Open 226: Big Love - Game over! Town wins!

[Robocopter87]

No, Millar isn't my Lover. I don't think I would kill someone that would lose the town two people and take myself down too.

You've never heard of the infamous Millar? Millar is a marathon legend. But an old one, I don't think he still has that much fame in that area either anymore.

[Sanxion]

Vote; Millar

I don't think Robo is scum, even if Millar is town. His statements make sense, but Millar looks like scum. I would like to think it's just Millar, but he's just so anti-town, there might be good chance he is scum.

[millar13]

Vote; Millar

I don't think Robo is scum, even if Millar is town. His statements make sense, but Millar looks like scum. I would like to think it's just Millar, but he's just so anti-town, there might be good chance he is scum.

Weak point.

[chihuahua0]

Vote; Millar

I don't think Robo is scum, even if Millar is town. His statements make sense, but Millar looks like scum. I would like to think it's just Millar, but he's just so anti-town, there might be good chance he is scum.

Weak point.

Please explain why.


I looked up millar13 on the wiki. Pretty much what Robocopter said. Maybe I hadn't heard of him because I missed marathon day .

He's a total noob. His fate in this game is sealed.

[millar13]

Been here longer than you you little shit

[Robocopter87]

Alright, Millar is not acting like he is in other games. I want him dead.

[Fidelis]

He definitely deserves death. Even if he isn't mafia, he's still rather anti-town. And as far as getting information goes, we'll probably be better off finding scum without his distractions. I'm still pretty sure he's mafia though...

[Shattered Viewpoint]

He definitely deserves death. Even if he isn't mafia, he's still rather anti-town. And as far as getting information goes, we'll probably be better off finding scum without his distractions. I'm still pretty sure he's mafia though...

If you're "pretty sure" he's mafia....

WHY AREN'T YOU VOTING?


Millar is being a tool and very anti-town.

Vote: millar

MOAR MILLAR VOTES plskthx

[Robocopter87]

Mod, Can we get a vote count? Plz and thanks.

[millar13]

He definitely deserves death. Even if he isn't mafia, he's still rather anti-town. And as far as getting information goes, we'll probably be better off finding scum without his distractions. I'm still pretty sure he's mafia though...

FOS FIDELIS

prolly a scum player, not wanting too hammer or be near end of wagon

just saying

[yabbaguy]

Okay, come on.

Dizzy's

posted votecounts daily for a while now. We really need to stop asking for it considering she's never been in remiss.

I need millar town and Mafia meta before I can weigh in for certain. I'll hunt for it myself, but that's what I'll do sometime late, late tonight. My hunch is to say that emotional compromising and the fact that he nearly quit is scummy. Another part of me doesn't want the Day to end without input from the whole field of players, though.

More later.

[Robocopter87]

Okay, I just wanted to make sure Millar wasn't at l-1. Hes at L-3 I think.

[millar13]

Unvote

[Robocopter87]

Wow, decided to actually care have we, Millar?

[chihuahua0]

Been here longer than you you little sh**

But you aren't acting your "age".

Alright, Millar is not acting like he is in other games. I want him dead.

Say that to Robocopter87.

He definitely deserves death. Even if he isn't mafia, he's still rather anti-town. And as far as getting information goes, we'll probably be better off finding scum without his distractions. I'm still pretty sure he's mafia though...

He/she's right. You are acting anti-town by distrating us and not helping us find the Mafia. And you aren't acting like a doctor, as I stated before.

If you're "pretty sure" he's mafia....

WHY AREN'T YOU VOTING?

Yes, Fidelis, why aren't you voting?

[Xite91]

He's a total noob. His fate in this game is sealed.

Is it? how would you say that?
Honestly people, Millar is being a poor player, but please trust me and don't kill him?
It would be a huge favor to me

Also, Chihuahua, you seem the scummiest to me.

Unvote, Vote Chihuahua

[Robocopter87]

I am soooooo not unvoting because Xite thinks he knows Millar is town. Theres only one way to know that...

[chihuahua0]

He's a total noob. His fate in this game is sealed.

Is it? how would you say that?
Honestly people, Millar is being a poor player, but please trust me and don't kill him?
It would be a huge favor to me

Also, Chihuahua, you seem the scummiest to me.

Unvote, Vote Chihuahua

...

This suggests that either Xite91 or millar13 is the Treacherous Lover. Why the big favor?

[Mr.Sandman]

EBWOP: people like Mr. Sandman are the clear scum....people just needed a lesson in


"IT NEVER THAT EASY"

boneheads

Is this your attempt at scum hunting? Contribute nothing and then accuse the people that actually try and get some sense out of you of being scum?

Anyway, I'm happy enough to lynch Xite and millar if they're lovers as it appears, on the grounds of what Xite just said.

Millar, do you think this would be a good lynch for town?

[ZeroFang]

My view from the off...was for people to out themselves or admit they had loves;

outing a lover is the only way to take a step forward

The death of a lover removes two votes from the town, not just the one you'd get from a townie death. It's for that reason that outting lovers is a mafia strategy and not town one. Are you truly suggesting that the lovers claim and expose themselves to the mafia?

[millar13]

yes. Everyone should so it

that way..

1) the treacherous love will likely not step forward first
2) the remaining player will be mafia

[Robocopter87]

So your really gonna kill six people to find one scum?

[millar13]

The maths -

5 lovers are town- if they all cllaim then that is.....what 19-5 so 14 people

truly everyone knows who there love is....so out of a pool of six people you will be able to untangle who is scum and who isn't.

with 13 peoople left, two of them are scum. (so if the TOWN) decides to lynch town siblings, then they are making the mistakes.

MAFIA

wont NK siblings...if everyone is outed...because otherwise they will be left with SAY 2 siblings...and one will definetly be seen as scum. So either way a townie will be SACRAFICIED for a treacherous lover.

Its is really not that hard to comprehend

[chihuahua0]

The maths -

5 lovers are town- if they all cllaim then that is.....what 19-5 so 14 people

truly everyone knows who there love is....so out of a pool of six people you will be able to untangle who is scum and who isn't.

with 13 peoople left, two of them are scum. (so if the TOWN) decides to lynch town siblings, then they are making the mistakes.

MAFIA

wont NK siblings...if everyone is outed...because otherwise they will be left with SAY 2 siblings...and one will definetly be seen as scum. So either way a townie will be SACRAFICIED for a treacherous lover.

Its is really not that hard to comprehend

What you are suggesting is to kill all of the lovers.

Exactly what the mafia wants.

No lover will sacrafice themselves by stepping forwards. The mafia

will

kill the lovers, even if it means that the treacherous lover will die in the process. And people will lie and say that they're a lover when they're not.


Let see...no one will step forward during day one, so there should be about 15 people left? I persume that there are three killing roles. If all the lovers survive and then claimed, if the treacherous lover dies, there might be about 11 players left, with 2 mafia.

The mafia will kill off the two other couples, one at most, if the doctor is alive. You are thinking of killing 7 innocents to get one treacherous lover.

Bottom Line: You are scum.

[Robocopter87]

We should use our skills to scumhunt. We will lose One Townie instead of five this way. If we kill the treacherous lover through logical reasoning we will do better. You are suggesting a more detrimental process then needed.