Gears of War Mafia (Over!)

[ReaperCharlie]

Karma for obvious reasons, of course, Reck for undisclosed ones.

[Fate]

You said you already got all you needed out of the xRECK wagon.

And if THAT's your scumlist why the fuck are you voting Karma and not the FUCKIN VANILLA.

Hey DGB I'm ready for that Reaper lynch now.

[ReaperCharlie]

You guys are literally out of your minds. I swear

[xRECKONERx]

ATTENTION ULTIMATE TOWN ALLIANCE OF DGB FATE AND RECK

WE ARE NOW LYNCHING RC.

VOTE: ReaperCharlie

wagon go

[Fate]

K

Unvote
Vote: Reaper

[Fate]

DGB isn't town then

[Fate]

Though**

[xRECKONERx]

Fate, hush, she clearly is.

[ReaperCharlie]

[Jack]

Claim: Neighbor

Neighbors with CMAR. He was rather unresponsive to start the game so I pushed him in thread instead. Now check back to the three quotes I posted earlier:

quote 1--CMAR says something about it being normal to for me to tunnel on someone, it "rings a bell" for him.
quote 2--Soc holds up my tunneling on cmar as a town tell because it would be too dangerous. Which is a lazy and untrue thing to say.
quote 3--now CMAR supposedly knows all about it while he didn't before.

I concluded that they had talked about it privately, fairly obvious if you ask me.

Rule 5 says I can't quote the QT, but I pressed CMAR on this and on Socrates. He softclaimed that he was also neighbors with Socrates and then claimed he wasn't allowed to talk about it when pressed. While talking about socrates he mentioned (soon after marathon day) that socrates didn't seem the type to bus, socrates played a game on marathon day with me where he bussed and it ended up being very stressful and he said "I'm never bussing again", I assume they discussed bussing given CMAR's scrambling defense, maybe it's coincidence maybe not.

Confirm vote:Socrates

If CMAR is scum I take it as a given that he is as well, and more likely to be a roleblocker/other scum role.

DGB is likely scum too.

[ReaperCharlie]

Interesting... I'll re-read later tonight and probably get back to you.

[DrippingGoofball]

Not sure about the bu'sing stuff, maybe I'm not understanding that part of Jack's explanation, but the part where CMAR admits to having another "neighbor" is damning indeed. I'm going to take a look at CMAR.

unvote, vote: Socrates

[Socrates]

Well, since I am not a neighbor with CMAR, this whole thing is goofy to say the least.

[Socrates]

Why vote me and not CMAR, since my scumness seems to be predicated on CMAR being scum?

[DrippingGoofball]

First CMAR votes Socrates, and then disavows it as a random vote. This could very well be bus'ing.

Second CMAR was acting all cocky and buddy-buddy with Jack as if they were masons rather than mere neighbors. Which means that he didn't suspect Jack - which he should have. Jack, on the other hand, didn't trust his neighbor; THAT is the townie reaction.

He hops on the Karma wagon.

Later he posts: "As Soc might say, this is just curiosity on why he was chosen for silver's RL. It feels as though he is more impassive than defensive/worried." It's a neutralish-sounding defense.

This POST is extremely noteworthy in light of Jack's revelation. CMAR explains why, with Socrates and Karma having done the same thing, he finds Socrates not scummy, but Karma not scummy. I suppose that *might* be interpreted as trusting his alleged neighbor Socrates; however, his "random" vote was for Socrates, so that blows this possible excuse out of the water.

CMAR is lynch-worthy as well.

[DrippingGoofball]

Well, since I am not a neighbor with CMAR, this whole thing is goofy to say the least.

You deny it?

FTR, I don't mind voting CMAR or yourself. They're equivalent. However all things being equal, his being the neighbor-scum means he's not a more important scum role like Godfather or roleblocker, which you might be.

[Jack]

Why vote me and not CMAR, since my scumness seems to be predicated on CMAR being scum?

I don't think the mod would give CMAR-scum two neighbors. And I already answered this question in my post...

[DrippingGoofball]

[quote="Jack"I don't think the mod would give CMAR-scum two neighbors. And I already answered this question in my post...[/quote]

Agreed.

[Jack]

Well, since I am not a neighbor with CMAR, this whole thing is goofy to say the least.

Also, this comment rubs me the wrong way.

[Socrates]

I'm not scum though nor do I have any way to communicate with CMAR, thats the thing. I'm very confused here.

Jack should elaborate on the cirsumstances of CMAR's "soft-claim". When did he do it?

I don't think the mod would give CMAR-scum two neighbors. And I already answered this question in my post...

Your reason gave me de`javu, Jack. You remember my "reasoning" when I bussed you in that game I mentioned.

[Socrates]

EBWOP:

I'm not scum though nor do I have any way to communicate with CMAR, thats the thing. I'm very confused here.

Jack should elaborate on the cirsumstances of CMAR's "soft-claim". When did he do it?

I don't think the mod would give CMAR-scum two neighbors. And I already answered this question in my post...

Your reason gave me de`javu, Jack. You remember my "reasoning" when I bussed you in that game

I

you mentioned.

[DrippingGoofball]

Socrates.

It's not "ad-homonym" it's

ad hominem

.

Fix you sig before we lynch you PLZ.

[Socrates]

I refuse to fix that typo. It's part of who I am.

[Jack]

I'm not scum though nor do I have any way to communicate with CMAR, thats the thing. I'm very confused here.

Why are you very confused? If you were townie I don't see why you'd be confused--it would be simple, CMAR is scum and took the opportunity to frame you--you at least sounded confident earlier that the connection between you two was obviously just coincidence. In no way would your not being neighbors with CMAR make the whole thing "goofy", since no one is assuming you are.

Jack should elaborate on the cirsumstances of CMAR's "soft-claim". When did he do it?

I pushed him on the tunneling thing soon after posting my case.

I don't think the mod would give CMAR-scum two neighbors. And I already answered this question in my post...

Your reason gave me de`javu, Jack. You remember my "reasoning" when I bussed you in that game I mentioned.

Ok, so the reason you asked a question that had already been answered was that you think I'm scum with CMAR? Assuming you aren't accusing me of bussing now. Yeah, I'm going to say you were grasping for a response with this post.

[DrippingGoofball]

SOCRATES, DIE YOU LATIN DISRESPECTING SCUM