Open 228 - Mafia in KyleVille - Game Over!

[Oopidstay]

So... you wanted to draw out teh scumz by being scummy? Try again, cause town looks for scummy stuff too.

lolreactions doesn't work. Try scumhunting.

(director voice)Take 2, ACTION!

Lol no I wanted to get rid of RVS by being scummy in RVS. Cause your right,

Town looks for scummy stuff

too. And when

they

see scummy stuff they talk and now I think we are out of RVS.

lolreactions do work, they wouldn't be so popular if they just failed miserably. I am scumhunting. But Its kinda page 3 and I really kinda think its impossible too just like call out the scum for the whole game. I can give it a loltry. I hereby declares that the scum will end up being Paltry and Kthxbye! If I am right I will laugh so hard.

Take 2 isn't needed.

unvote

Yay scumslip!

VOTE: Robocopter87

I hope you're joking. Reading up some more, I guess not. This makes me sad.

@Karma: Why are you still voting him if you don't want a quicklynch? Can't he talk without your vote on him?

This, however, is a good point. I still think Karma is scum.

So you have nothing to say about the leading wagon, yet deride an innocuous comment that was backed up by reasoning, and you make a tiny push on an alternate wagon that has little support right now.

And you've been lurking.

FoS: Hershey Kiss

If Robo is scum, Hershey is a nice candidate for a scumbuddy.

Mod: Did you say how many of each role there are in this game? I'm too lazy to go hunt it down in the Open Queue.

[Hershey Kiss]

So you have nothing to say about the leading wagon, yet deride an innocuous comment that was backed up by reasoning, and you make a tiny push on an alternate wagon that has little support right now.

I thought I made it clear that I don't believe Robo slipped.

[Merkabah]

So you have nothing to say about the leading wagon, yet deride an innocuous comment that was backed up by reasoning, and you make a tiny push on an alternate wagon that has little support right now.

I thought I made it clear that I don't believe Robo slipped.

*I* thought you read the whole thread and actually looked at my comprehensive take on all of Robo's play. You know, the part where I didn't even mention the slip as he's just an active lurker.

@whomever asked about my pushing: I'm pushing for a robo lynch because I believe that he's scum. Is there any other reason that I should have to lynch robo? Keeping him alive will only build apathy towards him and get away from my top scum candidate. That's obviously less than optimal since getting away from scum only hurts.

Also, both of us think this is a rather humorous (and scummy) attempt at deflection from the point at hand.

I didn't call myself scum. I don't understand where you got this idea stuck in your head. Your completly ignoring everything I'm saying. Have you fully read the posts in this game or are you just skimming them? Seriously, in my situation, I am doing a pretty darn good job .

-snip-

shush, obv-scum. Why *can't* we get a claim and a lynch?

[kyle99]

Mod: Did you say how many of each role there are in this game? I'm too lazy to go hunt it down in the Open Queue.

1 Jailkeeper, 1 Tracker, 2 Mafia Goons, 5 Townies.

[PaltryExcuse]

@Robo: WHY is my meta evidence null? Or why is the case against you (detailed by Merkabah) invalid?
Let's see if I get your Empking case: He voted for you weakly, and lurked a bit. Okay. Problem is, I'd expect that of bussing partner. It doesn't sway my opinion in the slightest, and I actually feel that Emp is a likely partner to you in this mess.
On you, a player appeals to the rest to start the game and persists with joking behaviour, and then just complains and insults at the town is not someone who I'd describe as 'pro-town'. More like lost scum. The fact that you are normally an early scumhunter and had to be attacked in order to scumhunt compounds the issue at hand.
I'm with Merk. Claim and lynch please and thanks.
Give me a #2 scum other than Empking, Robo.

@Karma:

@Merk: I like adding pressure. If anyone quickhammers him they can face my fiery wrath tomorrow.

This bothers me as I feel like you

know

you'll be alive tomorrow. I feel like the comment wards people from the Robo-wagon more than it encourages the lynch of someone you claim to believe is scum.

[Robocopter87]

Screw it then.

I'm a VT. You guys really shouldn't do what your going to do but hey, stuff happens.
My opinion was stated in my post with everyones name on it so I already packed my bags. I now think that because of everyones idea that I'm scum and won't let go of it, that by dying maybe you'll realize that you need to not be so stubborn and actually try listening to people. Emp's partner? I really can't say on Page 6 and I think the Meta is a null tell, really, the only constant is change and people change the way they act all the time. So Meta doesn't work. Well thats all IMO. I'm pretty glad I wasn't something important that would hurt the town if I died.

Well, I don't think Merk and his followers will be swayed but I will still fight to the death!

Btw, I never slipped.
Btw, I never called myself scum.
Btw, I called out the scum in the beginning to be Paltry and KthxBye and if thats true, I want a cookie.
Btw, Meta no work for reasons, but you didn't get that memo.
Btw, I'm not an active lurker because I didn't lurk and I only post fluff on occasion and for humor because its supposed to be a game and games are fun!

Also, *Putting* *stuff* *in* *stars* *doesn't* *make* *it* *true* *or* *more* *important* *Merk*.

[Oopidstay]

Unvote: Hershey Kiss
Vote: Robocopter87

You're dead now. Relax, it's a peaceful process, really. Once you lose enough oxygen you really don't feel much of anything...

[Merkabah]

It draws people's attention to it so it makes my point stand out to them. It's awesome.

Btw, the slip was more to see how you reacted (see other post without a case)
Btw, you said you acted like scum would (and didn't change)
Btw, you never said why meta didn't work. You can get a meta off of people that you haven't played with.
Btw, you are an active lurker insofar as you're active (i.e. not lurking) but you're lurking as you aren't really posting anything of content. Games are fun, but you also try to win.

Finally, GOD DAMMIT OOPID. You were doing so well, and now I think Robo is town.

[Muthaa]

Well that was faster than expected... although it has a funny/interesting (w/e the way you people think) ending.

[kyle99]

After much deliberation about who the town thought should die, they finally decided to string up Robocopter87. However, when searching his house, there was no evidence found that would associate him with the Mafia.

Robocopter87, a

Vanilla Townie,

has been lynched.

Night will last 3 days, or until all night actions have been received.

[kyle99]

After a long night of rest, the town members of KyleVille wake up with a pleasant surprise. Not a single member of their town had been murdered last night!

Day 2 has started.

[Oopidstay]

Interesting night...

[Muthaa]

And funny (in my opinion at least) lol

[Merkabah]

What's funny about it Muthaa?

[Muthaa]

Am I the only one to see the fail?

[Merkabah]

Am I the only one to see the fail?

I think we all see that there was no NK. I just find it funny that you find it funny. To quote Billy Bob Thorton:

"Funny queer, not funny ha-ha."

[Karma]

vote: Muthaa

I've always thought "congratulating the doc" was a fairly valid scumtell.

[Oopidstay]

vote: Muthaa

I've always thought "congratulating the doc" was a fairly valid scumtell.

This looks like scum trying to exploit something suspicious-looking.

Proof of your supposition, Karma?

[Karma]

https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?ti ... ding_Mafia

[Karma]

P.S. What does that even mean - scum trying to exploit something suspicious-looking?

If you agree that it is suspicious-looking, then isn't that just called...scumhunting?

[Hershey Kiss]

Vote Muthaa

Sounds like scum that's mad that the kill didn't work but is trying to cover it up by pointing it out as a positive.

[Oopidstay]

https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?ti ... ding_Mafia

What proof do

you

have, Karma? As in, link games plz.

P.S. What does that even mean - scum trying to exploit something suspicious-looking?

If you agree that it is suspicious-looking, then isn't that just called...scumhunting?

So scum can't point out suspicious things that townspeople do and try to exploit said suspicious things to create mislynches? Suspicious does not always equal scummy.

Vote: Hershey Kiss

For doing the same thing Karma is doing.

[Muthaa]

I see, I'll keep my comments to myself next time uh.

@Merk: What do you mean by that quote?
@Karma: "I always thought giving a pretty easy vote was a fairly valid scumtell."
@Hershey: "Sounds like scum that's trying to make a wagon on an easy vote."

[Karma]

Suspicious does not always equal scummy...? Huh? Why are you voting Hershey instead of me?

Should the jailkeeper come out with who he jailed, considering the no-kill? Or is that a bad idea this early?

[Kthxbye]

@karma and the rest: VERY BAD idea. Are you kidding me? In this set up, there are only 2 explanations of why there was no NK. One: scum chose to not NK anyone to confuse us or Two: the person the scum targeted was jailkept. Seeing as we are early in this game, I would NOT suggest our PR's out themselves this way.

Now that that's out of the way, I'm very disappointed that you all couldn't wait for me to catch up and give my input for D1. My automatic suspect is now Oop for not even caring that I hadn't been available to catch up and hammering AFTER I said that I would be back at the latest by the 26th. At the earliest, deadline would have been the 29th (tomorrow).

FoS: Oopidstay

Now that I have a little time, I'm going to do a full re-read to see how the heck day 1 ended without everyone giving their input and taking a stance.