Scummies Invitational (OVER!!!)

[Ojanen]

I dabbled a bit in skippy rereading. The news being:
myko's reaction to q21's claim D1 fits his claim. And he's still town anyway.
More doubts about Tenchi and ckd again.
Kmd is town.

[Hoopla]

Why aren't we finishing this off now? Lets just lynch Tenchi and then Incog.

[Incognito]

Tenchi needs to get in here and claim ASAP. His last two posts are making me think he's either scum or a PR. I can't see any other reason why he'd call me town when he's reached L-1 otherwise. I don't get why he didn't even claim.

Hoopla, why didn't you guard anyone on either Night?

[q21]

I imagine she wants to be certain someone's town before she risks her life for them.

[Incognito]

Well, after the Empking killing and Slicey lynching, I'd think you the claimed Vig would probably be a pretty decent person to protect.

[Hoopla]

Hoopla, why didn't you guard anyone on either Night?

There was nobody town enough to give my life for - perhaps I'm a little selfish, but why would I risk saving a possible VT for the loss of this role? Bodyguard is there to protect outed PR's, I feel, not townie towns. Besides, I was the towniest town, so it wouldn't have been worth it.

[mykonian]

now I really want tajo to claim.

there was no kill night 1. It surprised me as Q21 kindly broke my hope of drawing a doc-protection.

[Hoopla]

tajo is a jailkeeper.

[mykonian]

Tenchi needs to get in here and claim ASAP. His last two posts are making me think he's either scum or a PR. I can't see any other reason why he'd call me town when he's reached L-1 otherwise. I don't get why he didn't even claim.

Hoopla, why didn't you guard anyone on either Night?

can't we lynch incog first?

[Hoopla]

yes, he's after tenchi.

[q21]

Well, after the Empking killing and Slicey lynching, I'd think you the claimed Vig would probably be a pretty decent person to protect.

Not really. I was pretty much guaranteed to kill again that night. If she'd guarded me she could have ended up giving her life for what would essentially be a VT.

[mykonian]

a vt who shot scum night 1.

[Hoopla]

Who still could have been an SK.

[q21]

True... whatever, I'm still alive now, so... are we really going to wait for a tenchi claim?

[Hoopla]

We still have 10 days - it's not such a big deal.

[mykonian]

it's just that I promised myself not to play another game while this was going on.

and it is getting boring as tajo is a lurker and tenchi will never come back again.

Does anyone know a good joke?

[Hoopla]

Did you hear the one about the cannibal who dumped his girlfriend?

[mykonian]

no...

[q21]

*fear*

[Incognito]

Tenchi needs to get in here and claim ASAP. His last two posts are making me think he's either scum or a PR. I can't see any other reason why he'd call me town when he's reached L-1 otherwise. I don't get why he didn't even claim.

Hoopla, why didn't you guard anyone on either Night?

can't we lynch incog first?

I've pretty much had you on ignore mode for awhile now but amuse me. What exactly is scummy about what I said there?

[mykonian]

yeah, if you are town, we absolutely didn't work well together. Last game with you was definately better then this one. Anyway.

The uselessness of the post. It doesn't really matter if tenchi is a pr. Further, the question posed for hoopla is for the sake of asking a question: you won't ever deduce from that if someone is scum or not. You would already have, or you are assuming she is town at this point. The answer will only reinforce what you were already thinking. Plus that it won't actually matter, as hoopla will be lynched early enough to never win the game as scum.

[Incognito]

Admittedly, this hasn't been one of my best games. But I don't think I've played awful here either. I think I'm just bad with Large Games in general which is why I usually avoid them like the plague. I just have a hard time focusing on so many people at once. Maybe that's why we haven't been working well together here, idk.

As for my question, I just was curious as to what her response would be. I could see why Hoopla might be hesitant to Guard someone like q21 on Night 1 but on Night 2 after everything else that happened in-thread and it really really really began to look like q21 stood an even stronger chance of being town as opposed to SK? Not so much. I don't think she's scum for it, but I just wanted to get a feel for her thought process anyway. Maybe it really WILL have no bearing on this game but hey, maybe her answer could potentially help me in future games that I'm in with Hoopla.

And it might not matter to you if Tenchi claims a PR but it matters to me. I like winning games with as few town casualties as possible. And I hate hate hate being mislynched. Put those two together and maybe you'll better see where I'm coming from. I like having all information on the table particularly in situations like this so that we could win the game with the greatest number that we possibly can instead of a bunch of useless deaths.

[Kmd4390]

tajo is a jailkeeper.

Huh?

No, he's a watcher or tracker.

[Hoopla]

what are you, kmd?

[Hoopla]

what are you, kmd?

wait, no. you claimed vt. never mind.