Open 226: Big Love - Game over! Town wins!

[don_johnson]

Who would you lynch today?

the little yippy dog with the brief sortie of fame in Taco Bell commercials of the '90s.

[Fidelis]

And chihuahua is coming off more nooby than scum, so I'm not voting anyone for now.

how so? please expand on this line of thinking as best you can.

Basically I don't believe that a scum would make so many blatant errors, especially after being called out on them over and over again. I am entertaining the possibility that he is noobscum, but I'm not commital about it. If you want, I can go find more specific examples of what makes me think he's more scum. And just so people know, I'm going to be busy this whole week so I won't be able to get on the computer as much as I'd like.

Thinking it over, I find this to be really scummy though:

Well, while {millar|chihuahua} would be a juicy, crunchy and wholly satisfying lynch (due to the whole clinical insanity thang) I'd prefer to start with Xite.

Vote: Xite

This really strikes a bad chord to me. Since he was lazy and only barely read posts, he is obviously just going with who the majority of players agrees on lynching. He's literally bandwagoning, hoping for an easy kill, without really knowing the reason behind it.

VOTE: Shattered Viewpoint

[Fidelis]

EBWOP:

If you want, I can go find more specific examples of what makes me think he's more scum.

I meant "more noobtown than scum". Sorry, didn't catch that in preview.

[don_johnson]

i accept your offer. please produce your examples of what makes chichi more "noobtown" than scum.

[chihuahua0]

Who would you lynch today?

the little yippy dog with the brief sortie of fame in Taco Bell commercials of the '90s.

I heard that.


Sorry for lurking for the past two-three days. I had been focusing on writing a story and RPing and I don't have a good reason to vote.

So, why am I scum?

[Robocopter87]

Why don't you go back and read the thread to find out?

[Pittbunny]

I'm going to take a dive here and suggest that not all scum play to perfection. Or even close. Spinning town around in circles via absurdedly stupid moves is also a scum tactic should scum believe that they wouldn't be able to keep up a solid 'town' play.

[DizzyIzzyB13]

Vote Count #12

• chihuahua0 (smashbro_of_the_SSS, don_johnson) 2 (L-8)
  millar13 (ZeroFang, Mr.Sandman, chihuahua0) 3 (L-7)
  Robocopter87 (Xite9) 1 (L-9)
  Shattered Viewpoint (Fidelis) 1 (L-9)
  Xite91 (youngminii, Pittbunny, Robocopter87, millar13, Wacka Alpaca, Muthaa, Shattered Viewpoint) 7 (L-3)

Not voting: Enigma, PaltryExcuse, Sanxion1, yabbaguy, Zajnet

With 19 alive, 10 votes are required for a lynch.

V/LA:

Deadline is Wednesday, July 21st at 8pm UK time.

Activity Check!

We have replacements! Please welcome Zajnet, who is replacing Guthrie, and Enigma, who is replacing Reverse Simplicity.

I am still seeking a replacements for PaltryExcuse and youngminii.

Prod Count:

Muthaa, Pittbunny, Reverse Simplicity, youngminii - 1

[Robocopter87]

Welcome Replacements.

[millar13]

WELKOMEN! JA

[Fidelis]

Bah, you know what, I looked back through the thread to find examples, and he does seem really scummy. VOTE: chihuahua0. I'm going out on a limb here saying this, but the only reason I was kind of sticking up for chihuahua before was because he's my lover and I didn't feel like dying. But I really think he's the most likely candidate for treacherous lover, so I'll gladly be a sacrifice.

[Sanxion]

VOTE: chihuahua0

It's all been said, plus Fidelis has been convinced as chi's lover, so I think this wagon is the clearly the best by far.

[yabbaguy]

Let's get a confirm/deny from chi, first. I like where this is headed, though.

[Robocopter87]

So we know that Chi is a lover along with Fidelis, so we kill the lover to have two deaths? Am I the only one missing something here?

[Fidelis]

@Robo:The two deaths in question here are mine and chihuahua's. I bet chihuahua is probably scum, so a one-for-one trade is great for town.

[Robocopter87]

unvote vote Chi

I shall help in this endeavor I guess.

[DizzyIzzyB13]

Vote Count #12

• chihuahua0 (smashbro_of_the_SSS, don_johnson, Fidelis, Sanxion1, Robocopter87) 5 (L-5)
  millar13 (ZeroFang, Mr.Sandman, chihuahua0) 3 (L-7)
  Robocopter87 (Xite9) 1 (L-9)
  Xite91 (Switz, Pittbunny, millar13, Wacka Alpaca, Muthaa, Shattered Viewpoint) 6 (L-4)

Not voting: Enigma, DavidParker, yabbaguy, Zajnet

With 19 alive, 10 votes are required for a lynch.

V/LA:

Deadline is Wednesday, July 21st at 8pm UK time.

Activity Check!

We have more replacements! Please welcome David Parker, who is replacing PaltryExcuse, and Switz, who is replacing youngminii.

Prod Count:

Muthaa, Pittbunny, Reverse Simplicity, youngminii - 1

[DavidParker]

Hi guys, hi doom followed u here.

Umm, i just quickly skimmed the "drama" filled part between millar and xite. Haven't read through everything. Right now, I believe xite's claim as a VT, and I find millar as a possible scum, and his recent games he has played blatantly anti-town so i won't take much convincing to get on his bandwagoning.

Anyways, i'll read thread through properly, and maybe give millar the benefit of the doubt

[yabbaguy]

Hi again, David. *groan*

jk.

Fidelis threw a claim down, and millar softclaimed his lover as being in the prod list, so those are both notable as well.

chihuahua and to a lesser extent SV seem scummy to me. You tell me.

[Enigma]

Yoooo Godz suppp.

Stuck on dial up speeds for the next few days how disappointing.

Anyways I would like to ask Fidelis if there is anything of interest in the lover quick topic thread (not sure if its against the rules or not as its not a quote) which would help the case against chihuahua.

Robocopter87 and yabbaguy are arguing. I think that's a scumtell.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Robocopter87

Why did you pick Robocopter and not yabBaguy? Just wondering...

Because someone was already voting for him, and I don't want to be accused for making a wagon with a random vote.

You never really answered this. Now would be a good time to answer why you were so worried about starting the wagon.

[Switz]

Hey, everyone, glad to be here, etc.

Okay, I've only done a quick skim of the thread so far, so I'll be doing a more dedicated re-read tonight. My initial thoughts were that we needed to lynch either of the Xyte|Millar pair but the Fidelis claim has sort of thrown me for a loop, so I'll be checking that out especially. I'd have to say it might be enough to convince me to jump on, since it seems anti-scum for Fidelis to claim at this point, but I'm reserving judgment for the time being.

[Wacka Alpaca]

Could someone make a analysis post on chihuahua? I haven't seen anyone explain why he is scummy, and to be honest, I did not know he was in the game until everyone started talking about him.
He was, and to an extent, is, off my radar.

I'm starting to "cool down" off of Millar and Xite, they do seem like misguided townies... and especially now that they are trying to help more than try to be idiots.
I will unvote, but will not cast a vote on anyone until I personally beleive they are worthy of being lynched, and until someone proves it to me, I will remain off of anyone.

Unvote:

*Note:*
I am going to reread all of chi-chi's posts, to see if i see anything.

[Fidelis]

Anyways I would like to ask Fidelis if there is anything of interest in the lover quick topic thread (not sure if its against the rules or not as its not a quote) which would help the case against chihuahua.

The Quicktopic is entirely blank. Neither of us posted in it before Day 1 started (I for one didn't know if it was allowed so I didn't risk it.)

And yes, it was statements like that bandwagon one that makes him pretty bad in my eyes. I would like to hear a defense of that and also why he didn't vote for Xite recently when he said he would have been glad to hammer.

[Xite91]

Sorry guys, meds are making it hard to focus on the games, saving you guys some trouble

Mod, please find me a replacement

[Mr.Sandman]

Apologies for the inactivity. Internet connection problems.

I'm inclined to believe Xite, despite the 'plan' being flawed in more than one place.

I would also like to see the case on chiahuahua. If we're looking for one lover who is scum, I don't think we should forget everything that miller's said and done, particularly taking into consideration his actions earlier. He's done nothing notably pro-town - hasn't produced cases when he said he would, self-voted, claimed about 4 different roles. I'm not defending chiahuahua but it seems like everyone's suddenly just forgetting everything that's happened just because a new wagon has sprung up.

I agree with Fidelis that SV looks scummy and although it doesn't look like a lynch which is particularly likely to happen today what with the miller, chiahuahua, xite prospects on the go at the moment, I don't think this should be ignored completely.