Open 231: My Name is Earl (Game Over)

[XScorpion]

He fooled me because I wasn't paying attention to him as closely as I should have been (as I said yesterday, I didn't particularly care if Beefster lived or died), due to the fact that I wasn't particularly interested in participating in his lynch on day 1 AGAIN (I wanna play a full game with him, damnit!).

[nocase]

yes, xscorpion, i do. i've been playing my cards close to my vest but given that i think i've left a relatively transparent train of thought. thank you for finally admitting that you are in fact being completely useless. if you "haven't got any idea what to do," why don't you start by analyzing other people's cases or interactions, or rereading the thread, or reading some players in isolation, or . . . god, i don't know, the usual things you do when you play mafia.

vox technically isn't far less likely to be scum than d3x, but his play looks honest and i don't buy the case against him.

[XScorpion]

why don't you start by analyzing other people's cases or interactions, or rereading the thread, or reading some players in isolation, or . . . god, i don't know, the usual things you do when you play mafia.

Well see, normally this is what I do, but this is the first time I've played with people who think that:

voting without (immediately) stating a reason is neither anti-town nor scummy.

So perhaps you can understand why this game is a bitch to read in ISO. That's why I might as well just ask people questions now rather than re-read, since all I'm gonna find in ISOs are stupid things like:

unvote. vote: xscorpion. he's a slippery guy.

Umm... yup.

UnVote/Vote:Beefster

So yeah, whoever is town, thanks a lot for making the game more tedious than necessary.

What exactly about the AV case do you disagree with?

[TheButtonmen]

-headdesk-

I forgot to bookmark this thread.

Here and catching up.

[XScorpion]

Catching up? You made a vote. Surely you already thought about it before you made it?

[nocase]

i'm halfway out the door so i'll answer scorp later, but on another note if there's a cop in this game and he has an innocent report on someone not the doc then this is practically auto win for town (newbie 805). might want to look into that.

[TheButtonmen]

Yes, I was caught up when I voted 2 days ago.

I havn't read anything in the last 48 hours, hence catching up.

[XScorpion]

Vote: NoCase

This is exactly the kind of nonsense that hurts town. Seriously, I'm just going to vote the next person to vote without explanations out of spite.

[nocase]

unvote. vote: xscorpion.

[TheButtonmen]

nocase you sound way to informed about the set up.

[TheButtonmen]

How do you know there's a doc and how do you know there's no roleblocker?

[nocase]

that's right. forgot about roleblocker. in newbie 805 the roleblocker was lynched day one.

never mind then.

[XScorpion]

unvote. vote: xscorpion.

You already explained your vote earlier. Nice try.

How do you know there's a doc and how do you know there's no roleblocker?

There is probably a doctor because no one died last night.
If there is a cop and doctor then there is a roleblocker, so I dunno wtf is going through nocase's head.

[nocase]

yeah, see above. goddamn it.

[Scott Brosius]

Vote Count #13

AurorusVox (2) - Rhinox, Budja
Budja (0) -
ConfidAnon (0) -
d3x (1) - ConfidAnon
nocase (1) - TheButtonmen
Rhinox (0) -
TheButtonmen (0) -
XScorpion (3) - AurorusVox, d3x, nocase

Not Voting (1)- XScorpion

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch. Deadline is August 12, at 11am EDT.

[nocase]

goddamn it, button.

[TheButtonmen]

?

[XScorpion]

Vote: NoCase

Why?

[nocase]

content, button.

[ConfidAnon]

vote: AurorusVox

Very confident about this.

I'm kind of glad you present such awesome arguments that I can sheep off of. Baa.

But seriously, this logic is extremely sound.

Also, sorry that I've been quiet, I'm kind of busy.

Unvote, Vote: AurorusVox

[d3x]

was called out for forgetting about beefy. From that point on, was pretty much "ok with either beefy or xscorp lynch"

Can you point out where this happened? Because I'm pretty sure you're making things up to make me look bad.

@nocase- Care to discuss p160 now?

[nocase]

i said that i'd reread it and no longer thought it was important. he made a good point.

[nocase]

d3x, why xscorp?

[AurorusVox]

Rhinox, Budja, ConfidAnon -

None of you have made any responses to my defence against Rhinox's points. Anyone fancy saying something about that or do you just want to lynch me without even reading my posts?

[d3x]

Why XS what? Why is he Scum?

If so-
I think that the whole 'Townies play this way' from D1 feels very forced {mostly related to Voting with reasons}. I think the clear discrepency between AntiTown and scummy play is very pertinent {along with the strawman of calling it a semantics debate immediately after being called out}. In responce to me pointing out the difference between his own statements, he started flailing and imo stopped any real ScumHunting. I don't like his interaction with Beefy at all from either side {especially the part about having weak meta on Beefy being Town and Beefy's noncommital jump to defend XS}. The RoleFishing on Xite. His reaction to the FakeClaim. The last ditch effort to stop the Beefy Lynch.

That pretty much sums up my feelings on him.