Mini 973: "Bawhston" Brawl (WHAT A WIN!)

[havingfitz]

Still v/LA. Checking in for a few minutes and not seeing anything worth commenting on other than I'm surprised by the fact TBM has not been lynched yet. wtf?

And why, precisely are you so eager to speedlynch TBM.

Do my comments indicate the desire for a speedlynch? How would you define 'speedlynching?'

Not so much that I am eager as I am surprised he is still around. When I went v/LA it appeared momentum was going that direction (and still is with his current L-1 positon). Whether it is speedy or not...I support it because I think he's scum.

[havingfitz]

Shyte.

Mod...feel free to delete one of my double posts.

Done.

[TheButtonmen]

[Shamelessly Wagon]

Vote: Nik

[/Shamelessly Wagon]

[Nikanor]

I SPY A HAMMAH.

TBM, please claim in your next post.

[Oso]

Tired of waiting for Oso to see what I see.... so im just going to point it all out. Niks on RH/TBM doesnt add up to me.

Apologies there Furry. During the week I sometimes have time to get into a deep analysis but generally not right away. (Not unless I get lucky or use up some sleep time). I should have qualified that and said "...it may take a while."

[q21]

Still v/LA. Checking in for a few minutes and not seeing anything worth commenting on other than I'm surprised by the fact TBM has not been lynched yet. wtf?

And why, precisely are you so eager to speedlynch TBM.

Do my comments indicate the desire for a speedlynch? How would you define 'speedlynching?'

Not so much that I am eager as I am surprised he is still around. When I went v/LA it appeared momentum was going that direction (and still is with his current L-1 positon). Whether it is speedy or not...I support it because I think he's scum.

You comments indicate that you expected him to be lynched some time between your last post before going v/la (351) and your post which is quoted above (386). Given that the Day started on post 298 it looks like you expected - and since your vote was and still is on him, wanted - him lynched in under 4 pages. That's pretty speedy.

At this point I think the lynch is still premature as I don't like Nik's seeming willingness to hammer a cause he seems not to believe in himself.

[havingfitz]

I'm advocating a 'speedy lynch;' you think a lynch is premature at this point.

It's RL day 10. When would you feel more warm and comfy with a lynch taking place?

BTW...TBM's post 402 above seems like he's given in. I did not see a claim anywhere either. Can we hammer him now Q? Huh? Can we, can we (we being anyone not currently on the TBM wagon {attn: Nik}).

[yabbaguy]

"Eh. One of the Faneuil shops caught fire. It's all taken care of."

"Too bad the fire department has to go look at it anyway."

Vote Count:

6 to lynch

TheButtonmen (5): havingfitz, Oso, InflatablePie, Midnight's Sorrow, Hoopla
Nikanor (3): q21, Furry, TheButtonmen
Midnight's Sorrow (1): Gwynplaine

Nonvoters: Nikanor

Deadline is 6/24 @ 8 PM GMT-4. No Lynch occurs if this elapses.

[Oso]

Like, you know that feeling where you just know that it's two townies going at it in a big argument? That's how I feel about them.

That Oso and RH are both town.

If someone puts TBM at L-1 I'll hammer.
....

I said I'd hammer TBM because a) Hoopla was upset and I wanted to make her feel better and b) I have this weird tendency to be wrong most of the time. I figure that if the majority wants it, I can go with a Buttonlynch.

Until you had pointed that out, I had completely forgotten about the bolded post. Even on a re-read I had missed that. Definite -1 for that pair of posts. Even though I did use one of them to try and pressure TBM with.

The rest I'm not so sure on but that could simply be two people who disagree on tells and I have never played with Nik before so I can't comment on his meta. But it does hang together.

I am still comfortable with my vote on TBM. I believe he will flip scum and I'm convinced in my mind that he is the lynch for today. I'll keep in mind your points on Nik though. The most telling part of your post though that I hadn't even considered up until you mentioned it was Nik equating slepz-flaking with slepz-lurking. I agree that calling for a lurker lynch on that player slot is way off considering that Yabba has managed to get replacements for it so quickly.

[Nikanor]

That was a rather scummy post, havingfitz.
I'm still going to wait for TBM to claim before I hammer.

[Furry]

Like I said, im sure enough of the TBM lynch to not stop it. I just want a whole lot more opinions on people over the Nik lynch first. This just looks like the case of a really good lynch vs good lynch.

Hmmmm

@Nik - Can you make a nice big post of why TBM is scum for me?

[InflatablePie]

V/LA until Monday

due to work. It turns out I'm working three double shifts in a row, so I'll be mostly working or sleeping. Which means little/no time for mafia.

I'll try and catch up/make a content post sometime tonight, I've just been busy IRL and I have a few other games going on (on and off-site). =/

After that, I'll try keeping up with the thread, but posting will be very minimal till Monday, if I manage to get the time anyways.

[InflatablePie]

Something in this post seems off. I don't know why. I've read it three times and still don't understand it, for one.

This (by Hoopla) is worse, as she doesn't even address her little breakdown and instead goes right back on TBM.

I can see Hoopla/TBM. fitz is also a bit scummy in his latest post, but he doesn't exactly fit in well with those two. Maybe fitz/TBM, but not Hoopla/fitz or even all three - I don't think there would be two scum bussing one - this is of course, assuming the setup is 8:3:1.

[InflatablePie]

Actually, Hoopla/fitz pairing might work if there's three scum, if one is on the Nik wagon or something. But they're both pushing/voting for TBM so it's unlikely IMO.

I still think Nik is town, but the open caution of him to hammer has got me worried. It's reminding me of a certain "insane tell"...

[TheButtonmen]

Yo Fitz mind laying out why you think I'm scum?

I just went back and ISO'ed you and you never actually did; just kept saying your happy with your vote.

@The People Wanting Me To Claim:

Gimme until Fitz answers m'kay?

[Furry]

I would prefer Nik does it since he is more likely to be scum... they both can though.

[TheButtonmen]

Hnn; I would expect Nik to bullshit better then Fitz though. Thoughts on Fitz going first then Nik if we want both to?

[Furry]

Order doesnt matter, plagerism is easy to spot.

[Midnight's Sorrow]

Order may not matter, but the way in which you are going is the wrong one. Nik does not fit in the equation at this moment in time. TBM before Fitz please. This is the way to scum in this game. Yep. Yes siry bob~

[Nikanor]

I'll post something after fitz posts something.

[havingfitz]

That was a rather scummy post, havingfitz.
I'm still going to wait for TBM to claim before I hammer.

What was scummy about my post? The fact I’m questioning Q21's inference that I'm supporting a 'speedy lynch' and that a lynch at this time is premature? How is disagreeing with those opinions scummy?

I can see Hoopla/TBM. fitz is also a bit scummy in his latest post, but he doesn't exactly fit in well with those two. Maybe fitz/TBM, but not Hoopla/fitz or even all three - I don't think there would be two scum bussing one - this is of course, assuming the setup is 8:3:1.

Actually, Hoopla/fitz pairing might work if there's three scum, if one is on the Nik wagon or something. But they're both pushing/voting for TBM so it's unlikely IMO.

So you are linking me to the two people I have focused on the majority of the game? Brilliant.

Yo Fitz mind laying out why you think I'm scum?

I just went back and ISO'ed you and you never actually did; just kept saying your happy with your vote.

@The People Wanting Me To Claim:

Gimme until Fitz answers m'kay?

Uh...I gave my reasoning with my initial TBM vote. And other than the fact I have maintained my vote on you....what are you basing this,

’ just kept saying your happy with your vote’

comment on?

The background on my suspicions towards you is the link I just provided coupled with higher suspicions I had on D1 of JacobSavage and Hoopla. JS' claim put me off his wagon and Hoopla’s D1 wagon, along with a potential D2 wagon, have not had any traction. Therefore, I'm continuing my support of your lynch instead. If I had to choose between you and Hoopla I would prefer Hoopla for all of the D1 reasons I provided. Unfortunately, as already stated, she has stayed under the radar D2 and is not getting the attention I think she still deserves.

In addition to the comments I made when I placed my vote on you, I also find you suspicious for your reaction to Furry’s question to both of us (which I explain with my D2 vote on you) and the votes you place on Q21 (TBM ISO 15) and Nik (TBM ISO 25) which both came without any reasoning I can uncover.

[Nikanor]

Okay. NOW I'm going to hammer.

Vote: TheButtonmen.

[TheButtonmen]

Smooth Nik; before twilight ends want to answer the question or going to lurk until the mod ends the day?

[Nikanor]

I take it that means you're town?

[TheButtonmen]

I take it that means you're town?

Does it?

How about you answer the question then I'll answer yours?