Mini 986: Beatles Mafia (Game Over)

[petroleumjelly]

Official Day One Vote Count: #5

4 - MonkeyMan576 (TheSkeward, inHimshallibe, VasudeVa, Karma)
3 - inHimshallibe (danakillsu, Scott Brosius, muh316)
2 - Karma (Anon, Zang)
2 - muh316 (Shadow Dancer, ekiM)
1 - danakillsu (MonkeyMan576)

With

12

alive it takes

7

to lynch, and

4

to lynch at deadline. Deadline is July 2 at 4:00 p.m. PST.

Not Voting - 0 - Nobody

[TheSkeward]

VasudeVa, why are you listing your townreads? It's usually a bad idea to do that, as it's basically giving scum a map and directions for their nightkill target.

[Karma]

Scum can usually figure out the towniest players anyway. I always thought that argument was wrong but hey that's just me.

[inHimshallibe]

Nothing is wrong with listing town reads. More involvement from me will come this week.

[Karma]

I should clarify - by "that" argument I meant skeward's.

[danakillsu]

Yeah, actually listing town reads is definitely NOT a scumtell (I've tried to use it before) but it's not really pro-town unless one of your townreads is the main wagon and you're trying to save him/her. Nobody really needs to know who your town reads are except scum.

[Scott Brosius]

I think listing town reads is fine. Scum (at least less careful scum) are so focused on trying to secure a mislynch that they don't want to admit to anyone being town.

Can we get a prod on MonkeyMan?

[VasudeVa]

I post town reads for a reason. Posting the reason goes against the objective of posting the reads.

---

The game is definitely stalling due to lack of reactions from the two guys in the frying pan. Prod/Replace please.

[Zang]

Nothing is wrong with listing town reads. More involvement from me will come this week.

this is it? Not even a comment on the wagon on you?

UNVOTE:
VOTE: InHimshallibe

but I do agree that posting reads isn't scummy.

[TheSkeward]

I'd like to clarify - I don't think listing town reads is scummy. I think it's anti-town.

[danakillsu]

I'd like to clarify - I don't think listing town reads is scummy. I think it's anti-town.

My position in a nutshell.

[Karma]

I disagree but this is a post for MD, not here.

Let's talk real scum. MonkeyMan disappears under pressure...hm.

[danakillsu]

I disagree but this is a post for MD, not here.

Let's talk real scum. MonkeyMan disappears under pressure...hm.

Everyone disappears, whether under pressure or not.
@mod
I don't know who if any deserves one, but please send out appropriate prods. It seems half our players have gone missing.

[petroleumjelly]

Anon, MonkeyMan576, and muh316 have been prodded with the following prod:

Here comes the prod,
(Doo doo doo doo),
Here comes the prod,
And I say: You must post.

Please post within the next 48 hours, or I will search for a replacement.

PJ

[muh316]

So where is monkeyman i havent seen him in while

[Karma]

Muh, that's the best you got?

[VasudeVa]

Sigh, so we'll have to wait 48 hours to get some reactions.

[Scott Brosius]

So where is monkeyman i havent seen him in while

inhim at least promised to start participating. You get prodded and deliver this gem?

Unvote
Vote:muh316

[danakillsu]

Yeah, well. I haven't seen this "participation" thing from anyone, including inHim.

[Anon]

Unvote Vote: MonkeyMan

[Scott Brosius]

Um, any particular reason? If its lurking and general unhelpfulness, the pot calling the kettle black comes to mind.

[Anon]

Theres nothing wrong in posting your town reads, btw.

In fact, Ill go ahead and post a scumlist for your pleasure:

Town
2.) danakillsu
7.) muh316
10.) TheSkeward
11.) VasudeVa

Neutral
3.) ekiM
4.) inHimshallibe
8.) Scott Brosius

Scum
9.) Shadow Dancer
One of Karma or MonkeyMan
12.) Zang (100% if MonkeMan scum)

[Anon]

Um, any particular reason? If its lurking and general unhelpfulness, the pot calling the kettle black comes to mind.

I dont like the push on dana which is screaming easy target all over his head. Thats the basic premise of one of Monkey and Karma is scum.

I dont think lurking and being unhelpful are conclusive scumtells, btw. Do you?

[Zang]

Why am I scum if monkeyman is?

[Anon]

Yeah, you seem overly concerned about one vote, that's a scumtell. As far as the mod is concerned, if I were you I'd be more interested in scumhunting than mod complimenting. So who do you think is scum so far?

This is suspicous. There were three votes on Dana when he posted the post that you quoted (one of which was yours). And how could he be scumhunting until a few posts before this it was the RVS.

The whole case against Dana is flawed. And I see almost nothing from karma except "He is scum, vote for him!".

Unvote
Vote:Karma

In all your post you attack Monkeyman. Yet your vote is on Karma.