Open 236 - Pamplona Mafia (C9++) Game Over

[Beefster]

^^Crap. I think I mixed this up with another game. tumescence was never in this game, was he?

Nope. You're thinking of another game. ~~NS

[Prox]

^^Crap. I think I mixed this up with another game. tumescence was never in this game, was he?

Nope.

[Prox]

Shotty is at L-1 I think.

[Zajnet]

I'll bring the Hammah if that's alright with y'all.

[Beefster]

UNVOTE

for the time being.

[Prox]

Wait for claim and such first.

Shotty, your NEXT post needs to be good. And probably include a claim.

[Prox]

Beefster, are you unvoting to stall quickhammer, or because you confused games?

[drmyshottyizsik]

Ok here is my case on beefster.
All he does in this game is active lurk untill this post.

Ythan- My reasons against you and Netlava are the same as the others. It was purely speculation at the time, based mostly on yabbaguy's post.
I would like to say that I'm becoming increasingly uncomfortable both with the way you've reacted to questions and answers, as well as your reasonless rolefishing.
VOTE: Ythan

First off he says that he has a case on both of them, but he doesn't. Then he admits to playing follow the leader. Then he says he doesnt like that people are asking and answering question. Here I was already HoSing him.

I already voted you and I'm moving on[/b]
I hate this because he is acting like once you vote someone you shouldn't have to back it up.

Then he active lurks and posts long fluff and quote filled post, meaning basicly nothing.

Then he gets very confused, OMGUS's me, gets confused on which game he is in again, and unvote.

Beef is
1. Active Lurking
2. Playing anti-town
3. Doesn't want people asking questions
4. Dumb
5. confused
6. OMGUS'ing this late in the game
7.Still confused.

Oh and I

Claim: Back up Doctor (nurse)

[yabbaguy]

If true:

VVDD???

[Zajnet]

I have no counterclaim.

[yabbaguy]

...well, that's pointless really. Mason trio is the only one that can definitively counterclaim. as MMMM and DD can't coexist in VV?????

Two Backup Nurses could exist. :\

Frankly, I'm inclined to believe it.

[yabbaguy]

backup nurses???

Backup Doctors.

[Zajnet]

D = doc
DD = doc + backup doc
DDD = doc + doc
DDDD = doc + doc + backup doc
DDDDD = doc + doc + doc

In no situation are there two nurses. If someone counterclaims (which theres really no reason not to because nurse isn't really that powerful), then we lynch shotty, if he flips nurse then our vig hits who CCd him.

[yabbaguy]

Right. >_<

Okay, mason trio or a backup doc is a counterclaim.

[Zajnet]

Ok, but on the off chance we do have a Mason trio, don't claim yet.

Only a nurse/backup doc should counterclaim.

[ekiM]

I'm thinking backup doc is not a tempting fakeclaim for scum because there's only about a 50% chance the setup rolled any Ds at all, and if there were none then that would become apparent sooner or later. Obviously if someone else claims to be backup doc or part of a 3-man masonry we should do what Zajent says. Otherwise, I think we don't want to lynch dr today.

I'm not counter-claiming.

Looking at other lynches...

[ekiM]

I don't think the Ythan case is good. I know what he did at the start makes little sense as town, but it also makes little sense as scum. What would scum-Ythan hope to gain from asking that question? That nobody else would notice the anti-town consequences? I don't see it.

---

Dry-Fit really has done almost nothing this game. Look at his ISO. 8 posts.

1 random vote.
4 posts about Ythan starting at post 89, after other people had asked basically all the same stuff.
Asks me "what are your stances". Says he still suspect Ythan. Asks TheFonz about the way he started the game.
Says his Fonz question is moot. Reiterates Ythan. Doesn't like dr's vote on beef (but does nothing about it).
Asks if Fonz thinks he's scum for voting him. Says he believes Ythan is trying to scumhunt.

So. He's spent most of his very few postings repeating stuff other people said already about Ythan. He made very minor questions/comments towards three other people. And he thinks his top suspect is trying to scumhunt.

UNVOTE: drmyshottyizsik
VOTE: Dry-fit

[Prox]

Ok here is my case on beefster.
All he does in this game is active lurk untill this post.

Ythan- My reasons against you and Netlava are the same as the others. It was purely speculation at the time, based mostly on yabbaguy's post.
I would like to say that I'm becoming increasingly uncomfortable both with the way you've reacted to questions and answers, as well as your reasonless rolefishing.
VOTE: Ythan

First off he says that he has a case on both of them, but he doesn't. Then he admits to playing follow the leader. Then he says he doesnt like that people are asking and answering question. Here I was already HoSing him.

I already voted you and I'm moving on[/b]
I hate this because he is acting like once you vote someone you shouldn't have to back it up.

Then he active lurks and posts long fluff and quote filled post, meaning basicly nothing.

Then he gets very confused, OMGUS's me, gets confused on which game he is in again, and unvote.

Beef is
1. Active Lurking
2. Playing anti-town
3. Doesn't want people asking questions
4. Dumb
5. confused
6. OMGUS'ing this late in the game
7.Still confused.

Oh and I

Claim: Back up Doctor (nurse)

Good job.

Thoughts when Marathon ends.

[yabbaguy]

You blew it on the quote labelling. I think that [/b]astard tag did you in.

[Prox]

There's a random line in Ekim's post...

[Alduskkel]

Nurse doesn't seem like a very good scum claim.

Unvote

.

Now I'm off to the Marathon forum.

[Alduskkel]

In case the Mod is finicky:

Unvote

.

[Ythan]

Sorry everyone, my house got hit by lightening, and I just got a new computer today.

Seems legitimate. Who would lie about something like that?

SOMEONE WHO WANTS TO LURK. Was this a serious question?

Sigh.

Can we focus on the whole scumhunting thing now?

Scummy. Everyone posting is attempting to find scum (or lying if they are scum).

Unvote
Vote: Ythan

either you are just scimming the thread or you don't want people to start really scum hunting. Yes of course we all want to know who the scum is, but not everyone is doing so, not even you.

You're a fucking dumbass, no offense.

[Prox]

Sorry everyone, my house got hit by lightening, and I just got a new computer today.

Seems legitimate. Who would lie about something like that?

SOMEONE WHO WANTS TO LURK. Was this a serious question?

Sigh.

Can we focus on the whole scumhunting thing now?

Scummy. Everyone posting is attempting to find scum (or lying if they are scum).

Unvote
Vote: Ythan

either you are just scimming the thread or you don't want people to start really scum hunting. Yes of course we all want to know who the scum is, but not everyone is doing so, not even you.

You're a fucking dumbass, no offense.

You could be a little nicer.

[Prox]

unvote

. Sorry ^^