Open 231: My Name is Earl (Game Over)

[nocase]

As scum why would scorpy draw more attention to himself with his post-claim antics?

[AurorusVox]

Because he'd said this before the lynch:

Sure.
Congratulations to town on outing the cop on day 1.

I highly doubt he's lying. Are you seriously suggesting we still lynch him?

Perhaps he was trying to rationalise his reaction to the vote.

[AurorusVox]

EBWOP

*reaction to the claim

[AurorusVox]

Budja, what reasons do you have to believe TheButtonmen is town?

[d3x]

@AV- I'd thank you not to answer for me.

@nocase- I think it was an over-reaction followed by an attempt to lend credibility to the FakeClaim. Generally, I call it a slip.

[AurorusVox]

@AV- I'd thank you not to answer for me.

Sorry about that. Because nocase's post was at the top of the new page and he didn't put "d3x" or quote you, I didn't realise he was following up on your post but thought he was asking a general question to everybody ><

[nocase]

why would scorp risk drawing a line like that between himself and his scum buddy?

[AurorusVox]

why would scorp risk drawing a line like that between himself and his scum buddy?

Is this for d3x or me? ><

[XScorpion]

@nocase- I think it was an over-reaction followed by an attempt to lend credibility to the FakeClaim. Generally, I call it a slip.

You insult me, sir!

[Scott Brosius]

Vote Count #14

AurorusVox (3) - Rhinox, Budja, ConfidAnon
Budja (0) -
ConfidAnon (0) -
d3x (0) -
nocase (1) - TheButtonmen
Rhinox (0) -
TheButtonmen (0) -
XScorpion (3) - AurorusVox, d3x, nocase

Not Voting (1)- XScorpion

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch. Deadline is August 12, at 11am EDT.

[ConfidAnon]

Rhinox, Budja, ConfidAnon -

None of you have made any responses to my defence against Rhinox's points. Anyone fancy saying something about that or do you just want to lynch me without even reading my posts?

Not posting a response =/= failure to read a post.

I read it, I am just more swayed by Rhinox's argument.

This post sounds like a desperate scum attempt to smear those who are voting them.

[d3x]

I'll be on later tonight {hopefully} with game stuff, but let this serve as warning.

Mod

- Plz note the sig. Thx.

Noted.

[Budja]

@Aurorus, You are probably scum by elimination, further Beefster interaction. Not much you can say.
I've already said why Button is town.

[AurorusVox]

@Budja; "Not much I can say"? I disagree, because I've posted my defence, and I feel I said a lot there. Do you feel my defence is feeble? Please point out which parts of it are no good. And you said that thebuttonmen is town because he was the third Beefster vote? But, that was Col.Cathart. I'd like to hear what thebuttonmen has done himself to make you think he's town. Or is it simply based on the Colonel's play? Because would it not have looked suspect if Col. had unvoted on the primary wagon before going V/LA? Since he returned from V/LA he admitted he couldn't get into the game. I'm seeing townie in Colonel, sure, but it's not impossible that he was scum, and thebuttonmen hasn't done much at all since replacing in.

@ConfidAnon; it does feel like you're not reading it because you have given no indication of having read it. Same question to you as I put to Budja; which parts do you find of my defence to be the least convincing? I stand by my decision to not hammer immediately, because if he had been the cop, we'd be a cop down. I stand by my concern over voting to put Beefster at L-1 before going V/LA, because I wasn't going to be here to change that important vote if need be. Is it these? Or something else?

To both - if you're adding nothing new to the scumhunting of me, then if I get lynched (and therefore flip town), you can just say "Hey, I was convinced by Rhinox's arguments." In the interests of giving town something else to work with, and this is to Budja in particular, what exactly do you find scummiest about me that puts me as a better lynch than someone else?

[nocase]

my previous question was meant for d3x. sorry, vox, baby.

vox, how okay or not okay are you with getting lynched today?

[XScorpion]

Button is around on the site, yet not posting here. He is actively lurking, and has yet to explain his actions. I'm not feeling comfortable with this.

vote: TheButtonman

[AurorusVox]

nocase, are you trying to role-fish me? I've got my answer but I don't know if I should say in case you're looking for something in my response; I'll gladly answer if people think that your post has no malicious intent.

[XScorpion]

I don't think it's malicious intent, I just think it's a really stupid question. I won't mind if you ignore him.

[AurorusVox]

vote: AurorusVox

Very confident about this.

I'm kind of glad you present such awesome arguments that I can sheep off of. Baa.

But seriously, this logic is extremely sound.

Also, sorry that I've been quiet, I'm kind of busy.

Unvote, Vote: AurorusVox

A further question for ConfidAnon; how comes you had earlier voted for d3x, despite Rhinox's "extremely sound logic" already being posted (about six posts previously)? What changed between your d3x vote and your vote for me?

[nocase]

no, vox. answer my question role-related info aside.

[nocase]

xscorpion, i appreciate your criticism. why don't you back it up with doing something remotely meaningful at some point in this game?

[nocase]

you know, don't answer the question. it's too wifomable.

[nocase]

what does everyone think of col.cathart's play?

[XScorpion]

OK how about this: would you like to explain your motives behind the last 3 questions you've asked? Here, I'll even quote them for you:

vox, how okay or not okay are you with getting lynched today?

why would scorp risk drawing a line like that between himself and his scum buddy?

As scum why would scorpy draw more attention to himself with his post-claim antics?

As someone voting me, I don't understand your need to ask any of these questions. Do you want me lynched? Or are you looking for someone to answer these questions because you want someone to confirm your suspicions?

[XScorpion]

Col. Cathart's play doesn't give very much info onto his alignment. Yes, he supported a Beefster wagon, but that could simply be distancing and he may have planned to unvote later, but never got a chance.