Riddle Me This! NY111 - mafia dead - Town wins!

[Anon]

Because I want to see if we are thinking the same! I want to see why you think he is scum. This is mafia 101 Anon. You're being ridiculous and extremely antitown.

You expect other people to look at that post where you called don_johnson scum and expect people to look at his posts and come to the same conclusion as you. Mafia doesn't work that way. You think he is scum, explain why.

This is ridiculous and thats why you are scum.

The ONLY reason why a townie would want another player to post a case against other is to:

a) get a read of the player doing the case or

b) get a read of the player that is being attacked.

If you already have reads on both players then your only motive is to let two townies fight each other. And thats why, good sir, you are scum.

Confirm vote: scotmany.

[dahill1]

scotmany, for once, is correct.

Then why are you voting for me?

I don't get why attacking the tell is suddenly chainsaw defense. Although, the fact that he was vehement about it even after the claim warrants a vote.

Vote: Dahill

Vehement about what and which claim? This is a weak vote.

I disagree with Anon's recent attack of Scot because I would've asked Anon for reasons too, nothing wrong there. Just took a bunch of SAT IIs so more later

[Anon]

Why would you ask reasons dahill?

[dahill1]

Why would you ask reasons dahill?

To know why they think the person is scum..

If everyone went around voting without reasons that would be quite a difficult game.

[Anon]

I understand that.

My question is why, as a townie scumhunter entity, would you want that information?

[Anon]

I dont think Im being clear enough.

The situation is this:

1. A player posts a compilation of quotes.

1.1. You dont care.

1.2. You do care and ask for clarification. Why?

1.2.1. You want to know if the player making the case is bullshitting, therefore prob scum.

1.2.2. You want to know if the player making the case is telling the truth, therefore prob town and the player being attacked prob scum.

But Scotmany already thinks I am prob town and Don is prob scum. What is the REAL motivation then for asking for clarification?

As I said, I really think Scot is scum here trying to make me do the dirty job and let two townies fight each other.

[scotmany12]

BS Anon. You're full of your self and have no idea how the game works. It doesn't matter if I think you are town or not. I still want to know why you think don is scum. And you're putting words in my mouth, I never said don_johnson is prob scum. I said he was scummy. If i thought he was prob scum I would be voting for him.

It doesn't matter if I have reads on both player, because reads can change! I want to know what you are thinking and why you think don_johnson is scum. And I have every reason to think that besides the fact that I think don_johnson is scummy. Perhaps your reasoning is BS. Perhaps you have this amazing case against don. Perhaps not. I can't know because you didn't explain. Not to mention it would be helpful to everyone else for you to post it.

You think that because I think you are town and that don is scummy that I wouldn't want to know your reasoning. That is ridiculous. Just because two people think one person is scummy doesn't mean they do for the same reason! You are entirely wrong in this matter Anon.

[Anon]

Okay, who is scum then?

[Mr. Chaos]

Unvote

What the hell, Anon, don? I'm really not sure which one of you is acting more anti-town right now.

Hell, even I would've asked what scot's asking. Anon, I really think you need to provide your reasoning. There's no reason, if your town, to withold it at all.

Don's been rereading since he replaced in. Stalling = bad.

[Anon]

You really think I need to provide my reasoning?

You just posted my reasoning. Did you or scot even read what the quotes I posted had in?

Its a MASSIVE compilation of Don stalling since he replaced in.

FOR GOD'S SAKE, PEOPLE.

[Anon]

Chaos, also you didnt comment anything on my reasoning of dahilltown. Please do it now.

[Mr. Chaos]

Chaos, also you didnt comment anything on my reasoning of dahilltown. Please do it now.

Oh, that? Actually thats fine. When you actually spell things out, people understand what you are saying.

You really think I need to provide my reasoning?

You just posted my reasoning. Did you or scot even read what the quotes I posted had in?

Its a MASSIVE compilation of Don stalling since he replaced in.

FOR GOD'S SAKE, PEOPLE.

OK, ok, ok. I didn't know if you had different reasoning for it. Yeesh.


Well, this makes it easier, then.

vote: don

Lets see if he miraculously finishes reading in time to respond to my vote.

[Anon]

What do you understand about my dahilltown reasoning?

[Mr. Chaos]

What do you understand about my dahilltown reasoning?

I understand exactly what you are saying. I agree that I don't see dahill, as I have observed his play this game, as capable of assuming cove was the sk. If someone hadn't pointed it out before I had posted, I would've also continued to assume so, because DN didn't point out that it was a murderer in the deathpost.

Now, why are we going on about this?

[Yosarian2]

Don, can you explain why you voted for Cove here, especially if you hadn't read the whole game yet? I mean, horray, you voted for scum, but your reasoning seems really odd (and it's kind of amusing you spend half the post talking about "bussing" and then vote Cove for what appears to be a terrible reason, lol).

bussing cannot be "premature". it is, by definition, "the attacking of ones scum partner". timing is irrelevant. anyhoo. i don't know what to make of the amished scumtell without links and/or proof, but for now:

unvote, vote: cove

evening out the bandwagons can only lead to good things. i should be back in this with analysis soon.

[RichardGHP]

Obviously I'm going to use my role as a defense. I'm not going to lie and say I haven't done scum-like things, because I have. Just about everyone in the game has at one point or another.

Leave me alive today, let me track someone, and lynch me tomorrow if I don't come up with anything (provided that my lynch will help the town). I doubt the game will get to Night 6 and you will probably have found the scum by then/soon after anyway.

Scum won't have the numbers to drive a wagon anymore so I'm just going to blatantly BW.

[farside22]

vote count:

Dahill (5) Nachomamma, Amished, Mr. Chaos, VasudeVa, RichardGHP
Scot (1) Dahill
RicharadGHP (1) Anon

not voting:

iamausername
Don_Johnson
Scotmany
Yosarian2
inHimshallibe

With 12 alive it will take 7 to lynch
Deadline June 24th, 6:00pm PST

[RichardGHP]

FTR I would support a lynch of either dahill or scotmany. Anyone else, and I'll just half-heartedly BW.

@Dahill I was referring to the chainsaw thing.

@Anon if you think scotmany is scum why are you still voting me?

[RichardGHP]

EBWOP: Disregard that last question Anon, it appears that the last VC was incorrect.

[don_johnson]

yos:

evening out the bandwagons can only lead to good things.

very sound and logical reasoning for a vote from someone who has not read the thread and is being pressured to contribute. you guys are lucky i'm even gonna read this monstrosity. have you played with amished before? i have. nacho too.

[Amished]

Quick access:

@Anon: If your vig role wasn't proveable I'd smack you upside the head and try to get you lynched right here and now. Your stupid ass questions from yesterday should never have been asked in the first place.

@don: FYI, of the current player list I've played with:
3. RichardGHP
4. don_johnson
11. Anon
12. Nachomamma8
18. inHimshallibe

[Amished]

Oh, and one more thing: Anon, you're still blind as a bat. If the "majority of players didn't think that Cove would flip scum" how the HELL did we get him lynched?

Tentative

Unvote
Vote: Yosarian2

[Nachomamma8]

A Yosarian2 vote is a horrible vote.

[Mr. Chaos]

Mod: Last VC was incorrect. Fix plz

Anyways, I too disagree with the Yos vote. Any reason you did it?

[RichardGHP]

Much as I would like to say otherwise, Yos votes are bad votes.