NY 114: Mafia vs. Werewolves (Game Over)

[Midnight's Sorrow]

If you do flip scum, I will be looking harshly at Midnight's Sorrow for trying to buy you time to defend yourself when you were already doomed.

Is this supposed to scare me?

...If so, it isn't working all that well

[Parama]

Lynch proof was part of the Crapclaim.

You're still lynched.

[Unsight]

How could Unsight knew he was a werewolf and not a mafioso?

That has to do with Unsight's role though... How would this be any reflection on chrono? If Unsight is ww, then its WIFOM. If Unsight is Mafia, then it means Unsight knows that they aren't the same alignment. If Unsight is Town, then it's baseless.

Er, I don't "know" anything for sure.

My theory is that Chronopie was trying to guide the mafia kill by dropping hints that masons could be cops or werewolves. If Chronopie flips WW then it's 99% certain there's no scum in the mason group as I really don't see scum painting that big of a target on themselves. One dead scum and three mostly-confirmed townies would be pretty nice to have on Day 2.

[MichelSableheart]

Seventeenth vote count of day 1:

animorpherv1 (0):
askbob (0):
Chronopie (13):

Unsight, Leafsnail, Dry-fit, foilist13, Super Smash Bros. Fan, vezopiraka, LynchMePls, SerialClergyman, Parama, nhammen, Pomegranate, Timeater, Dr. Robotnik

Dr. Robotnik (1):

Sevis

Dry-fit (0):
Faraday (0):
foilist13 (0):
Leafsnail (1):

The Goat

Lowell (1):

askbob

LynchMePls (0):
Midnight's Sorrow (0):
nhammen (1):

pman5595

Parama (0):
pman5595 (0):
Pomegranate (1):

Chronopie

SerialClergyman (0):
Sevis (2):

Vi, Lowell

SGRaaize (0):
Super Smash Bros. Fan (0):
The Goat (0):
Timeater (0):
Unsight (0):
vezopiraka (0):
Vi (0):

Not Voting (4):

SGRaaize, Faraday, Midnight's Sorrow, animorpherv1

With 24 players alive, it takes 13 votes to lynch someone.

---

LynchMePls will have limited access from wednesday 26th till monday 1st.

Faraday might be V/LA for the next couple of days.

No activitycheck, because a lynch just ended the day. Any unresponded prods will not lead to replacements.

---

The villagers were confident that they were able to handle these threats. They were far less confident when it came to actually determining who the threats were, though. Discussions became loud and heated, accusations flew this way and that. As the day went on, slowly but surely a consensus was reached.

"Chronopie's a dirty scumbag!", one villager shouted. "I've never trusted him!" someone else responded. Suddenly, a mob formed, dragging their loudly protesting victim to the nearest tree. Some eager hands provided the rope, and Chronopie decided not to fight the inevitable. Shortly afterwards, a limp body was all that remained of him.

That limp body didn't suffer any strange transformations. In fact, it seemed completely normal. A thorough search of his clothes also didn't reveal anything unusual. An old clay pipe and a bent nail could hardly be considered weapons. It seemed that the villagers had made a mistake.

Chronopie has been lynched day 1. He is now dead. He was a Pro-town Vanilla Townie.

Tired and disappointed, they went to bed. Being outside at night with such scum roaming through the village was way too dangerous. Still, they feared what they would see when dawn would come.

Day 1 has ended, it is now night. Night 1 will last at least till sunday the 30st of may, 1 am GMT+1. It is likely that the night will last slightly longer though, because I may not be awake at that time.

[MichelSableheart]

They went to bed dreading what would come. Who would be killed by those foul beasts, human or otherwise? The night was again filled with howling and gunshots, but only in the morning did the fair citizens of confidence leave the safety of their houses to check who had survived the night.

Luckily for them, that was almost everyone. Only Vi didn't show up when the rooster called. The whole village went to look for him. Pretty soon, someone found his body, and it was obvious then why he didn't show up. People who are bitten to death and clawed to pieces don't usually attend village meetings.

Vi has been killed night 1. He is now dead. He was a Pro-town Vanilla Townie.

Relieved to see only a single death, discussions soon started again. After all, there were still scum to kick out of the town.

Night 1 has ended, day 2 has begun. Deadline for day 2 is tuesday, 13th of july 2010, 10.00 am GMT

---

First vote count of day 2.

animorpherv1 (0):
askbob (0):
Dr. Robotnik (0):
Dry-fit (0):
Faraday (0):
foilist13 (0):
Leafsnail (0):
Lowell (0):
LynchMePls (0):
Midnight's Sorrow (0):
nhammen (0):
Parama (0):
pman5595 (0):
Pomegranate (0):
SerialClergyman (0):
Sevis (0):
SGRaaize (0):
Super Smash Bros. Fan (0):
The Goat (0):
Timeater (0):
Unsight (0):
vezopiraka (0):

Not Voting (22):

SGRaaize, Faraday, Midnight's Sorrow, animorpherv1, Unsight, Leafsnail, Dry-fit, foilist13, Super Smash Bros. Fan, vezopiraka, LynchMePls, SerialClergyman, Parama, nhammen, Pomegranate, Timeater, Dr. Robotnik, Sevis, The Goat, askbob, pman5595, Lowell

With 22 players alive, it takes 12 votes to lynch someone.

[vezopiraka]

@Nhammen: Who did you blocked tonight?

[Faraday]

Good question.

In other news

Vote SGRaaize

[SGRaaize]

Alright, guys, I know I'm sounding very scummy here, but I wanna get replaced, exams are starting and I can't bother to be ISOing on a Mafia game all the time

Sorry, but I will only start playing Mafia games again when holidays start

[Parama]

Haha, only one kill? From the flavor it sounds like the werewolf kill, too. Hmm... who would want to kill Vi? I think I need to ISO him.
inb4NKWIFOM

Also placeholder vote until something happens:

vote: nhammen

[Midnight's Sorrow]

Vote:Sevis

Because Vi had strong scum vibes from him. And after ISOing Sevis. I agree.

Also GL SGR ^^

[vezopiraka]

Who is the replacement for seraphim?

[Super Smash Bros. Fan]

I had a really strong town read from Vi, as did most other people. This is something worth looking into. We need to look at people who conflicted with him and who thought Vi was scummy.

@vezopiraka: That would be animorpherv1.

@Parama: We have to remember that Vi got a strong town read from a lot of people here, especially me who at one time consider him my strongest town read, so no surprise he died.

[vezopiraka]

We must find out who the mafia targeted. I think the werewolfs killed Vi because they thought it was from an opposing faction.

[Super Smash Bros. Fan]

We must find out who the mafia targeted. I think the werewolfs killed Vi because they thought it was from an opposing faction.

Finding out who the Mafia targeted will probably put us in a WIFOM situation that'll leave little room for scum hunting, plus putting us in danger of being lynched.

I remember using that argument in Newbie Mafia 934 at the beginning of Day 2 and it didn't turn out well. So yeah, main focus should be scum hunting.

[Leafsnail]

Mod - if two kills are performed on the same target, would the kill flavour change?

I seem to remember reading somewhere that the more dramatic kill method tends to be the one shown (ie if someone's ripped to pieces you don't notice a bullet wound in them). It's quite possible both factions went for him.

Chrono hasn't put up a good defense, and he's digging a deeper hole, trying to claim that more than half his wagon is scummy. Vannilia town? Maybe. We'll see.

Vote:Chronopie

Did you actually think chronopie was scum when you hammered him? If so, roughly how sure were you of this?

Vote: Midnight's Sorrow

. Your ISO made my head hurt... almost EVERYTHING you posted is irrelevant fluff, and none of your posts seem to be even vaguely connected to each other. You also jump on the chrono wagon for no reason at all.

You are pretty much the most active-lurkery player I have ever seen.

[Super Smash Bros. Fan]

Vote: Midnight's Sorrow. Your ISO made my head hurt... almost EVERYTHING you posted is irrelevant fluff, and none of your posts seem to be even vaguely connected to each other. You also jump on the chrono wagon for no reason at all.

You are pretty much the most active-lurkery player I have ever seen.

This. Had it not been for a possible role block and nhammen's roleblocker claim, I would be going stright atfter him. Until nhammen tells us who he blocked...

Vote: Midnight's Sorrow

[vezopiraka]

Vote midnight's sorrow

Also just thought about a posibillity. nhammen is scum roleblocker and he blocked the player who submited the kill. Keep doing that nhammem

[Dry-fit]

We must find out who the mafia targeted. I think the werewolfs killed Vi because they thought it was from an opposing faction.

Why is it so crucial to find out who the mafia targeted?

I like this pressure on MS. waiting for nhammen before voting though.

[animorpherv1]

Who is the replacement for seraphim?

Hello.

I may reread, I many not. Don't hold me to it. But, IMO the Day I replace in is the Day I watch the most. So just let me wtahc today, and I'll e able to post more tomorrow.

[vezopiraka]

I was just asking. Faraday asked this too and i thought he was the one who replaced seraphim.

[Midnight's Sorrow]

Vote: Midnight's Sorrow

. Your ISO made my head hurt... almost EVERYTHING you posted is irrelevant fluff, and none of your posts seem to be even vaguely connected to each other. You also jump on the chrono wagon for no reason at all.

You are pretty much the most active-lurkery player I have ever seen.

Out of all the people this could apply to...you choose me?? Why?

And I do believe I gave a reason for that vote. It seems it just hasn't meet your qualifications.

My bad! I'll do better next time! /dripping sarcasm~

Vote: Midnight's Sorrow. Your ISO made my head hurt... almost EVERYTHING you posted is irrelevant fluff, and none of your posts seem to be even vaguely connected to each other. You also jump on the chrono wagon for no reason at all.

You are pretty much the most active-lurkery player I have ever seen.

This. Had it not been for a possible role block and nhammen's roleblocker claim, I would be going stright atfter him. Until nhammen tells us who he blocked...

Vote: Midnight's Sorrow

Eager Beaver is Eager in this one xD

[LimMePls]

Vote:Sevis

Because Vi had strong scum vibes from him. And after ISOing Sevis. I agree.

Also GL SGR ^^

Vote: Midnight's Sorrow

I know its WIFOM, but seems interesting that you would immediatlely point to Sevis. Isn't that what the scum would want us to think? Did you one time mention that you might agree about Sevis D1? We talked about it for pages, and I'm sure you posted during that time. Why do you wait till now to go after Sevis?

@nhammen who was blocked? Maybe they were the killer that didn't get a kill?

[Midnight's Sorrow]

It may be WIFOM, but it certainly doesn't garner

not

being looked at. Or do you just want to look elsewhere maybe?

Ain't it critical, to not make the same mistake we did last phase, to look at all angles before we make a decision on who is scummiest of the day???

That is what I am trying to do, and why I voted Sevis. The one person Vi was adamant about being scum. Whether or not I believed Vi then, is not the question, seeing as we all know now that he was town. Whether or not Vi was killed because of that very reason to make Sevis look bad is not the question either. Vi was the only one to die last phase, and sanzing any protection role, we can assume that he was killed by the Werewolves.

You are aware that there are two factions of Mafia in this right? Mafia and Werewolves? Could not the Werewolves tried to make Sevis look bad because he may be one of the Mafia?? Did you think about that??

[vezopiraka]

It may be WIFOM, but it certainly doesn't garner

not

being looked at. Or do you just want to look elsewhere maybe?

Ain't it critical, to not make the same mistake we did last phase, to look at all angles before we make a decision on who is scummiest of the day???

That is what I am trying to do, and why I voted Sevis. The one person Vi was adamant about being scum. Whether or not I believed Vi then, is not the question, seeing as we all know now that he was town. Whether or not Vi was killed because of that very reason to make Sevis look bad is not the question either. Vi was the only one to die last phase, and sanzing any protection role, we can assume that he was killed by the Werewolves.

You are aware that there are two factions of Mafia in this right? Mafia and Werewolves? Could not the Werewolves tried to make Sevis look bad because he may be one of the Mafia?? Did you think about that??

WIFOM. You're aware that we are sure you're scum. We lynch you today and then we lynch you scumbuddy sevis D3

[Midnight's Sorrow]

WIFOM. You are aware that my wagon started pretty fast(and you not giving a reason for one), over something that could equate to about half of the players on here. Are you also aware that if it wasn't for the fact that you were pretty much confirmed town thanks to being both a monk and mason, that you probably would have been lynched?