Open 226: Big Love - Game over! Town wins!

[Robocopter87]

L-4 I do concur.

[Wacka Alpaca]

Hmm, I was hesitant to swap votes to Xite, because the only real reason I can think of to vote for him (Until that great summation by fidelis) was that he was acting like an idiot, and appealing to WAY to many people's emotions with the whole "plan" thing.
I am curious as to what the plan is though, but not enough so to not vote him if I see it fit.

Millar to me was mostly a vote on a horribly anti town player, who keeps promising content, but never delivers. which don't get me wrong, is good enough in and of itself, especially on D1.
I am still not quite convinced that we should stop scum hunting for today though, I mean, literally all we have done so found so far is:

Millar says Robo is his lover
Robo denies this
Xite says Miller is his lover
Millar denies this

To me, that still seems like we learn MORE from a Millar lynch, since we know if Robo is truthful, AND Xite.
If we kill Xite, and Millar DOESNT die, then we are still in the dark as to if Millar and Robo are connected.

My vote still stands on Millar.

[millar13]

Robo isn't my lover...don't get that wrong. That was a tactic to see if he would respond to it.

You can kill me today; actually i hope i am lynched

Vote:Millar

but when i do die and Xite91 doesn't
.

I implore you to go for him.

[chihuahua0]

chichi is scum. why are we bothering with xite and millar?

Even though I'm still considered a suspect, Xite and millar overshadow me as portenial scum. Good job for noticing that, though. But I'm not saying I'm scum, but the "Chihuahua is scum" theory is still out there.

Robo isn't my lover...don't get that wrong. That was a tactic to see if he would respond to it.

You can kill me today; actually i hope i am lynched

Vote:Millar

but when i do die and Xite91 doesn't
.

I implore you to go for him.

That was a weak post. You waited this late to clarify that?

But still, the purposed XMR triangle is prominet, though Millar is the top of it. And as stated before, millar might be a lover with Xite or Robocopter.

Out of these three, I'll vote millar for self-voting and for other reasons. And also the likehood that he's a treacherous lover:

UNVOTE:
VOTE: millar13

Mod: Vote count, please.

[don_johnson]

^^ see?

he's

even considering that he might be scum.

millar's self vote is disturbing.

[millar13]

What don't you understand...me self-voting isn't actually me going "IM SCUM"

self voting or sacrificing isn't actually always scummy. When i die; and Xite doesn't it proves...that he was lying and his attempt to pair up was really scummy. SO you can go for him next. And chiii...i already cleared up that Robo wasn't my lover a long time ago...your just selectively reading if u think differently.

[don_johnson]

vote: millar

your logic is fuzzy. xite could just be playin around. kind of like you were. oh well.

[yabbaguy]

Bu-bu-bu, logic! Logic says lynch Xite, and if it's a mislynch, millar dies as scum since he would be Lover! And if it isn't, Xite dies as scum!

Lynching Xite kills scum, therefore!

Unvote, Vote: Xite

!

[millar13]

Bu-bu-bu, logic! Logic says lynch Xite, and if it's a mislynch, millar dies as scum since he would be Lover! And if it isn't, Xite dies as scum!

Lynching Xite kills scum, therefore!

Unvote, Vote: Xite

!

this is actually someone playing with logic...but i dont think everyone listens to him.

[yabbaguy]

Yeah.

So why are you voting millar, millar?

[millar13]

So when i die; Xite doesn't...thus proving that he was lying.

(and maybe killing a lurking scum member in the process)

[yabbaguy]

It takes two Days to do the process you're describing. Mine takes one.

[Wacka Alpaca]

The argument between YaBbA and Millar is what I have also been saying, that Xite seems to be more of a KNOWLEDGE lynch, but Millar seems to be the better lynch overall.
we learn more from lynching Xite I think, but Millar still is being horribly anti-town, and STILL hasnt posted that analysis... which if he gets his way, will never be able to post (IE: hes dead).

Also, sorry if I forgot you revoked your claim to be Robo's lover, or if it was a joke all along, that peice of info just stayed with me, so i used it in my above post. Although, Robo does seem to be either:
1) Strong town
2) Strong mafia
Sadly, a great mafia and a great townie play almost EXACTLY the same, the only difference is that the mafia has an agenda, the townie doesnt.
I still have my eye on Robo, but to Millar I ask this:

Won't the mafia just NOT kill Xite now? Or am I missing something that makes Xite irresistable to being killed by mafia?
Let's say the mafia just doesnt kill him, then the town goes with your logic, and lynches him... now we (Possibly) have 2(or 3, or 4 if both are lovers with diff people) dead townies + mafia kill.
Is that what you want to (Possibly) die for?

Or again, am I missing something?

[Xite91]

Look, Xite, I'm not too tempted to trust you and your "plan" when you currently have a 50% chance of being a liar/scum. How do I know that your plan doesn't benefit scum in some way?

Because if it benefited scum I would tell you what it is, not telling makes it valid. I will tell you when the purpose is fulfilled if you just trust me until then.

Let me explain my request thing better.
In another forum I'm at, the GM's allow this kind of thing due to lack of activity, so for instance, I could PM him this instruction, and then take it back, or alter it the next time I log on.
Ex//: I would be equally happy lynching Millar (For his horrible anti town play) or Xite (For his childish actions, and obvious relation to Millar, plus the HUGE amount of appeal to emotion with the whole "plan" thing). So why shouldn't (While I am away with life during the day) be able to have the mod choose my actions for me.

At Robo, yes technically this is a laziness thing, nothing more really, but let's say that you guys all decide that we will lynch Xite for today, and you need one more vote; but im out, doing life stuff. Why cant the mod just add mine on from Millar in this event?

That is what I was meaning about the whole request thing.

OOOOOOOOOH!!!!!! So what you're saying is that you want to vote for the biggest wagon.

unvote vote Xite

Funny considering your last two posts and, you know, the lack of reasoning.

Even though I'm still considered a suspect, Xite and millar overshadow me as portenial scum. Good job for noticing that, though. But I'm not saying I'm scum, but the "Chihuahua is scum" theory is still out there.

Heh?

vote: millar

your logic is fuzzy. xite could just be playin around. kind of like you were. oh well.

Or maybe this plan I speak of is real and therefore you should just trust me and give me a chance to see if it works?

Please, I won't even oppose to a lynch on me if my plan goes horribly wrong, but I don't think it will.
Leave me and Millar for later.
Robo would still be a good lynch.
I'm can't say I hate the chichi idea either, except that I'd prefer to wait on him for a bit, he really just seems like noob, not sure if noobtown or noobscum yet, just leaning toward scum a slight bit more

[millar13]

im not going to post in this game anymore lol....

[Robocopter87]

I know this sounds like buddying but I know what you mean.

[Fidelis]

Bu-bu-bu, logic! Logic says lynch Xite, and if it's a mislynch, millar dies as scum since he would be Lover! And if it isn't, Xite dies as scum!

Lynching Xite kills scum, therefore!

Thank you! Finally someone else who uses immediate reason.

Because if it benefited scum I would tell you what it is, not telling makes it valid.

That's a bunch of crap. If it benefited scum, you obviously wouldn't tell us, because we would lynch you. No matter what you wouldn't tell us your plan, so I really don't feel inclined to trust someone who is most likely falsely claiming.

[DizzyIzzyB13]

Millar and Xite are REALLY bothering me (and that is hard, I mean given my history and all).

@Mod: Can we give you instructions?
Ex//: Vote for whoever has the highest vote count between Millar and Xite.
so that, if Millar has more votes at any given instant, I vote for him, and vice versa.
Is this possible?

The reason I ask, is because they are both acting like children, and drawing all of the town's attention to them, I mean, just look at the last 16 pages, who have we even discussed OTHER than Millar, Xite, and a tiny bit of Robo?
Whichever one goes first, I don't mind, I agree with Fidelis, either way, 1 for 1, it is a good trade (Hell, even 2 townies to one scum is a good trade in this game set up).

No.

[DizzyIzzyB13]

Vote Count #9

• chihuahua0 (smashbro_of_the_SSS) 1 (L-9)
  millar13 (ZeroFang, Mr.Sandman, Wacka Alpaca, Sanxion1, millar13, chihuahua0, don_johnson) 7 (L-3)
  Robocopter87 (Muthaa, Xite9) 2 (L-8)
  Xite91 (youngminii, Pittbunny, Fidelis, Robocopter87, yabbaguy) 5 (L-5)

Not voting: Guthrie, PaltryExcuse, Shattered Viewpoint, Reverse Simplicity

With 19 alive, 10 votes are required for a lynch.

V/LA: smashbro_of_the_SSS (Friday, July 9th)

Deadline is Wednesday, July 21st at 8pm UK time.

Activity Check!

I am still seeking a replacement for Guthrie and Reverse Simplicity.

youngminii still hasn't posted. Sigh. That's another replacement needed.

Prod Count:

Muthaa, Pittbunny, Reverse Simplicity, youngminii - 1

[millar13]

Vote: Xite91

[Wacka Alpaca]

Xite now looks to me like he is grasping air to cling to.
That big post of his doesn't make sense of anything, and really, is just an OMGUS post - a quick, one liner reply to a bunch of random posts before it.
He doesn't draw any conclusions from anything, and in the one related to me, directly ignores my reasoning behind the thing he is attacking me about, which again, screams of desperation.

I'm not liking Xite, and other than the horrible, horrible post by Millar where he says he isn't posting anymore (After promising pro-town analysis content), he is definately close to moving into #1 spot for scum for me.

[don_johnson]

unvote, vote: xite

let's do it then.

[PaltryExcuse]

/replace out. With my basement flooding I have limited time to catch up. Sorry all.

(Bet some people forgot / didn't know I was even in this game.)

[Wacka Alpaca]

Xite has surpassed Millar in votes, therefore

Unvote:
Vote: Xite

Also, sorry to hear about your basement, that must be infuriating and yet humbling at the same time.
I hope you do not suffer to many damages.

[don_johnson]

as long as there's no poo poo floating in it you should be fine.