Supernatural mafia - Mafia team wins!!!!!

[farside22]

@Mod: Will we ever get flips, or is that a game mechanic for this round?

There will be flips

[Benmage]

Reaper, have you ever played in a game or read a game with a miller in? (If yes, which one(s)?)

Are you familiar with general miller consensus on this site?

[ReaperCharlie]

I am currently in one (a game with a claimed miller). As far as I am aware, site-wide consensus is that millers are supposed to claim day 1, right?

What's your point?

[ReaperCharlie]

Read: It sounds like you are trying to play the IC here; what in heaven's name makes you think I need that? 0_o

[Benmage]

I am currently in one (a game with a claimed miller). As far as I am aware, site-wide consensus is that millers are supposed to claim day 1, right?

What's your point?

Chrono didn't follow this line of thought, and yet you defend him.

Read: It sounds like you are trying to play the IC here; what in heaven's name makes you think I need that? 0_o

I wasn't I was trying be an IC, I was trying to understand your knowledge and experience with millers.

But as far as experience an level of skill...yours is lacking.

[Chronopie]

The reason I didn't claim Miller, is because my role isn't

specified

as a miller. I had the thought (overnight) that being a demon may be construed as miller-esqe, much like a vig to a gunsmith...

[Sawyer]

So you weren't told you were a millar?

[farside22]

Dean: Well, so you lie to them?
Sam: No, I just don't tell them... everything.
Dean: Yeah, that's called lying.

Hunting:

Tubby (6) ReaperCharlie, TheLonging, MagnaofIllusion, Sawyer, Benmage, Chronopie

Not hunting:

GroupThink
Nero Cain
animorpherv1
Snow_Bunny
Chronopie
GenericHydra
Midnight's Sorrow
BlazezRb
Lowell
Robocopter87
Untrod Tripod
LynchMePls
tubby216
willows_weep

LynchMe post 573
What is this vote you speak of?

[TheLonging]

The tubby wagon seems forced to me, I think there are opportunistic scum there. TheLonging for one.

Point out where I was opportunistic. Or where I was scum.

[Chronopie]

2) idk if we have any kind of cop,

but if we have one that detects Demons, I'd be a miller.

Thus the emphasis.

The reason I didn't claim Miller, is because my role isn't

specified

as a miller. I had the thought (overnight) that being a demon may be construed as miller-esqe, much like a vig to a gunsmith...

[Midnight's Sorrow]

I want to know why, in a game where the show its based on has demons and angles switching sides willy nilly, no one could believe Hydrak's claim.

Sounds fishy to me, no mater what he ends up flipping.

[LimMePls]

So any votes but Tubby votes are scummy RC? That is laughable.

[LimMePls]

The tubby wagon seems forced to me, I think there are opportunistic scum there. TheLonging for one.

Point out where I was opportunistic. Or where I was scum.

Clearly in the context of what I was saying, I think you were being scummy and opportunistic in your tubby vote.

@MOD: Whoops, thanks

Hunt: Chronopie

[ReaperCharlie]

So any votes but Tubby votes are scummy RC? That is laughable.

Nope, but the way you said it slapped me in the face and I couldn't just ignore it, now, could I?

And don't twist my words. What I said was: YOUR vote was scummy. Nothing about 'any votes except tubby votes are scummy'.

But while we're still on this subject, do you not think tubby is a good wagon? Why or why not? What in the H377 is wrong with TL's post? What's wrong with mine? What's wrong with ANY of them?

You sound like you're dissenting for the sake of dissenting, throwing a mass-FOS at a block of us like that.

Consider this your two-and-a-half^th strike.

[Chronopie]

Crowley on the Super-wiki.

--

The reason I was dis-inclined to believe a 'cult un-recruiter' claim, is because I would have expected Demons to be Mafia, rather than Cult. And Castiel, an Angel, doesn't exactly fit that kind of claim.

--

I could see yellow-eyes being a cult recruiter though.

[tubby216]

first of all this wagon smells of fear and cluelessness. so yah i think i will sit back have my PBR and work on my awesome mullet.

[TheLonging]

The tubby wagon seems forced to me, I think there are opportunistic scum there. TheLonging for one.

Point out where I was opportunistic. Or where I was scum.

Clearly in the context of what I was saying, I think you were being scummy and opportunistic in your tubby vote.

So uh, you can't provide reasoning

[ReaperCharlie]

first of all this wagon smells of fear and cluelessness. so yah i think i will sit back have my PBR and work on my awesome mullet.

Instead of concentrating solely on the wagon, yet ignoring all pressure to contribute, how about you actually help us win the game instead of being a useless moron?

What a novel idea.

[LimMePls]

So any votes but Tubby votes are scummy RC? That is laughable.

Nope, but the way you said it slapped me in the face and I couldn't just ignore it, now, could I?

And don't twist my words. What I said was: YOUR vote was scummy. Nothing about 'any votes except tubby votes are scummy'.

Twist your words? Are you kidding??? Here are you words, bolded for emphasis:

And LMP, the feeling I get from your counter-vote

(i.e. not a Tubby vote)

is that of a scum member trying

to establish a viable counter-wagon

... i.e. NOT constructive.

How exactly did I twist your words? You yourself said that you had a problem with it because it was "not a Tubby vote" and that I was "trying to establish a viable counter-wagon". How does that mean anything other than you have a problem with non-Tubby votes? Why are non-Tubby votes "NOT constructive"?

But while we're still on this subject, do you not think tubby is a good wagon? Why or why not? What in the H377 is wrong with TL's post? What's wrong with mine? What's wrong with ANY of them?

You sound like you're dissenting for the sake of dissenting, throwing a mass-FOS at a block of us like that.

Consider this your two-and-a-half^th strike.

What are you talking about? I even called out TL by name, I wasn't "throwing a mass-FOS". And no, I don't think a tubby lynch is right, but you guys go ahead if it makes you happy. I tend to agree with his observation that lynching while we have 5 dead unknowns is risky. Think about it, except for the fact that there are fewer targets its like its still D1. We have little more info than we did. As for his "scum-slip", I don't think assuming cross kills in a game this size is scummy. If you all see it as a slip, well I can't fault you, but that's not the way it read to me at all.

"Strikes" from you don't scare me at all RC. As for your accusation of me throwing out FOS's:

HOS: ReaperCharlie

For claiming I misrep him when he CLEARLY said he didn't like my vote because it was non-Tubby.

My hunt on Chrono stays. His "fake breadcrumb" should be translated as "lie" and now he's claiming millar, only not millar. Seems really scummy to me.

[Chronopie]

Shy of quoting my Actual Role PM (Modkill territory), I've put my entire role out there. So try finding some

Actual

scum. kthx.

[LimMePls]

The tubby wagon seems forced to me, I think there are opportunistic scum there. TheLonging for one.

Point out where I was opportunistic. Or where I was scum.

Clearly in the context of what I was saying, I think you were being scummy and opportunistic in your tubby vote.

So uh, you can't provide reasoning

It's really quite simple.

well we could always not hunt today and see if that forces the flips from yesterday. cause otherwise we are hunting blind and who knows what we will end up killing.

No that is a terrible idea. I'm sure there's a role that will reveal flips. I would much rather hunt someone today.

Hunt: tubby216

Your vote is almost completely void of reasoning. You vote him because he suggests we maybe shouldn't lynch with 5 dead unflipped players. Why exactly is this suggestion scummy? Did you suspect Tubby prior to this? Have you ever even mentioned Tubby this game so far? I'm thinking no. Remember this is before he makes the statement that others saw as scummy (about the scum cross-kill). Even if you disagreed with his suggestion that we shouldn't hunt, why does that mean he should be the one hunted?

I've put my entire role out there. So try finding some

Actual

scum. kthx.

Shhhhhh scum, I am.

[tubby216]

first of all this wagon smells of fear and cluelessness. so yah i think i will sit back have my PBR and work on my awesome mullet.

Instead of concentrating solely on the wagon, yet ignoring all pressure to contribute, how about you actually help us win the game instead of being a useless moron?

What a novel idea.

how about i tried that that Captian Clueless and i got my hand smacked for it and you and your mindless minions are tryin to get me killed. So i think I just do you and you try to play the game a lil better ok thankx

Hunt: Reaper Charlie

[ReaperCharlie]

What makes them my mindless minions? Just because you're being a doof and not providing any content and I was the first to call you out on it and others quickly followed? Hahahahahahahaha

[tubby216]

What makes them my mindless minions? Just because you're being a doof and not providing any content and I was the first to call you out on it and others quickly followed? Hahahahahahahaha

Really?? all I am saying is that you are not the white knight here ,,nor are you the paragon of mafia hunters here.

[ReaperCharlie]

No I'm not, and I never said I was, but you're a better lynch than anyone else at this time for a number of reasons.