Newbie 960 - Game Over

[Nikanor]

There are a lot more walls than I was anticipating in this game.
On page eight, it looks like Equinox and NDP (or whoever replaced him) are scum.

[Equinox]

i see some liquid rebuttal there not solid

What was wrong with NomDePlume's rebuttal, then?

[Locke Lamora]

Sorry for the lack of activity, I'm teaching for the first time tomorrow so I've got to make sure I'm ready for that! Will catch up tonight if I can, after my class tomorrow if not.

[I Am Innocent]

Still V/LA. We actually will be leaving our one friend's house Tuesday morning and going to our other friend's. Should have more internet access there/be around more as we get closer to the deadline.

Welcome Nikanor.

[Nikanor]

Welcome, Nikanor. I look forward to reading your analysis.

Ahahahaha. That's a good one, Neto. ME, write an ANALYSIS?

Anyway, I read pages 20-24, and I see that IAI is scum, probably with Sotty7. The fact that Sotty attacks IAI for legitimate points but doesn't vote him (when she's not voting in the first place), and then votes Neto (a town read for me since Tittiboo) for what I feel is comparatively less is weeeeird and consistent with scumbuddy play.

Let's lynch IAI first, though, since I'm more sure of him.

Vote: I Am Innocent.

[Nikanor]

Neto and andrew are probably town. We shouldn't lynch Neto today thanks.

[Sotty7]

You make me sad Nik. If Neto is town, Equinox is probably scum. With who, I have no clue yet.

Nothing Neto has done since coming in has made me not want to lynch him.

[Sotty7]

I actually had my vote active on Equinox when I started in on IAI. I unvoted because I doubted my thoughts on Equinox and was getting ready to place it on IAI but I decided against it after reading a couple of his games.

[Nikanor]

I don't think his actions make sense as scum. On top of that, the fact that it's you, Equinox, and IAI on the wagon does not exactly make me want to lynch him.

[Sotty7]

Don't hate me Nik.

But seriously, what makes you more sure on IAI? I had my argument with him for the set up speculation, but other than that he has felt really town to me. You say you are more sure of him over me, but you don't really explain why, where you have some (all be it bad) reasoning for suspicion on me.

With the above in mind, it is also strange that you would chose to spread your vote on IAI when I already have one vote on me. The deadline is coming up, if you think I am scum with IAI wouldn't it be more productive to vote me at this point?

[Sotty7]

Actually forget that last part there. Looking back the latest vote count is wrong, so voting for IAI isn't as scummy to me if you were working off that and I have no idea if you were or not.

Day 2 Vote Count - Deadline: Extended 3 days to Saturday, July 17 (11:59 pm CST)

7 alive; 4 to lynch

Netopalis (3) - Equinox, I Am Innocent, Sotty7
Equinox (1) - Locke Lamora

Not voting (3) - andrew94, Netopalis, Nikanor

Neto is voting for me unless I missed his unvote

[Netopalis]

I'd be willing to switch to IAI in a deadline crunch....So don't feel that you need to move it if you don't want to.

[andrew94]

There are a lot more walls than I was anticipating in this game.
On page eight, it looks like Equinox and NDP (or whoever replaced him) are scum.

i see no post of ndp and few of equinox on page 8?

[andrew94]

post 26 of ndp: Ugh, what a mess.

I've seen people using IKD's tone before and they flip town...

UNVOTE: ImKingDavid

post 28 of ndp: Obviously we need a lynch so I'll revert if necessary before the deadline. Has anybody got an alternative?

Ok, I'm here and we need to get a lynch sorted pronto. Out of IKD and Equinox I prefer IKD as the lynch.
Equinox has been incredibly indecisive and uncommital in her suspicions but it has been a hard first day and some of her stuff I thought was town talk. I suspected Ren strongly and nothing IKD has said has me reading him as town - apart from that "lynch me now" post which could just be as he and IAI say, a cool scum.

VOTE: ImKingDavid


please look at above.


also, i just THINK the rebuttal is not as solid as you said it was. in fact hes just defending his actions- any one can do that

[Netopalis]

IKD was lynched on D1. He was a townsperson. Seriously, read the bloody game.

[Equinox]

IKD was lynched on D1. He was a townsperson. Seriously, read the bloody game.

Insert quote tags into his post. He wasn't voting imkingdavid; he was quoting NomDePlume.

Please explain why you have a town read on Netopalis "since Titiboo." Titiboo was, at best, a null read because of the inactivity and lurking. Skill006 didn't take a solid position even when we were doing a deadline lynch on Day 1. Netopalis's buddying up to me is pretty insane.

[Equinox]

EBWOP: The second paragraph was directed at Nikanor.

[inHimshallibe]

Day 2 Vote Count - Deadline: Extended 3 days to Saturday, July 17 (11:59 pm CST)

7 alive; 4 to lynch

Netopalis (3) - Equinox, I Am Innocent, Sotty7
Equinox (1) - Locke Lamora
Sotty7 (1) - Netopalis
I Am Innocent (1) - Nikanor

Not voting (1) - andrew94

[Sotty7]

Andrew, why aren't you voting?

[Equinox]

Looking from that vote count and from andrew94's posting, we're going to have two competing bandwagons with people who won't budge and scum who may push for a No Lynch. Deadline is on Saturday. I'm getting antsy.

[Netopalis]

So, you absolutely are refusing to budge on I Am Innocent? Why?

Locke Lamora, where do you stand right now?

[Equinox]

No, I absolutely refuse to budge on Netopalis. Reasons have already been stated.

[Netopalis]

That's not what I asked you. You're worried about a no lynch, but you're just as unwilling to jump as the other side.

[Netopalis]

Oh, and I realize that I forgot to respond to your 3 points earlier.

1) Quote walls are not something that I normally like, but I don't see why my straying from my standard form of posting is scummy.

2) Quotes in cases can sometimes appear to be marginally relevant, because nobody's going to come out and say that they're scum. I think that my case is a fairly good one, though.

3) I've said my piece. It was only a one-line point in a list of player analysis earlier, and I didn't intend to "Buddy up" to you. I stand by the fact that you've made the most sense out of any player here. That doesn't point to alignment and you could still be scum. I really fail to see what is so scummy about that statement.

Altogether, I feel that the case against me is paper-thin.

[Equinox]

Hmm... You win.

Unvote

Deadline's on Saturday, so I think I have a couple of days to look again at all the case-slinging. I'm also open to the option of lynching Equinox, since that would settle more than a few questions before we go into LyLo (assuming worst-case scenarios). ...but wait until I've said my pieces first, though. It'd be a waste to lynch Equinox before I say anything. >_>