Open 226: Big Love - Game over! Town wins!

[Robocopter87]

Alright, I want Millar out.

VOTE: Millar

[Xite91]

@Don's Lover lynch question: nulltell. I think Xite's actually the lone person to call it scummy, which is curious.

Wait what?
I don't recall saying that

MAFIA HAVE LOVERS WHO ARE TOWN DUMB DUMB!

That's it. He's a bigger noob than I am:

UNVOTE:
VOTE: millar13

Actually, I totally follow his logic. He just doesn't relay it well, I guess.
If we outed one pair of lovers at a time, wait to see if they get nk'd and if they don't we can assume one is the scum lover.
I am aware that things can go wrong with this plan, but I'm willing to try it
That being said, I'd like to out myself. I am one, but I'm going to not out my lover at the moment, they can out themself if they deem fit.
Other lovers - don't say a word until we see if this works out. I'm willing to be put on the chopping block for a possibly dumb idea.

Alright, I want Millar out.

VOTE: Millar

Btw, wha...?

Why don't we wait and see, I have a feeling I should trust him and I almost always follow my feelings.
Also, going solely off of that, you robo seem really scummy to me

[Pittbunny]

Unvote Vote Robo

[Robocopter87]

You think you should trust him? I thought that to. But no. I can't.

Heres an Idea Xite, why don't you ISO him? You really should just look through his posts. He doesn't care about this game. Simple as that. The only way to get rid of him is to kill him. Simple, isn't it?

Also, Why Am I scummy?

[Xite91]

First, like I said thinking you're scummy is a gut feeling, nothing that should warrant more than an FoS, but i'll ISO you and if you so wish I can make a case based on what you've said. I'd just rather post my suspicions and when I know for sure I'll give you a case. But like I said, up to you
Second, I just do? I feel like I know what he's doing and so does he.
He may seem to not care about the game but honestly I'm relating him a lot to multiple different playstyles I've seen and I'm pretty sure I've got him figured out.

[millar13]

THANK GOD for Xite91....one of the few people who doesn't see this game as just black and white lol (and yea...i play games differently....coz i was sick of having a meta)

[Pittbunny]

Is the goal of getting rid of a player presumably without worth superceding the goal of getting rid of scum?

[millar13]

My view from the off...was for people to out themselves or admit they had loves;
outing a lover is the only way to take a step forward

[Robocopter87]

No no no, I meant ISO millar. I just did and I started laughing.

[Pittbunny]

Already have. Don't see your point.

[Pittbunny]

Rather, I don't see why your point justifies wasting a lynch.

[Xite91]

Yeah, I tend to laugh when I see posts by millar too, but I do with a lot of other posts too.

And I know what you meant, but you asked why I thought you were scummy, I was offering my services as a todays shelock holmes (except minus the massive ammounts of drugs )

And yes pitt, that's part of my problem with robo.

[Robocopter87]

For now, to see if he complies. If he does not, he is of no use to us and a burden. One of the many reasons village idiots are so detrimental is that in LyLo people can't focus and choose scum because the VI is screaming "IM SO SCUMMY" and just gets in the way. We can't have that.

You don't remember me saying this? This is why I want Millar lynch. Because right now hes being the VI. We will most likely mislynch, why not take care of a burden to the town while we are at it?

[Xite91]

And that's why you're scummy. I say we move on a bit, find more things out, then decide who to lynch
also, didn't i say a bit about people that play like him? They tend to get information well, even if it's an odd way to do so. I think we should trust him for a little bit. At least until day 2 or three, if nothing then we can lynch him, k?

[Pittbunny]

We will most likely mislynch

, why not take care of a burden to the town while we are at it?

Defeatist attitude.

[Robocopter87]

Theres a downside to everyone's argument.

[Pittbunny]

Yes, but yours borders on being hypocritical. You're giving up on the success of Day 1.

[Robocopter87]

Well, what do you want me to do about it? What do you suggest I do? What would you do in my situation?

Also, not being sarcastic on these questions, I would like an answer.

[Xite91]

Well, what do you want me to do about it? What do you suggest I do? What would you do in my situation?

Also, not being sarcastic on these questions, I would like an answer.

What do you mean, in your situation?
Explain plox

[Robocopter87]

In my situation, meaning if you were me right now.

[Xite91]

Yeah, that really answers it.
What's different between me and you?
As far as I know atm we're all town looking to lynch scum.
Unless you're different, otherwise we're both in the same situation and we would want day 1 to go on a while so we can get more info first.
If I explained this right then everyone should know why I'm doing this

Unvote, Vote: Robocopter

[Wacka Alpaca]

Back from vacay, and posted in the wrong topic! i am reading THIS game now (Wow waste of time).
should post soon.

[Wacka Alpaca]

Ok, speed reading through this, I gotta say that I (Who has fresh eyes from not reading or being affected by this game yet) see most of Millar's actions as scummy.
In my experience, most people who request to be replaced out in a rage are scum, trying to play to a fearful town of killing a townie.
also, he just feels off (Again speed-read, but he consistently poked out as scummy).

I feel confident that lynching Millar will provide good information for playing this game further (If scum (I believe he is scum more than any other 1 person) than we learn that some people are crusadors, if town (I doubt it, more than any 1 else) we can see some people who tried a bit too hard to get this guy lynched).

Unvote:
Vote: MIllAR

[chihuahua0]

@chihuahua: Are you familiar with millar in any way (in other words: have you seen him play games, interact with the site, etc.)?

No. I never played a game with him and I don't remember seeing him around the site.


And as I stated before, there seem to be a relationship between Robocopter and millar. They might be lovers, but...

For now, to see if he complies. If he does not, he is of no use to us and a burden. One of the many reasons village idiots are so detrimental is that in LyLo people can't focus and choose scum because the VI is screaming "IM SO SCUMMY" and just gets in the way. We can't have that.

You don't remember me saying this? This is why I want Millar lynch. Because right now hes being the VI. We will most likely mislynch, why not take care of a burden to the town while we are at it?

This post makes me think he might be a mafia member disposing a VI scum, by voting for him and directing attacking him. The same argument can be made against me, but millar hadn't directed any posts at me, until I make him talk in his defense.

They seem too close and attacking their own lover is basically sucicide. So, is Robocopter town or scum?

[chihuahua0]

MOD: i'll stay
Vote: millar

lynch me instead
idc tbh

Oh, by the way, millar's defense was just bad. First he requested for replacement (coward's way out), then he changed his mind and self-voted himself. Self-voting is a scumtell and backing out simply sends the message that he's a weak player.