when I'm town! Look at my meta!") is also very flimsy unless you had something else to defend yourself too (which you didn't).

Anyway, that is probably way more than I probably needed to do for a simple question but I don't really have that much to do and I was bored XD

[TonyMontana]

Limerickx, Col.Cathart and Kerristar prodded

[Col.Cathart]

Gah, exam hell + AC/DC concert this evening. Post coming either today late in the night or tomorrow morning.

[VP Baltar]

On the flip side, your defense to me ("But I vote hop when I'm town! Look at my meta!") is also very flimsy unless you had something else to defend yourself too (which you didn't).

How is it flimsy? My guess is that you didn't even bother to look. If I vote hop as town, then how the frak can you call it a scumtell on me? You're clearly grasping at straws and picked the wrong one.

Anyhow, I was busy the last two days and I need to give this game a full reread tonight. Deadline is looming and we clearly need some significant discussion going. I'm find with a doombunny lynch today, but xLimerick has said shit for all today and I'm not really a fan of that...so he can die too.

Fate and reck are pretty far in my town column...but compared to everyone else that's not saying much. Col. still looks confirmed town since I don't think there is a third party and he had no reason to counter vig claim if he was scum. That leaves a pretty small lynching pool where the scum HAS to be imo.

Kerristar, you should already know where to look tonight I think.

[lukepukeduke]

Vote: Doombunny

I'd like you all to take notice of the fact that this post would have put luke on my blacklist, had it not been for the fact that he already was.

[VP Baltar]

Vote: Doombunny

[Limerickx]

I really just don't see anything crazy about Doombunny which makes him a better target than xRECKx.

I don't know why people are so cool with straight-up lying twice.

Seriously, am I missing something? What has he done which is so townlike which makes it cool to overlook this?

[Limerickx]

I really just don't see anything crazy about Doombunny which makes him a better target than xRECKx.

I don't know why people are so cool with straight-up lying twice.

Seriously, am I missing something? What has he done which is so townlike which makes it cool to overlook this?

Side note: I have reason to believe that DB's (scum or not) non-death is unrelated to any scumblocking skills. Just saying.

[Doombunny9]

Luke- You're dead. Deal with it.

How is it flimsy? My guess is that you didn't even bother to look. If I vote hop as town, then how the frak can you call it a scumtell on me? You're clearly grasping at straws and picked the wrong one.

I did look and while I can verify this, using meta as your only defense isn't that good of your defense. You did something scummy and I caught you. I don't care how many times you've done it before, it's still going to be scummy.

[TonyMontana]

Arrrrrgh ffs, why is ms so retarrrrrrrded sometimes

[VP Baltar]

So doombunny, you freely admit that I do something as town and yet that is scummy to you...forgive me if I'm unmoved.

@ Limerick - have you ever played with xRx before?