Open 226: Big Love - Game over! Town wins!

[Xite91]

Nope, I'm back, and pitt's vote is already on me, i'm still at L-2

[Pittbunny]

Figured you'd notice. =/ Worth a shot.

[Xite91]

I lol'd

[Muthaa]

UNVOTE: whoever I was voting
VOTE: Xite
I'm really curious about your plan.

[Xite91]

Okay, I guess I'm telling my plan.
I am VT.
Here were my thoughts;
Millar is a scummy player
I am only able to get one kill if nk'd (aka no suicide involved in my death)
If scum take a shot in the dark at a townie, they could be a lover and bam, scum get 2 kills in a night.
If they shoot at me, then that's only one kill
If millar is scum, they're obviously not gonna kill him, but they will also know that I am not his lover = might try to kill me in the off chance I am a lover
The whole idea was to save town from losing 2 town in a night from 1

So there you have it.
And now it will never work

That being said, Millar who is your lover then?

[Muthaa]

It would've never worked anyways. And why do you want to know his lover if he really has one?

[Xite91]

because hes hinting so y not just say it?

[millar13]

Someone hammer this lying scum-bag!

[Xite91]

Uhm you were hinting weren't you?
And I told you my plan and my role, so what's the problem?
My lie was truly meant to help town, and it didn't cause any sort of mis-lynch.
I don't see why you're reacting so poorly millar.
Maybe because you were the bait?

[DizzyIzzyB13]

Vote Count #10

• chihuahua0 (smashbro_of_the_SSS) 1 (L-9)
  millar13 (ZeroFang, Mr.Sandman, Sanxion1, chihuahua0) 4 (L-6)
  Robocopter87 (Xite9) 1 (L-9)
  Xite91 (youngminii, Pittbunny, Fidelis, Robocopter87, yabbaguy, millar13, don_johnson, Wacka Alpaca, Muthaa) 9 (L-1)

Not voting: Enigma, PaltryExcuse, Shattered Viewpoint, Zajnet

With 19 alive, 10 votes are required for a lynch.

V/LA:

Deadline is Wednesday, July 21st at 8pm UK time.

Activity Check!

We have replacements! Please welcome Zajnet, who is replacing Guthrie, and Enigma, who is replacing Reverse Simplicity.

I am still seeking a replacement for youngminii.

PaltryExcuse has requested replacement.

Prod Count:

Muthaa, Pittbunny, Reverse Simplicity, youngminii - 1

[Zajnet]

Hai. I've been reading some of the game, so I don't have much to catch up on. Expect a post with opinions tonight or tomorrow morning.

[millar13]

Be a good new player and just hammer...

[Enigma]

Yo confirming

[Xite91]

Or read the game first so that you can see what's going on.
That's funny tho millar, mindless hammer so that A) one less town for scum (which I am now pretty sure you are) to deal with B)we can lynch you tomorrow on the mindless hammer idea

[millar13]

you will be dead....so not you

US

[Xite91]

First, that was me pointing things out in

your

perspective, sorry if i didn't make that clear
second, is your vote already on me? Yes
So it's no longer up to you if I die. Yes I might, but it's not necessarily true
Also, I like how you diverted the situation completely so you didn't have to answer to that

[Enigma]

OK this is from my initial read.

My aim for the read was to judge Xite from a fresh viewpoint and identify a few suspicious activities from people who have been drawing less attention. Wasn't expecting the Millar fiasco so kinda got a bit siderailed due to that. But here goes:

I won't be the one who hammers Xite. At least until I do another reread which won't be anytime today. Foolish behaviour doesn't necessary imply scum. I'd be more keen for those who have been actively lurking to be lynched, rather than players who formulate plans and express opinions to be lynched. It's just because of the sheer ratio of this game, there will be so many opportunities to lynch said player and if Xite truly is scum then maybe we can learn something else from him (or her? was it).

I believe Millar's claim about his lover being one of those on the prod list. Assuming he is a lover and take his earlier play into account, I think there is a possibility that he is telling the truth. And I don't think he is foolish enough to push the town's trust more than he already has.

As promised my scum reads from my initial read:

Ok, speed reading through this, I gotta say that I (Who has fresh eyes from not reading or being affected by this game yet) see most of Millar's actions as scummy.
In my experience, most people who request to be replaced out in a rage are scum, trying to play to a fearful town of killing a townie.
also, he just feels off (Again speed-read, but he consistently poked out as scummy).

I feel confident that lynching Millar will provide good information for playing this game further (If scum (I believe he is scum more than any other 1 person) than we learn that some people are crusadors, if town (I doubt it, more than any 1 else) we can see some people who tried a bit too hard to get this guy lynched).

Unvote:
Vote: MIllAR

My read took me over an hour. And you know what. I hate it when people say I think he is scummy but don't provide reasons.
Why do you think he is scummy early game?
What do you think you can learn if Millar is lynched (The Xite BS hasn't started yet)?

Also I had a case for Sanxion but it can wait until he posts again.
Just feels like he is actively lurking.

FOS: Sanxion

[don_johnson]

Or read the game first so that you can see what's going on.
That's funny tho millar, mindless hammer so that A) one less town for scum (which I am now pretty sure you are) to deal with B)we can lynch you tomorrow on the mindless hammer idea

what makes you think the lurkers are town? i wish i had two votes here.

[don_johnson]

ebwop: replace "lurkers" with "replacements". thanks guys.

[Xite91]

not saying they are, and if one of them quick-hammers then I do think people should put suspicion on them tomorrow, if it were someone else in my situation, I would do that for them, especially if they flipped town (and I swear to you now that there's no lies in my last claim, not that I'm expecting you to believe me because, hey, its mafia)
But yeah, I'm going to reread, Robo is still my main choice as scum, especially if millar flips scum. Either of them would be a good lynch to me today. This is mostly because their back and forth seems a lot like distancing, especially when robo calls it off when millar "promises to be a better player"

[Zajnet]

Be a good new player and just hammer...

No.

I'll finish the reread tomorrow morning because I'm going to bed.

[yabbaguy]

Policy

unvote

. Will analyze Xite's plan later.

[chihuahua0]

Hi, sorry for the day off.

Well, it seems like Xite was almost in a postion to be hammered. I would have done it, but...

Hi, Zajnet. We want to hear your suspects.

[yabbaguy]

Well, it seems like Xite was almost in a postion to be hammered. I would have done it, but...

YES! Mission get!

[don_johnson]

Hi, sorry for the day off.

Well, it seems like Xite was almost in a postion to be hammered.

I would have done it

, but...

Hi, Zajnet. We want to hear your suspects.

^^ but you don't even vote him. why are we not lynching this guy again?