Supernatural mafia - Mafia team wins!!!!!

[ReaperCharlie]

I shot Midnight's Sorrow last night, rofl.

[farside22]

With 16 alive it will take 8 to lynch.
Deadline is August 11th, 8:00pm PST

[TheLonging]

At least we got flips

And welcome back SB!

[Kmd4390]

Damn. Didn't finish my read. Well, here's what I have so far:
Ok, attempting to do all of this read in one day because I got told not to come into work today. Keep in mind I'm doing this during night, so even though this will be posted Day 3, anyone dying Night 2 is being talked about as if they were still alive because at the time that I am reading, they are.

I already said I found Reap and Animorph scummiest in the first two pages. Kage was obvtown by the way, but that's irrelevant now.

On to Page 3. LynchMePls might be scum. Not as scummy as Reap or Animorph though. Same with Starbuck. Robo and Midnight seem to like posting irrelevance. At least one of them is scum, maybe both.

I get to Page 4 and change my mind on LynchMePls. Leaning town now. Midnight's vote on Benmage is crap. Willows, why FoS Benmage instead of voting him? Ok, there is a scum in Midnight/Willows/Nero. So for clarification, at least one scum in that group, Reap/Animorph both scummy, Starbuck/Robo slightly scummy with Robo being scummier than Starbuck. I'd probably be voting Midnight if I were in the game at this point.

Page 5 now. And LynchMePls gets scummy again. I can tell already that he's gonna be the player I have trouble reading all game. Reap saying LynchMePls is scum for saying "the town" like he isn't part of "us" is scummy. Notice how Reap was sure to use the word "us" when making this point. (Wait, he was joking?) Robo still isn't being useful and is therefore scummy. I don't like Midnight's vote on Kage with no other text in the post. LynchMePls's vote on Kage is scummy.

Page 6. Magna's catch up post is awful. Any KageLord votes AFTER LynchMePls, I fully understand. He started to get scummy. That being said, I'm sure at least 1-2 scum took the opportunity to ride this easy wagon. Jmj is town for seeing pretty much the same thing I saw in Kage's post. Again, Midnight and Robo make scummy posts.

Page 7, I lol'd at Robo's "that's all you have to say?" when he himself hasn't really added anything to the game. Post 160 by Reap is townier than the rest of his game before that point. Hmm. Ok, it's been an hour of reading. Time to call it quits for now.

Three hours later...

Page 8. Midnight's "gut read" on the leading wagon and overexplanation of why he won't elaborate on the gut read is ridiculously scummy. He needs to be lynched. Also, same post, he seems to defend his lack of content pretty hard for someone not being attacked. Nero, scummy post. Robo, scummy post. Post 190, Magna defends his scumbuddy LynchMePls.

Players I want dead ASAP:

Midnight, Magna, Robo, Nero, LynchMePls, Animorph[/b]. Willows would be next on the list followed by Starbuck, but they aren't scummy enough for me to push hardcore.

Page 9. Magna's lurker callout of three players when several others are just as bad is interesting. Not sure why Tubby is trying to be scummy. Robo gets hypocritical again. Robo speculating on a cult is bad. Ok, Midnight's vote on Magna throws me off a little.

Page 10. Post 246 by Reap is one I completely agree with. Kage's post that Reap references seems to basically just show interest in the theme. The fact that people are making a case off of it is ridiculous.

Page 11. Robo is so obvscum.

*Sigh*. It's so hard to stay on a computer long enough to read all this. Break time again.

[Lowell]

I still have literally no idea what's going on. I guess I'll see if the flips do anything for me.

[Super Smash Bros. Fan]

I'm glad to see that Starbuck has returned to the game. Given his Day 1 play and his claim (Which he proved by killing KageLord), I am 99% confident that he's town.

I was really surprised that animorpherv1 flipped town. Will need to look more closely into his bandwagon as I do think we have scum on them.

As of now, my top two suspects are Chronopie and ReaperCharlie. Both are great lynches for today. But let's see what Chronopie gave us on July 25, 2010:
ISO 26: Talking about animorpherv1's claim and the possibility of fakeclaims provided to scums.
ISO 27: Asks if animorpherv1 had any last words and if we had anything else left to say. Also said he announced intents to hammer.
ISO 28: Said that now that ReaperCharlie hammered, it was the time to say something.

Let's give them a further look:

ISO 26 is full of fluff. As shown with his other posts, Chronopie puts too much emphasis on roles instead of actually scum hunting. He also tries to prove that animorpherv1's claim might be true. This wouldn't be a problem, since animorpherv1 flipped town, except for one thing:

ISO 27, he announces intentions to hammer. He immediately distance from animorpherv1 by announcing intention to hammer. If he wanted to hammer, he should have told us he was going to do it, no need to stall around. This gives me the feeling Chronopie-scum is trying to remove responsibility for the mislynch by announcing intentions to hammer and hope that ReaperCharlie gets all the blame.

But wait, there is also hypocrisy in ISO 27 and ISO 28. He asks us for our last words, yet never really say anything about the animorpherv1's bandwagon up until then.

So yeah, further solidfy my scum read on him:

Vote: Chronopie

[SpyreX]

I'm obviously out of my element with the mechanics:

We got specific kill flavor night 2 but not night 1.
Yesterday's lynch flipped by not day 1's.
Starbuck got revived.
We didn't get a 4th shot last night.

I dont even know. I was banking HARD on getting that D1 flip in regards to the cult and clearing some people. Further, MoI AND Benmage dying doesn't give me those fuzzy RC feelings.

And ani's whole business and him flipping vanilla? God

[TheLonging]

Yesterday's lynch flipped last night, not right on the lynch. I'm betting we didn't lynch any scum.

[TheLonging]

Vote: tubby

Am fine with a Chrono lynch too, but let's work our way up mmk?

[Super Smash Bros. Fan]

Vote: tubby

Am fine with a Chrono lynch too, but let's work our way up mmk?

No offense, but as said by me and others, tubby216 sounds more of an easy lynch then a best lynch. If he's town, this is exactly what scum wants us to do. ReaperCharlie and Chronopie have a lot more backing them up as scums then tubby216. What makes you think that Chronopie/ReaperCharlie aren't the best lynches for today?

[Nero Cain]

But aren't we forgetting about Group Think and Lowel?

[ReaperCharlie]

I am betting 100% that scum killed off Magna and Benmage just to make me look bad. Those are the last people I would kill. Magna was pretty pro-town and 77% awesome except for thinking I was scum, but I admit I didn't like Benmage. And I wouldn't have shed many tears if LMP or tubby died either. I didn't want to kill tubby though because obv that'd put me in Magna/Benm's sights even more firmly. Anyways. Midnight's Sorrow was a good choice for my one shot if I do say so myself. In other games I've seen him in, he's really anti-town even as town, and he certainly wasn't acting pro-town in this game either. Hopefully he flips something red, or at least not-green.

And I also must say I am surprised that I didn't die last night. But since I killed MS, and I know for sure Magna's mason buddy didn't kill Magna, then I assume that Magna's buddy killed Benmage, which is also unexpected to me.

And I must admit that before posting my first post, I didn't pay much attention to the timing of the flips. I am perplexed that our Day 2 lynch flipped before our Day 1 lynch. WTF?

KMD, your reads would be better if you'd posted them on Day 1. lol. I mean, I realize it's part of the process, but maybe just save it all for one chunk instead of peppering us with multiple spurts of content which may in fact be obsolete... That post seems realllllly out of place. Night time is probably the worst time to write posts, cause you never know who'll get killed at night and ruin most of your post.

[ReaperCharlie]

Vote: tubby

Am fine with a Chrono lynch too, but let's work our way up mmk?

No offense, but as said by me and others, tubby216 sounds more of an easy lynch then a best lynch.

Your defense of tubby is noted.

If he's town, this is exactly what scum wants us to do.

puuuuure WIFOM. and boy, is it tasty.

ReaperCharlie and Chronopie have a lot more backing them up as scums then tubby216. What makes you think that Chronopie/ReaperCharlie aren't the best lynches for today?

You mean, we've both been forced to claim? In your own words, why do you think either of us are scummy?

[ReaperCharlie]

But aren't we forgetting about Group Think and Lowel?

What about them?

[Starbuck]

Hello all! I missed you!

[ReaperCharlie]

I dont even know. I was banking HARD on getting that D1 flip in regards to the cult and clearing some people. Further, MoI AND Benmage dying doesn't give me those fuzzy RC feelings.

Yeah I know right? especially when my only chance to look town was to NOT kill both of them the same night. lololol dam# what a fail on my part! but at least we know that if anyone ever claims mason with Magna and they aren't counter-claimed, that we can almost 100% believe them.

THIS DOESN'T MEAN CLAIM.

DO NOT.

but yeah. if.

[Nero Cain]

But aren't we forgetting about Group Think and Lowel?

What about them?

I find them fairly scummy, especially Lowell. I'm not a big fan of this lets lynch

Chono or RC today

. I'll have to re-read Chono though.

[Kmd4390]

Smash bras, not sure what starbuck claimed, but keep in mind confirmed role isn't the same as confirmed alignment.

Reap, I hate posts that say "well I've read XX pages. Content soon". Whatever I can say later, I can say now. It's just how I roll.

Starbuck, any recent thoughts on the game? Have you been following since you died? Do you know why you were revived? Did you know before that you would be revived?

[Starbuck]

I haven't really been following along and I'm about to be V/LA while I am on vacation.
I don't know why I was revived and I didn't know that I would be revived.

If you need my claim, it's at the bottom of this post.

[ReaperCharlie]

oooh, and more importantly, was there a Waiting in the Wings quicktopic and did anyone admit to anything juicy?

[Starbuck]

Nope, no QT.

[ReaperCharlie]

Drat.

[Super Smash Bros. Fan]

Your defense of tubby is noted.

You and Chronopie will give us a lot more information to go on then tubby216. Both of your lynches will reflect heavily on other people and give us a lot more to go on in terms of connections then tubby216.

puuuuure WIFOM. and boy, is it tasty.

The reason for the supposed-WIFOM is because I have no intentions of joining tubby216's bandwagon when there are bigger fishes to fry.

You mean, we've both been forced to claim? In your own words, why do you think either of us are scummy?

Read the section about you and Chronopie. How could you possibly miss that, especially since all my opinions about you still remain.

But aren't we forgetting about Group Think and Lowel?

Definently haven't forgotten those two. As a matter of fact, my scum reads of {Chronopie, ReaperCharlie, GroupThink, Snow_Bunny, and Lowell} still remain. All five of those people I would be willing to lynch today, but I have a preference on Chronopie/ReaperCharlie.

[ReaperCharlie]

oooOOOoooo, I didn't see your giganta-post. Very nice. I'll read it tomorrow when my brain starts working again. Sleep is good.

Good night

[Ythan]

MS AND BEN ARE BOTH DEAD. GAME JUST GOT FUN.