NY 114: Mafia vs. Werewolves (Game Over)

[Parama]

I either didn't see them or didn't realize they were directed at me. I don't remember which.

[Parama]

Timeater if you could post actual content once in a while that would be great, thanks.

[Timeater]

Parama if you could post actual content once in a while that would be great, thanks.

[Unsight]

*** Can we play the list your top three suspects game? ***

Code: Select all

1. Parama
2. Socrates
3. Pomegranate

[Super Smash Bros. Fan]

@Timeater: Can we at least explain why?
1st: askbob
2nd: Midnight's Sorrow
3rd: Parama

[Timeater]

@Timeater: Can we at least explain why?

No, that defeats the purpose.

[Parama]

Lookee that. Two scum reads and an idiot put me on their suspicions list. I'm amused to say the least.

[Parama]

Also this should be obvious by now

1. foilist
2. nhammen
3. SSBF

if you couldn't guess yourself

[Lowell]

Okay I give. Foilist is in fact scummy. But soc is still the play. I'll take the known (a roleblock followed by missing kill

) over scummy behavior (being as I am someone who tends to "look scummy" all the time).

The votes on nhammen and parama are stupid though.

[LimMePls]

1. nhammen
2. MS
3. Sevis

[Midnight's Sorrow]

*** Can we play the list your top three suspects game? ***

Code: Select all

1. Sevis
2. Leafsnail
3. Pomegranate

[Midnight's Sorrow]

Okay...just noticed that the words are green....ewww

[SerialClergyman]

Yo Lowell, why don't you like the push on nhammen? I get everything else you're saying (although I think the chance of more kill factions than 2 is unlikely given we're in a game consisting of two distinct scum groups that have mod-confirmed distinct killing styles.)

But I don't get why you're anti-nhammen wagon.

[Leafsnail]

*** Can we play the I continue to fail at chainsaw defence game? ***

I suppose I could indulge you for now.

Code: Select all

1. Foilist
2. Timeater
3. Midnight's Sorrow

Seriously, why the FUCK did I move to the top of your scumlist just because I said you were scum?

[MichelSableheart]

Nachomamma8 will replace pman5595.
Nikanor will replace The Goat.

Votecount coming up shortly.

[MichelSableheart]

Seventh vote count of day 2.

animorpherv1 (0):
askbob (2):

Super Smash Bros. Fan, nhammen

Dr. Robotnik (0):
Dry-fit (0):
Faraday (0):
foilist13 (4):

Parama, Socrates, Leafsnail, vezopiraka

Leafsnail (1):

Timeater

Lowell (0):
LynchMePls (0):
Midnight's Sorrow (0):
Nachomamma8 (0):
nhammen (3):

SerialClergyman, Dry-fit, LynchMePls

Nikanor (0):
Parama (2):

Unsight, foilist13

Pomegranate (0):
SerialClergyman (0):
Sevis (2):

Midnight's Sorrow, Pomegranate

Socrates (4):

Faraday, askbob, animorpherv1, Lowell

Super Smash Bros. Fan (0):
Timeater (1):

Dr. Robotnik

Unsight (0):
vezopiraka (0):

Not Voting (3):

Sevis, Nikanor, Nachomamma8

With 22 players alive, it takes 12 votes to lynch someone.

---

Still looking for replacements for Sevis and animorpherv.

Faraday has announced limited access.

Pomegranate has announced limited access till friday.

I unfortunately don't have time for an activity check. That will come later tonight.

[Parama]

Hey Nacho and Nikanor don't bother reading the thread just vote foilist and everything will be OK. There's not much worth reading anyways.

[Lowell]

Yo Lowell, why don't you like the push on nhammen? I get everything else you're saying (although I think the chance of more kill factions than 2 is unlikely given we're in a game consisting of two distinct scum groups that have mod-confirmed distinct killing styles.)

But I don't get why you're anti-nhammen wagon.

I don't find him super-town, if that's your question. But since I believe at least one kill

was

blocked yesterday, I'm not willing to start out by killing the guy who claims to have blocked it.

[nhammen]

@nhammen You said you blocked SGR in 952 and you voted him right then. You didn't admit to other possibilites until 984, and only after others pointed out that there were other explanations for missing NK besides your RB.

When I first voted, I said that I didn't believe the kill did not happen because of NKWIFOM, but I was worried about something else. That something else was the possibility of a Doc protect. I honestly can't remember why I did not just say that... At that point, I had not yet thought of the possibility of an NK-immune player, which is why I didn't mention it.

nhammen - you totally caught me out. It seems when I first raised this I was more thinking you failed your kill and wanted to take advantage of it and more recently I've been thinking maybe you didn't and you have a genuine reason to push your block target. The fact that I'm so happy to switch between both possibilities indicates a bit (!!) of leftover confirmation bias from D1 as well as changing thoughts after you pointed out SGRaise was your target and didn't have to be.

Yeah, I like to think I'm good at catching contradictions... I just usually assume that they are scummy, even when I shouldn't.

*** Can we play the list your top three suspects game? ***

Code: Select all

1. askbob
2. Socrates
3. Sevis

I'm not sure about Socrates though. Without the predecessor's behavior I would assume pretty confidently that the block wasn't what stopped the kill. But it's still there. So I keep going back ad forth on this.

Seriously, why the FUCK did I move to the top of your scumlist just because I said you were scum?

Leafsnail, not every attack against you is OMGUS...

Nachomamma8 will replace pman5595.
Nikanor will replace The Goat.

@nacho, what do you think of your predecessor's behavior?
@Nik, what do you think of your predecessor's behavior?


I ISOed midnight in the game that Serial linked, and while you did attack a few cases, you came under suspicion quickly afterward. So I cannot be sure if this is normal for you.
@midnight, you have been trashing other players' cases. Can you provide a game in which you have been doing this as Town?

[vezopiraka]

Can't you guys see how scummy is foilist?
Please vote for him.

[LimMePls]

@vezo no I can't. The best case I've seen on him is 1104, and he responded well in 1108. If you want us to see how scummy he is, could you actually try and produce a logical well thought out case against him? I've seen nothing from you on foilist13 except parroting Parama.

[Parama]

Foilist is a good vote.
Now are you willing, LMP? Are you sure you're not the mafia among the monk group who has decided to use his semi-clear status to defend a buddy?

[LimMePls]

Am I willing to what? And I don't think foilist13 needs someone to defend him, he has done it fine himself.

[Super Smash Bros. Fan]

Welcome Nikanor and Nachomamma8. When you get done reading the thread, tell us of your suspects.

Will work on daniel/Faraday's analysis now.

[Super Smash Bros. Fan]

And now, the second installment of "The Claimed Masons/Monks Mini-Series!", which will focus on daniel/Faraday.

daniel made almost no contributation to the game whatsoever. Most of his posts have been fluff written all over it. Sometimes, he can't seem to make up his mind, like for example, saying that I was town, but later saying he didn't know. He has been rolefishing in ISO: 9, saying that Vezopiraka was some sort of cop, but never backs it up. He usually fails to explain well why he found a particular person suspicious. Some of his posts are hard to read because they're in color. He makes big quotes, but adds very little. His promise of more content in his last post has not been fufilled. Overall, very poor play.

Faraday started out by jumping on the biggest bandwagon at the time (Chronopie). His reason for it is basically agreeing with other people on Chronopie. From ISO: 2 to ISO: 9, all he basically did was list his town reads and said he was re-reading. Town reads are nice, but if it gets in the way of scum hunting, that's feigned contribution. Then when nhammen said he role blocked SGRaaize, Faraday deciding to move his vote to SGRaaize, which is him basically bandwagoning. He has also not done much scum hunting throughout the game. Sadly, he is slightly better then daniel. Overall, I find daniel/Faraday suspicious and they are in my scum list.

Tomorrow, I conclude with LynchMePls.