Monty Python Quest for the holy grail, GAME OVER!!!

[mathcam]

Are we agreed that Fishbulb and God should role claim? I say yes.

Cam

[rite]

As do I

[Werebear]

You know, DS still hasn't told why he's SURE SURE SURE Concorde is who he says he is. Everyone else doesn't see why Arthur shouldn't be a sane cop, DS is the only one dissenting, and everyone's following him.

PICK WHAT YOU WANNA DO. For heaven's sake.

[Dragon Slayer]

I don't have a problem with God and Fishbulb claiming. It should certainly shed somemore light on things. However, you'll all just have to believe me when I say that Concorde/Pasty (same thing) IS in the game. I really don't want to claim.

-DS

[Night Stalker]

DS> I thought you had voted Fishbulb becuase you unvoted him today.

That's why I'm confused!

From the previous page:

Stop this! I know Loose Cannon is just the innocent Pasty/Concorde. And his role ability is also basically true. Stop voting him. There's obviously somthing wrong with Orbiting results and lynched these people just to find out won't do any good when I can tell you for a fact that one (Loose Cannon) is definetly innocent. I will not yet reveal my role.

Unvote Fishbulb

.

-DS

However, if you are who I suspect you are, then Loose Cannon is innocent, no matter how much I'd like to believe otherwise. (Of course, if it turns out you're not...)

unvote: Loose Cannon

vote: god

[bane221]

Ok: I've been trying to find the support to these arguments, and it's there, just tough to pick out which side to take in all of this. NS: I'm curious who Slayer is, care to share? Also if Fishbulb and/or God are going to roleclaim, as at least one of them should, then waiting for that is in the town's best interest.

[Dragon Slayer]

I think you know, too, NS. It's not hard to figure out. Don't say...

-DS

[Werebear]

Fine, fine, fine...

Vote: God

Obviously ARthur gets guilty for some reason, maybe so simple as if they're a knight or not. Who knows. But Arthur gets innocents, so we should focus on the guilty.

[God]

No fake claim this time, I'm a peasant. Perhaps Arthur thinks I would delay the quest....

Help! Help! I'm being repressed!

[Dragon Slayer]

So where are we on our list of claims.

-DS

[Night Stalker]

I suppose I could buy that.

Unvote: god

Vote: Fishbulb

[Macros]

2 loose cannon (Mathcam, Rite)
1 Fishbulb (Nightstalker)
1 God (Werebear)

[mathcam]

Unvote: Loose Cannon, Vote: Fishbulb

Claim, Fish boy!

Cam

[God]

yeah fishy, your turn...

[Werebear]

Unvote, Vote: Fishbulb

So we have Concorde and a peasant claiming on Arthur's list. Not any provable roles so far...

[Fishbulb]

Sorry for the delay. The break left me little chances to have computer time.

I am Brother Maynard, a doc, and if the rabbit attacked me he would've been blown to tiny bits with the Holy Handgrenade of Antioch.

[mathcam]

Hm, relatively believable.

Unvote: Fishbulb

.

Cam

[Werebear]

I know I've missed one or two things, someone add to this? Also, there are probably three more evil roles.

EVIL DEAD

1 French
2 heads
The Rabbit (SK)

GOOD DEAD

2 Minstrels
Sir Bedevere
1 knight who said Ni!
Tim The Enchanter
Bridge keeper
Galahad
Roger the Shrubbist

CLAIMS

Night Stalker - Black Knight (mod given)
Fishbulb - Brother Maynard, doc
Jadesmar- replaced by God2 - a peasant
Loose Cannon - concorde
Orbiting - King Arthur

Dragon Slayer - hinted at a role
Bane221
Darkblade
mathcam
Rite
Wearbear

Roles not claimed - Lancelot, Robin, Patsy, Prince Herbert, The King, Zoot, Dingo, Sir Bors, Dennis?

Fishbulb - who have you protected so far as doc?

[Fishbulb]

Night 1: Polotet
Night 2: Thoth
Night 3: mathcam
Night 4: Saigon
Night 5: mathcam

Mostly random, I haven't been able to read people this game. I feel pretty good about mathcam, though. I know, I should've protected our "cop" last night, but seeing as the baddies would assume he was covered and would pick someone else,

and

considering he got bad results on me...

Is there a possibility of there being only one French left? Maybe there were only two to start with. Then we'd have only one Head and one French. Dunno, just a thought.

[rite]

In any case, I think it's obvious that role claims are now crap. We've got more potential roles than we do unclaimed people, and I could easily see any of those potential roles in the game (save one, for reasons I'll reveal later).

[Orbiting]

Vote: God

I find it hard to believe that with all the named roles in the film, he'd be given an unnamed role (peasant). Oh, that and I already investigated him...

Sorry for the absence, holidays are happening with a vengeance in my world, and my being able to focus on the boards is sporadic. Not trying to confuse anybody, so I hope this helps:

I got one flat out guilty/innocent result (i.e. Macros actually used the word "guilty" or "innocent" in the message). That was Thoth, innocent. As it turns out, Thoth was innocent. My other results talk about "seeks to delay the quest" and "is dangerous", that sort of thing.

There is no other component to my role, at least as far as Macros has told me (I say this only because one of my last games was Werebear's HHGG game, in which almost everybody had some extra ability that they didn't know about until it happened. I don't think Macros plays this way, but you never know.)

[mathcam]

Yeah, peasant's just not that believable. Or, at least, as unbelievable as they're going to get, and

much

less believable than Brother Maynard. The one thing that stops me from being sure is that there were 2 minstrels in the game.

Vote: God

Cam

[Fishbulb]

I'm gonna have to agree with you guys there. Unless he

is

Dennis, I don't see plain peasants being in here. And mathcam, about the minstrels, my thoughts are that they are the "townies" in this game. The don't have any abilities, correct? So why have minstrels

and

peasants. Doesn't make sense to me.

Vote: God

[Macros]

3 God (Orbiting, Mathcam, Fishbulb)
2 Fishbulb (Nightstalker, Werebear)
1 loose cannon (Rite)

[mathcam]

I thought maybe the minstrels were masons or something. We have little information about roles after their death.

Cam