Supernatural mafia - Mafia team wins!!!!!

[Benmage]

Some mathematician quick, did hydrak just get hammered?

[ReaperCharlie]

The hammer has dropped, btw. Unless there are some shenanigans going on that screw with vote-counts.

[Nero Cain]

He's lynched but...

Rules:

11) Posting in

twilight

is acceptable, for both the lynchee and town members. Feel free to post as much or as little as you want of whatever you like.

[Sawyer]

Sawyer, you mean besides the fact that he has one of the most unbelievable claims I have ever heard, plus his attempt at defending KageLord before his lynch, made me suspicious of them.

Ok, so before the claim, when you had your vote down, the one reason was because he defended Kage? I assume that's why you suspect me as well?

Also, the following question wasn't rhetorical:

So you're saying that because I think Kage is suspicous for one reason, that means I should go along with any other reasons as to why he's scummy just because it helps the case against him? Hmmm, interesting.

Is that what you would do?

[jmj3000]

No, but you never bothered to post a case or any substantial reason as to why you found him suspect other than your initial post stating your suspicion. You instead just said your initial suspicion then nothing baout his later posts. You instead defended him and tried to discredit the people who were voting him with your speculation about what you thought he meant. You never once gave evidence to support your views, and he never came in to validate yours. Therefore, I think you were saying you were suspicious of him to just go along with the popular opinion of town.

[Sawyer]

No, but you never bothered to post a case or any substantial reason as to why you found him suspect other than your initial post stating your suspicion. You instead just said your initial suspicion then nothing baout his later posts.

Because I didn't agree with the suspicion of his later posts. How is that not obvious?

You instead defended him and tried to discredit the people who were voting him with your speculation about what you thought he meant. You never once gave evidence to support your views, and he never came in to validate yours.

I gave reasons as to why I thought what he meant, and in a post in response to you, no less.

Therefore, I think you were saying you were suspicious of him to just go along with the popular opinion of town.

Then why didn't I go along with with everyone else when they thought his conversational post was scummy? I'm baffled at how you came to that conclusion.

[jmj3000]

The point of the matter is the fact that your defense of him is based off of your speculation about what he said and no hard fact. As to why you didn't go along with town when they found his conversational post scummy, you wouldn't want it to be so obvious that you were just following along with town's suspicion. You have already stated when you signed up your are at least semi-experienced player, so I am sure you know how to play the distancing scum very well.

[Sawyer]

The point of the matter is the fact that your defense of him is based off of your speculation about what he said and no hard fact.

And everyone else's offense is based off of there speculation about what he said with no hard fact. Your point?

As to why you didn't go along with town when they found his conversational post scummy, you wouldn't want it to be so obvious that you were just following along with town's suspicion.

Is it just me or does anyone else think he's reaching here?

So you haven't noticed anyone else that outright went with the towns suspicion, rather than trying not to be obvious?

You have already stated when you signed up your are at least semi-experienced player, so I am sure you know how to play the distancing scum very well.

If you think I was defending Kage, how would I be distancing myself from him?

[hydrak]

Ummm... yeah I was really Castiel. And though my power was not explained in detail, that was my power as explained by Farside. I just reworded it w/ synonyms and changed the word order.

[ReaperCharlie]

So there is a cult in this game then.

[hydrak]

Ahh well. Maybe I'm not really dead yet. Sure hope so.

[hydrak]

More likely a cult recruiter. This role sounds extremely unlikely.

@Hydrak: You are saying that there definitely is a cult in this game, and you can undo the recruitment? Does it saying anything about what would happen when a recruited player reverts to town? Would they be stopped from telling us all the members of the cult? If not, wouldn't that be too powerful.

I do not have any information in my powers text then I gave. Farside was very vague when describing it. That may or may not have been purposeful.

Undoing recruitment was actually an idea my other head thought of when I was AFK @ the pool and was going to post it when I got back. Guess I was too late.

[hydrak]

EBWOP: By idea I mean theory.

[Chronopie]

Still doesn't seem much like a power that would fit the flavour. Cas raised Dean from hell, and he's angelically exorcised a few minor demons, and killed an angel or tow. And cut a finger off one of the horsemen of the apocalypse... and been resurrected twice(?) (In so far as being restored to earth)

Nothing would really fit cult un-recruiter.

--

Besides, that would be a broken role. Any ex-recruit would be able to say "Cult is X | Y | Z", or at least "Cult Leader/recruiter is X" depending on the cult mechanic.

[hydrak]

Still doesn't seem much like a power that would fit the flavour. Cas raised Dean from hell, and he's angelically exorcised a few minor demons, and killed an angel or tow. And cut a finger off one of the horsemen of the apocalypse... and been resurrected twice(?) (In so far as being restored to earth)

Nothing would really fit cult un-recruiter.

--

Besides, that would be a broken role. Any ex-recruit would be able to say "Cult is X | Y | Z", or at least "Cult Leader/recruiter is X" depending on the cult mechanic.

Even if it sounds cheap, my legit role is Cult Un-recruiter. Perhaps when a person would be recruited to the other side, they simply gain the win condition and cannot participate in the night kill or the quick-topic, so they wouldn't know who the other cultists are. I am thinking that is the most likely scenario.

[Nero Cain]

Still doesn't seem much like a power that would fit the flavour. Cas raised Dean from hell, and he's angelically

exorcised a few minor demons

Nothing would really fit cult un-recruiter.

[farside22]

hunting down:

Midnight's Sorrow (2) TheLonging, Sawyer
Hydrak (12) BlazezRb, Lowell, Chronopie, LynchMePls, GenericHydra, Snow_Bunny, animorpherv1, jmj3000, Benmage, Starbuck,
tubby216, MagnaofIllusion
Magna (2) Untrod Tripod, Midnight's Sorrow
TheLonging (1) Robocopter87
animorpherv1 (2) willows_weep, Nero Cain
willows_weep (1) GroupThink

Not hunting:

Hydrak
molestargazer
ReaperCharlie


With 23 alive it will take 12 to lynch.
Deadline is July 19th, 12:00pm PST

Starbuck stands over Kagelord.
The hunters look at her.
Is he dead?
Starbuck: "so far no movement."
Well we still have some light lets check into this guy Hydrak.
The investigation from the hunters have Hydrak tracked down. The 12 gathered around him.
We don't know what you are yet. We don't know what will kill you for now you will die.

Hydrak - lynched day 1 is waiting in the wings.

I will be out of town this weekend so Night 1 is extended. Deadline for Night 1 ends Sunday July 18th, 9:00pm PST
I may be late starting the thread.

[farside22]

The day had felt like a disappointment. There is still no word of who or what it was that was killed yesterday morning.
You start making circles and symbols on the floor in the hope of protection yourself during the night.


You salt the room. You keep a gun under your pillow and sleep unsoundly.

The morning arrives there are few numbers then there was when you went to sleep.
You find more dead bodies. One looks slashed, one looks shot and another body has litterally turned to ash.


The following players are waiting in the wings from last night:

Molestargazer - killed night 1
jmj3000 - killed night 1
Starbuck - killed night 1

[farside22]

With 19 players still living it will take 10 to lynch.
Deadline will be Aug 2nd, 6:00pm PST

[farside22]

By the way for those who are waiting in the wing:

You are in limbo between death and life. You can not post in the game or do a bah post till you are dead as a door nail.
Thank you.

[TheLonging]

This is frustrating, not knowing what they flip. With 3 dead last night, I'm thinking vig?

I'm about as far as pg 10, I'll compile a full post full of thoughts later (yay Talking Heads and Neutral Milk Hotel for helping me).

[LimMePls]

I really don't know what we're supposed to say. Is that 5 deaths with no flip? Vig + lynch plus 3 NKs?

@Mod: Will we ever get flips, or is that a game mechanic for this round?

[Snow_Bunny]

Ah, we need flips!!!

I'm guessing scum + vig + sk. But that's just a guess.

[animorpherv1]

Ah, we need flips!!!

I'm guessing scum + vig + sk. But that's just a guess.

or 2 scum groups (2 different demon types?) + vig.

[MagnaofIllusion]

I find it quite funny that Day 2 opens and we see an rush of Day 1 lurkers popping up to comment on game design and not discuss their almost total absence Day 1.

Until we see some flips this discussion seems rather pointless.

Hunt: TheLonging.

Nice of you to join us. You are tickling my scumdar already.